You’ve probably seen the memes. One is a guy in white spandex who talks to an Egyptian moon god; the other is a guy in red spandex who talks to you, the reader. On the surface, they look like two flavors of the same brand of "Marvel crazy." But if you actually put them in a room together, it isn't a comedy routine. It's a bloodbath.
The Time Moon Knight Actually Won
Back in 2010, Marvel gave us the answer to the Moon Knight vs Deadpool debate in the pages of Vengeance of the Moon Knight #7-8. Written by Gregg Hurwitz, this story finds Marc Spector in a weird place. He’s trying to be a "hero." He’s sworn off killing. He’s basically trying to be Batman with a heavier therapy bill.
Then Wade Wilson shows up.
Deadpool was hired to assassinate a mob boss named Herman Goncharenko. Moon Knight, committed to his new "no-kill" rule, steps in to protect the guy. They square off in a carnival’s hall of mirrors, which is honestly the most on-the-nose setting for two guys with fractured psyches.
Wade starts doing what Wade does: he talks. He mocks Marc for his newfound morality. He calls him soft. Then, Deadpool makes a tactical error. He brags about his healing factor. He explains to Moon Knight that he literally cannot die, thinking this makes him superior.
✨ Don't miss: Jonas Brothers We Got the Party: What Most People Get Wrong
It had the opposite effect.
Since Moon Knight knew he couldn't actually kill Deadpool, he realized he didn't have to hold back. He stopped pulled his punches. He stopped worrying about internal bleeding or broken bones. Marc Spector absolutely mauled him. He sliced Wade up so badly that the Merc with a Mouth ended up in a hospital bed with two IV bags just to keep his body from shutting down while it knit itself back together.
Moon Knight won that round. Easily.
👉 See also: Why Emperor I Am the Black Wizards Still Defines Black Metal Three Decades Later
Why the Fight is More Complicated Than a Healing Factor
If you ask a casual fan who wins, they usually say Deadpool. "He can't die, right?" Sure. But "not dying" isn't the same thing as "winning a fight." You can be immortal and still be a puddle of meat on the floor.
Honestly, the power dynamics here are fascinating.
- Pain Tolerance: Moon Knight is famous for not wearing armor on his face because he wants his enemies to see him coming. He takes hits he should probably dodge just to get a counter-strike in. Deadpool, meanwhile, uses his healing factor as a crue. He’s sloppy because he knows he’ll be fine in twenty minutes.
- The Taskmaster Factor: This is the best way to understand their skill levels. Taskmaster can copy almost anyone’s fighting style. But he hates fighting Moon Knight because Marc would rather take a punch to land a punch—it’s "suicidal" logic. He also struggles with Deadpool because Wade is too chaotic to predict. Both are "unpredictable," but for totally different reasons.
- Gear: Moon Knight usually carries Carbonadium equipment. For those who aren't deep in the lore, Carbonadium is a budget version of Adamantium that actually slows down healing factors. If Marc brings the right crescent darts to the party, Wade's primary advantage starts to lag.
The Mental Game: Who Is Actually Crazier?
There's a common misconception that these two would be best friends. They wouldn't. Moon Knight generally finds Deadpool annoying and unprofessional. Marc’s "madness" is heavy, somber, and tied to trauma and religious servitude. Wade’s "madness" is a Fourth Wall-breaking nihilistic joke.
In the comics, Moon Knight is a former mercenary with a lot of blood on his hands. He’s a guy trying to outrun his past. Deadpool is a guy who has embraced the fact that nothing matters because he’s a fictional character.
That difference shows up in how they fight. Moon Knight fights with the precision of a US Marine and the brutality of a street brawler. Deadpool fights like a Looney Tunes character with a Glock.
Could Deadpool Win a Rematch?
Yes. Probably.
If we’re talking about a war of attrition, Wade Wilson eventually wins because he doesn't stay down. In a "to the death" match, Deadpool is the only one who can actually fulfill the criteria. Moon Knight can be revived by Khonshu, but it’s not an automatic biological process like Wade’s. It requires a god’s whim.
However, in a standard "who is the better combatant" scenario, Marc Spector has the edge. He is more disciplined. He is arguably more vicious when the gloves come off. He has a higher floor for skill, whereas Deadpool's effectiveness varies wildly depending on how much he's joking around that day.
Actionable Insights for Comic Fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into this rivalry or want to settle a debate at the local comic shop, keep these specific points in mind:
- Read the Source Material: Check out Vengeance of the Moon Knight #8. It’s the definitive encounter.
- Watch the Healing Factor: Remember that incapacitation counts as a win. If someone is chopped into pieces and put in separate boxes, they lost the fight, even if they're still "alive."
- Check the Version: MCU Moon Knight (Steven/Marc) is a very different beast from the 2010 "Batman-era" Moon Knight. The comic version is much more of a tactical powerhouse.
- Context Matters: Most heroes in the Marvel Universe actually avoid Deadpool. If you're writing or debating a crossover, remember that Moon Knight would likely view Wade as a liability, not a partner.
At the end of the day, Moon Knight proved that having a superpower like immortality is a double-edged sword. It just gives your opponent a reason to be as brutal as they've always wanted to be. For a guy like Marc Spector, who spends every day fighting the urge to tear people apart, Deadpool is the ultimate punching bag.