The Divisional Round is where fantasy seasons go to die. Or, if you’re smart, where they’re reborn. Honestly, most managers are still playing by the same rules they used in Week 4, but that’s a massive mistake. The 2026 playoff landscape has shifted so violently in the last 48 hours that your old spreadsheets are basically coasters now. Between the soul-crushing George Kittle news and the Nico Collins concussion drama, the math has changed.
NFL fantasy start 'em sit 'em decisions are no longer about "who is the best player." They’re about who is actually left standing and which offenses aren't currently held together by duct tape and prayers.
The Stafford Finger and the Rams' High-Wire Act
Let’s talk about Matthew Stafford. He banged his index finger against a helmet late in the Wild Card win, and while he finished the game, that’s the kind of thing that makes a quarterback’s deep ball look like a wounded duck. The Rams are double-digit favorites against Carolina, but if Stafford can’t grip the laces, that Rams passing attack becomes a lot less scary.
You’re starting Puka Nacua regardless. You just are. He’s the WR1 on almost every board for a reason. He’s crushing Cover-3 looks, and Carolina runs that more than almost anyone. But Davante Adams? That’s where it gets sticky. Adams is coming back from a hamstring issue. In the 13 games they’ve played together, Nacua has commanded a 37% first-read target share compared to Adams’ 26%. If Stafford is limited, he’s going to look for his safety blanket. That’s Puka. Adams is a "start" because of his absurd red-zone usage—27 end-zone targets this year—but don't be shocked if the yardage isn't there.
Then there’s the backfield. Kyren Williams and Blake Corum have been in a 60/40 split for over two months. Williams still gets the high-value touches inside the 10-yard line, but Corum is the one fresh enough to break a 40-yarder. If you're in a DFS format, Corum is the ultimate "sit" that everyone is actually going to "start" as a sleeper, which kind of defeats the purpose, doesn't it?
📖 Related: Why Arvada Skatepark in Arvada CO is Still the King of Colorado Concrete
The Tight End Wasteland Just Got Worse
If you had George Kittle, I’m sorry. Truly. News broke Tuesday that he’s undergoing season-ending Achilles surgery. It’s a brutal blow for a San Francisco team that’s already an underdog against the Eagles. Without Kittle, that offense loses its most versatile blocker and its most reliable middle-of-the-field threat.
So, what do you do?
- Colston Loveland is the name everyone is circling. The Bears-Packers game is a literal coin flip, and Loveland has been a zone-beater all year.
- Dalton Kincaid is essentially a wide receiver at this point for Josh Allen.
- Colby Parkinson just saved the Rams' season with a 19-yard score. He’s the "chasing points" play, but with Kittle out, the bar for a "start" at tight end is in the basement.
Honestly, unless you have one of those top three, you're better off punting the position and hoping for a random touchdown. Safe doesn't win playoff leagues. Variance does.
Why NFL Fantasy Start 'Em Sit 'Em Strategy Changes in the Cold
The Texans are heading to New England to face MVP-favorite Drake Maye and a Patriots defense that looks like a brick wall. This is a nightmare for Woody Marks. Look, I know he gets 17+ touches a game. I know he’s the "lead back." But he’s averaging 3.59 yards per carry. That’s 48th out of 49 qualifying backs.
The Steelers just held opponents to 73 rushing yards per game over the final month. If Houston thinks they can just run Marks into the teeth of that New England front, they’re in for a long day. If Nico Collins doesn't clear the concussion protocol—and remember, this is his second one this season—the Texans' offense might just evaporate. You’re sitting Marks. You’re probably sitting most Texans pass-catchers not named Tank Dell if Nico is out.
On the flip side, the Patriots' offense is finally fun? Drake Maye is playing better than any QB in the AFC right now. He’s a "start" in every format. He’s mobile, he’s aggressive, and he’s finally got TreVeyon Henderson and Rhamondre Stevenson healthy at the same time. That New England stack is the secret sauce for the Divisional Round.
The Josh Allen Experience
You don't sit Josh Allen. Ever. He leads the league in fantasy points when the game total is over 45.5. The Bills-Jags game is sitting at a 51.5 over/under. It’s going to be a shootout.
But here’s the wrinkle: James Cook.
Cook is the RB1 in many rankings, but the Bills just lost Tyrell Shavers to a torn ACL. That thins out the receiving corps even more. Expect Buffalo to lean on the ground game and Allen’s legs. If you’re looking for a "sit" that might surprise people, it’s actually the secondary Buffalo receivers like Khalil Shakir. The volume just isn’t consistent enough when Allen decides he’s going to do it all himself.
Actionable Next Steps for Your Lineup
Stop looking at season-long stats. They're lying to you. A player’s Week 4 performance against a bad defense doesn't matter when they're playing in 20-degree weather against a top-five unit.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Denver Broncos 2015 Schedule Was a Brutal Masterclass in Survival
- Check the Nico Collins status Friday. If he's out, move Tank Dell up to a high-end WR2 and downgrade C.J. Stroud to a low-end QB1.
- Monitor Matthew Stafford’s practice reports. If he’s limited or "DNP" with that finger, the Rams' offensive ceiling drops significantly.
- Aggressively target the Eagles' pass-catchers. San Francisco is missing linebackers and now their best defensive weapon in Kittle (mentally and physically). A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith are primed for monster games.
- Don't overthink the "Safe" play. In playoff fantasy, a 0 is the same as a 5. You need the 25-point ceiling. Start the guy with the high-variance matchup, not the guy who "should" get you 8 points.
The playoffs aren't about being right 100% of the time. They're about being right when it matters. If you're still holding onto names like Christian McCaffrey as "must-starts" despite him being a 4.5-point underdog with a struggling QB, you might want to rethink your process. The board is wide open. Use the chaos to your advantage.