College football is basically a religion in the Midwest. If you’ve ever stood on the sidelines in South Bend or felt the concrete vibrate under your feet in Columbus, you know that Notre Dame vs Ohio State isn't just another game on the schedule. It's a collision of two massive, distinct identities. On one side, you have the golden-domed independent traditionalists who view themselves as the moral compass of the sport. On the other, the scarlet and gray juggernaut of the Big Ten, a program built on the singular, relentless pursuit of national titles.
They don't play often. That's the weird part. For two schools separated by roughly 250 miles of flat highway, you'd think they'd be at each other's throats every October. Instead, we’ve only seen a handful of meetings across more than a century. This scarcity makes every matchup feel like an atmospheric event. When they finally do meet, the stakes are almost always astronomical.
The Weight of History and Those Recent Heartbreakers
Honestly, if you're a Notre Dame fan, the mention of the Buckeyes probably triggers a specific kind of internal wince. The recent home-and-home series in 2022 and 2023 was supposed to be the moment Marcus Freeman—a former Ohio State linebacker himself—proved the Irish had finally closed the gap.
It didn't quite go to plan.
In 2022, the Irish went into the Shoe and actually held a lead in the third quarter. People were shocked. The defense looked elite. But then, the depth of Ohio State’s roster just started grinding them down. Ryan Day’s squad eventually pulled away for a 21-10 win. It was respectable for ND, sure, but a loss is a loss.
Then came the 2023 rematch. This one was personal.
The image of Ohio State’s Chip Trayanum plunging into the end zone with literally one second left on the clock still haunts South Bend. It was a 17-14 final that felt much louder than the score suggested. The post-game drama was even wilder, with Ryan Day calling out Lou Holtz on national television. That’s the kind of raw, unfiltered emotion you only get when these two brands collide. It’s not just about a win-loss record; it's about respect and the perceived toughness of the "Midwestern" style of play.
Breaking Down the "Toughness" Narrative
People talk a lot about "Ohio State vs Notre Dame" as a battle for the soul of the region. Ohio State is often viewed as the blue-collar, "three yards and a cloud of dust" (at least historically) powerhouse, while Notre Dame is seen as the "academic elite" who play a national schedule.
But look at the recruiting numbers.
👉 See also: Is Shannon Sharpe Still on First Take? What Really Happened
Ohio State consistently brings in top-five classes. They have a pipeline from Florida, Texas, and California that most schools would die for. Notre Dame, because of their independent status and strict admission standards, has to work twice as hard to get that same level of depth. This creates a fascinating dynamic on the field. The Irish often have a starting eleven that can hang with anyone, but when injuries mount or the game enters the fourth quarter, the Buckeyes’ sheer volume of four and five-star athletes usually takes over.
The Marcus Freeman Factor
You can't talk about this matchup without mentioning Marcus Freeman. He’s the bridge between the two programs. He played at Ohio State under Jim Tressel. He knows exactly what the "Buckeye Way" looks like. Since taking over at Notre Dame, he’s tried to instill that same level of aggression and physical dominance.
Some analysts argue that Freeman is trying to turn Notre Dame into "Ohio State Lite." Whether that's fair or not, the results on the field show a team that is much more comfortable in a fistfight than they were under Brian Kelly. The 2023 game showed a Notre Dame defense that could actually limit an explosive OSU offense, something we hadn't seen in years.
The Recruiting War in the Midwest
While the games are rare, the battle on the recruiting trail is constant. Both schools consider the state of Ohio their backyard. If there’s a five-star defensive end in Cincinnati or a lightning-fast receiver in Cleveland, you can bet both coaching staffs are on his doorstep.
- Ohio State’s Strategy: They sell the "NFL Factory" aspect. If you want to be a first-round pick and play for a team that is a lock for the College Football Playoff, you go to Columbus.
- Notre Dame’s Pitch: It’s about the "40-year decision." They sell the degree, the global brand, and the chance to be a legend in a way that transcends the NFL.
This creates a lot of friction. When a kid flips from one to the other, it’s big news. It’s not just a roster move; it’s a rejection of one philosophy for another. This off-field tension feeds the atmosphere whenever the Notre Dame vs Ohio State game finally rolls around on the calendar.
What Most People Get Wrong About This Series
A lot of casual fans think Ohio State has always dominated. While the Buckeyes have certainly had the upper hand recently, the historical context is more nuanced. Early on, Notre Dame was the gold standard.
The 1935 game is still cited by historians as one of the "Games of the Century." Notre Dame came back in the final minutes to win 18-13 in front of a record crowd at Ohio Stadium. It was so impactful that some sportswriters at the time claimed it helped solidify college football as a premier national sport, moving it out of the shadow of baseball.
🔗 Read more: Mike Brown: Why the Kings Head Coach is the Only Choice for Sacramento Right Now
We also have to look at the bowl games. The 2006 Fiesta Bowl and 2016 Fiesta Bowl were both Ohio State victories, and they weren't particularly close. Those games created the narrative that Notre Dame couldn't handle the speed of a top-tier Big Ten or SEC opponent. Fair or not, that's the mountain the Irish are still trying to climb.
The Future: Will We See This More Often?
With the expansion of the College Football Playoff to 12 teams (and likely more in the future), the risk-reward calculation for scheduling big non-conference games has changed. In the old four-team system, a loss in a game like Notre Dame vs Ohio State could end your season in September.
Now? A "quality loss" in a high-profile game might actually help your seeding if you run the rest of the table.
There is a lot of talk about Notre Dame eventually joining a conference. If they ever land in the Big Ten, this would become an annual tradition. Imagine this game every November. The ratings would be astronomical. However, the Irish value their independence like a holy relic. Until that changes, we’re stuck waiting for these rare, scheduled bursts of brilliance.
Key Factors for the Next Matchup
When these two inevitably meet again, watch the trenches. Ohio State has shifted toward a more pass-heavy, high-finesse offense in recent years, though they’ve tried to reclaim their physical identity under Ryan Day. Notre Dame, meanwhile, has doubled down on offensive line development.
The game is usually won or lost on whether the ND offensive line can protect their quarterback long enough to exploit the OSU secondary. Conversely, if Ohio State's defensive front gets into the backfield early, it tends to be a long night for the Irish.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Analysts
If you are tracking the progress of these programs or betting on future matchups, keep these specific metrics in mind:
- Blue-Chip Ratio: Track the percentage of four and five-star recruits on each roster. Currently, Ohio State maintains a significant lead here, which usually manifests in the fourth quarter.
- Transfer Portal Efficiency: Both schools have started using the portal aggressively. Note how many starters were "homegrown" versus transfers; it tells you a lot about the current health of the program's development pipeline.
- Third-Down Conversion Rates: In their recent meetings, the difference was almost always a failure by Notre Dame to stay on the field in high-pressure situations.
- Strength of Schedule: Look at who they play the week before they face each other. Ohio State often has the luxury of a "tune-up" game against a lower-tier Big Ten opponent, whereas Notre Dame's independent schedule can be a gauntlet of travel.
The rivalry is a measuring stick. For Ohio State, it’s a chance to prove they are the kings of the North. For Notre Dame, it’s the ultimate opportunity to silence the "overrated" chants that have followed them for decades. Whether you're wearing green or scarlet, you have to admit: college football is just better when these two are on the field together. It’s loud, it’s messy, and it’s exactly what the sport should be.