You’ve seen it. I’ve seen it. Your dad has probably quoted the "flesh wound" line until your ears bled. But when we talk about Monty Python and the Holy Grail, we usually focus on the coconuts or the killer rabbit. We forget that the whole thing almost fell apart because of how the troupe actually worked behind the scenes. Especially John Cleese.
People think of Cleese as the "star" because he’s the tallest and loudest. Honestly, he was often the one most ready to walk away. By the time they started filming in 1974, Cleese was already feeling the itch to do something else. He was tired of the "sketch" format. He wanted structure. He wanted something like Fawlty Towers, which was bubbling in his brain at the time.
Yet, without his specific brand of aggressive, high-status lunacy, the movie would be half as funny.
The John Cleese Effect: High Status Meets Pure Chaos
In Monty Python and the Holy Grail John Cleese plays several roles, but they all share a specific "Cleese-ian" DNA. Think about Sir Lancelot. In any other movie, Lancelot is the hero. In Cleese’s hands, he’s a homicidal maniac who mistakes a wedding for a battle cry. He’s not just "silly." He’s terrifyingly committed.
That’s the secret.
Cleese doesn’t play the jokes; he plays the intensity. When he’s Tim the Enchanter, he’s not trying to be a funny wizard. He’s a man genuinely concerned about a rabbit with a "vicious streak a mile wide." The humor comes from that massive gap between his dead-serious delivery and the fact that he’s wearing ram horns and shooting fire from his fingers.
Why the Black Knight is his Masterpiece
We have to talk about the Black Knight. It’s the scene everyone knows.
Cleese’s inspiration for this didn't come from a joke book. It came from a story his school teacher told him about two Roman wrestlers. One guy was so tough he wouldn't tap out even when his limbs were snapping. He actually died before he gave up.
Cleese thought that was hilarious.
It’s a perfect example of his "never-say-die" comedy style. Even when he’s just a torso on the ground, yelling "I’ll bite your legs off!", he’s playing it as a man who genuinely believes he’s winning. He once mentioned in an interview that he had a small precancerous growth removed from his arm, and when the doctor finished, the guy actually said, "’Tis but a scratch." That’s the level of cultural saturation we’re dealing with.
The Production Was a Total Disaster
Don’t let the "classic" status fool you. Making this movie was miserable.
They had no money. They were funded by rock stars like Pink Floyd and Led Zeppelin because the big studios wouldn't touch them. The budget was so tight—around £175,000—that they couldn't afford real horses.
That’s where the coconuts came from.
It wasn't a creative "choice" at first. It was a desperate "we can't afford a stable" reality. Michael Palin usually gets the credit for the idea, but it was Cleese and the others who turned it into a running gag about swallows and weight ratios.
Directing Tension
The two Terrys—Gilliam and Jones—co-directed. It was a mess.
Gilliam cared about how things looked. He wanted the mud to look like real medieval mud. Jones wanted the jokes to land. Cleese, meanwhile, was stuck on a freezing hillside in Scotland, wearing a wool tunic that weighed 50 pounds when it got wet. He wasn't exactly having the time of his life.
In fact, the "Them vs. Us" divide between the actors and the directors was real. Cleese has been open about how much he hated some of the takes. There’s a famous bit in the witch scene where he pauses for an eternity. Eric Idle is in the background, literally biting his scythe to keep from laughing. Cleese wasn't doing it just to be funny; he was messing with the timing to see how far he could push it.
✨ Don't miss: Why Pharrell Williams Songs Still Own the Radio (And Your Playlists)
The Roles You Forgot He Played
Everyone remembers Lancelot. Everyone knows the French Taunter. But Cleese is all over this movie in ways you might not realize:
- The Black Knight: Obviously.
- The French Taunter: The guy who "farts in your general direction."
- Tim the Enchanter: With the Scottish accent that Cleese mostly did because it sounded "mystical."
- Sir Launcelot the Brave: The guy who kills the dragon (sort of).
- The Peasant: In the "she turned me into a newt" scene.
That peasant role is actually vital. It shows Cleese’s range. Usually, he’s the "loud authority figure" (think the French Taunter). But as the peasant, he’s a sheepish, low-status coward who has to admit "I got better."
Why the Ending Still Annoys People
If you’ve ever watched the movie and thought, "Wait, that’s it?", you aren't alone.
The film ends with the modern-day police showing up and arresting everyone. It’s a total cop-out. Literally.
Cleese has gone on record saying they ended it that way because they ran out of money for a big battle scene. They couldn't afford the extras, the armor, or the horses (again). So they just had a guy in a police car drive into the frame and shut down the production. It’s the ultimate "meta" joke, but for Cleese, it was partly a result of the chaotic writing process where 90% of the first draft was tossed out.
How to Watch it Like an Expert
If you want to truly appreciate the Monty Python and the Holy Grail John Cleese performance, you have to look past the subtitles and the songs.
Watch the eyes. Cleese has this specific wild-eyed stare when he’s playing the French Taunter. He’s looking at the camera but also through it. He’s mocking the very idea of a "brave knight."
Also, look for the "Basil Fawlty" energy. Fawlty Towers premiered the same year as Holy Grail (1975). You can see the overlap. The way he gets frustrated with the "bloody peasants" is the exact same energy he brings to a hotel guest asking for a Waldorf salad.
Actionable Insights for Fans
To get the most out of your next rewatch, try these three things:
📖 Related: Why the Wicked the Musical Soundtrack Still Hits Different After Two Decades
- Ignore the foreground: In the "Witch Trial" scene, watch John Cleese’s face while the other villagers are talking. His "expert" nodding is a masterclass in background acting.
- Listen for the "Middle-Class" voice: Cleese and the other Pythons were mostly highly educated Oxford and Cambridge grads. A lot of their humor comes from putting polite, middle-class British arguments into the mouths of filthy 10th-century peasants.
- Check the "Double-Up": Since they played multiple roles, look for scenes where Cleese’s characters interact with other characters played by the same person. It’s a miracle of editing for 1975.
The movie works because it’s smart enough to be incredibly stupid. Cleese provided the "smart" structure—the sharp, biting dialogue—and then performed it with the "stupid" energy of a man who just wants to throw a cow off a rampart.
Next time you hear someone shout "Ni!", remember that behind that silly voice was a group of men who were genuinely cold, tired, and broke, just trying to make each other laugh so they wouldn't go crazy in the Scottish rain.