So, you’re looking at that New York City ballot and thinking, "Wait, why am I picking five people for one job?" Honestly, it’s a fair question. New York changed the game a few years back, and if you haven’t kept up, the whole thing feels like a math homework assignment you didn’t study for.
Basically, the how does the nyc mayoral election work question boils down to two big phases: the messy primary and the slightly-less-messy general election. But the real star (or villain, depending on who you ask) is Ranked Choice Voting (RCV). It’s the reason why "winning" in NYC doesn't always mean getting the most votes on night one.
The Primary: Where the Real Fight Is
In a city that's overwhelmingly blue, the Democratic primary is usually where the next mayor is actually picked. But since 2021, we don't just "pick one."
New York uses a "closed" primary. This means if you aren't registered with a specific party—say, the Democrats or the Republicans—you’re sitting on the sidelines until November. You've got to pick a side by February of the election year if you want a say in who the parties nominate.
✨ Don't miss: Why the United States Institute of Peace in Washington DC Is Actually Worth Your Time
How Ranked Choice Voting (RCV) Actually Works
Imagine you're at a pizza shop. You want pepperoni. They're out. If this was a normal election, you’d just go hungry. In RCV, you say, "Okay, if no pepperoni, I’ll take mushroom. If no mushroom, I’ll take plain."
On your ballot, you get to rank up to five candidates.
- The First Count: Everybody’s #1 choice is counted. If someone gets more than 50% right away? Game over. They win.
- The Elimination: If nobody hits 50%, the person in last place is kicked out.
- The Redistribution: If you voted for that last-place person as your #1, your vote isn't wasted. It "moves" to whoever you put as your #2.
- The Loop: This keeps happening—bottom person out, votes move—until only two people are left. The one with the most votes then becomes the nominee.
It sounds complicated, but it’s mostly just a computer doing the heavy lifting while we all wait weeks for the official results.
Money, Money, Money (The Matching Funds)
You can't talk about how does the nyc mayoral election work without talking about the "8-to-1" match. This is New York’s way of trying to stop billionaires from just buying City Hall.
🔗 Read more: DHS Secretary Kristi Noem: What Really Happened During Her First Year
If a regular New Yorker (not a lobbyist or someone doing business with the city) gives a candidate $10, the city "matches" it with $80 of public money. This turns a small $250 donation into $2,250. It’s why you see so many candidates spending their time at small house parties in Queens instead of just hitting up Wall Street.
Candidates have to jump through hoops to get this money. They need to raise a minimum amount from at least 1,000 different NYC residents. If they take the public cash, they also have to agree to a "spending limit." They can't just drop $50 million on TV ads unless they want to forfeit the match.
The General Election: A Different Beast
Once the primaries are over in June, we head to November. Here’s the kicker: Ranked Choice Voting is NOT used in the general election.
Yeah, you read that right.
In the November general election, it’s back to the old-school "choose one and pray" method. The winner is whoever gets the most votes (a plurality). It doesn't matter if they only get 35% because the rest of the vote was split between three other people—if they have the most, they’re the Mayor.
Term Limits: The Eight-Year Wall
Mayors in NYC can only serve two consecutive four-year terms. That’s it. They can technically sit out for four years and come back later (like a political "refresh" button), but they can't stay for 12 years straight.
Registration and Deadlines
You can't participate if you aren't in the system. To vote in New York, you need to be:
- A U.S. citizen.
- A resident of NYC for at least 30 days.
- 18 years old by Election Day.
The deadlines are usually pretty strict. For the 2026 cycle, for example, if you want to vote in the June primary, you’ve got to be registered by mid-June, but if you're switching parties, you need to have that paperwork in by February 14th.
Why Results Take So Long
Back in the day, we knew who won by 11:00 PM on election night. Now? Not a chance.
Because of the RCV rounds and the massive influx of mail-in ballots (absentee ballots), the Board of Elections usually takes a few weeks to "run the numbers." They have to wait for every legal ballot to arrive by mail, verify the signatures, and then start the elimination rounds.
It’s a test of patience.
Actionable Steps for New York Voters
If you want to make sure your voice actually counts in the next cycle, don't just show up on Tuesday and hope for the best.
- Check your registration status right now on the NYC Board of Elections website. If you moved, your old registration is useless.
- Decide on a party affiliation before February 14th if you want to vote in the primary. If you’re "Independent," you won't get a ballot for the June mayoral race.
- Research all five slots. Don’t just pick one person and leave the rest blank. Ranking other people as your #2 or #3 never hurts your #1 choice; it only gives you a backup plan if your favorite loses.
- Look into the "Doing Business" list. If you work for a company that has contracts with the city, your donation limits are much lower, and your money won't be matched.
The system is built to favor the most "likable" candidate—the one who can be everyone’s second choice if they can’t be their first. Understanding that is the key to figuring out who's actually going to end up in Gracie Mansion.