Honestly, if you ask a casual fan about the history of Ohio State vs Tennessee, they’ll probably tell you it’s some storied, back-and-forth rivalry. It feels like it should be, right? Two massive programs, stadiums that hold over 100,000 people, and fanbases that treat Saturday like a religious holiday.
But here is the weird part. Until very recently, these two titans basically lived in parallel universes. They were like two ships passing in the night—one in the Big Ten and one in the SEC—hardly ever actually touching.
That all changed in late 2024. Before that, you had to go all the way back to the Clinton administration to find a game between them. We’re talking 1996. For nearly 30 years, the only thing connecting Columbus and Knoxville was a shared hatred for a certain team up north (Michigan for the Buckeyes, and well, everyone for the Vols).
🔗 Read more: Por qué ver un partido del Manchester United hoy es una montaña rusa emocional total
The 2024 Playoff Collision That Changed Everything
When the College Football Playoff expanded to 12 teams, we all knew we were going to get some "brand name" matchups we weren't used to. We just didn't expect Ohio State vs Tennessee to feel quite this lopsided when it finally happened on December 21, 2024.
It was the first round. A cold night in Columbus.
Tennessee came in as the No. 9 seed, making their first-ever CFP appearance. The hype was unreal. Josh Heupel had the Vols humming, and Nico Iamaleava was supposed to be the dual-threat nightmare that would keep Jim Knowles awake at night.
Ohio State, sitting at No. 8, was playing with a massive chip on its shoulder. They had just lost to Michigan (again) and the fan noise was reaching a deafening pitch. Ryan Day needed a win like he needed oxygen.
The Buckeyes didn’t just win. They dismantled them. Ohio State 42, Tennessee 17.
The first quarter was a blur of Scarlet and Gray. Jeremiah Smith—the freshman who everyone said was "too good to be true"—was very much true. He caught a 37-yard touchdown pass from Will Howard within the first three minutes. By the time the first quarter ended, it was 21-0. Tennessee looked like they’d stepped off the plane and directly into a snow globe they weren't prepared for.
Iamaleava showed flashes of why he's a star, especially with those two rushing touchdowns, but he was under siege. The Buckeyes’ defensive front, led by guys like Jack Sawyer and J.T. Tuimoloau, lived in the Vols' backfield. It was a reality check for a Tennessee team that had survived the SEC gauntlet but couldn't find an answer for the sheer depth Ohio State had accumulated.
Why the 1996 Citrus Bowl Still Matters to Old-Timers
Before the 2024 blowout, the "rivalry" was defined by a single rainy afternoon in Orlando. January 1, 1996.
If you talk to an older Ohio State fan, they still get a twitch in their eye when you mention this game. The Buckeyes were 11-1. They had Eddie George, the Heisman winner. They had Orlando Pace. They were, by almost every metric, the best team in the country that didn't play for the national title.
Tennessee had a guy named Peyton Manning. Maybe you've heard of him?
The Vols won that game 20-14. It was a muddy, ugly affair. Eddie George was held to under 100 yards, which was unheard of at the time. Tennessee's defense stuffed him on a crucial fourth-and-short near the goal line. That single play basically became the "I told you so" for SEC fans for the next three decades.
It’s funny how a game from 1996 can influence how people view a matchup in 2026. For years, Tennessee fans held onto that 1-0 lead in the series as proof of SEC dominance. Ohio State fans, meanwhile, viewed it as a fluke—a "Cooper-era" bowl collapse that didn't reflect the true status of the programs.
The Tale of the Tape: Compare and Contrast
If you look at the programs side-by-side, it's actually pretty wild how similar they are in stature but how different they are in results over the last twenty years.
- Total Wins: Ohio State is a top-three program all-time. They’ve passed the 990-win mark and are barreling toward 1,000. Tennessee is no slouch, sitting in the top 15 with over 880 wins, but they hit a massive speed bump in the 2010s that they’re only now fully recovering from.
- National Titles: Tennessee fans will point to 1998. It was a magical run with Tee Martin. Ohio State fans will counter with 2002, 2014, and the recent 2024-25 run.
- The Heisman Factor: This is the ultimate "bragging right" for Columbus. Seven Heismans (counting Archie Griffin twice). Tennessee? Zero. It’s a sore spot in Knoxville, especially considering Peyton Manning was famously "snubbed" for Charles Woodson in 1997.
The 2024 game effectively leveled the head-to-head series at 1-1. It also proved that when these two schools meet, the "style of play" argument is usually a myth. People say the SEC is faster and the Big Ten is more "three yards and a cloud of dust."
Nonsense.
In their last meeting, Ohio State was the faster team. They used a high-tempo, modern spread that looked more "SEC" than what Tennessee was running. Meanwhile, the Vols tried to lean on a power run game with Peyton Lewis and Dylan Sampson that felt very old-school Midwest.
What to Watch for in the 2026 Landscape
So, where does Ohio State vs Tennessee go from here? We are currently in an era where these teams are likely to see each other more often. With the 12-team playoff (and talks of 14 or 16), the chances of a Round 1 or Quarterfinal matchup are incredibly high every single year.
💡 You might also like: Badger Basketball Score Today: Why Wisconsin Nearly Blew a 26-Point Lead
The "talent gap" that existed for a few years is closing. Josh Heupel has turned Tennessee into a recruiting juggernaut again. They are consistently landing five-star talent that used to automatically go to Alabama or Georgia.
Ohio State is... well, they're Ohio State. They are the only program in the country that has stayed consistently at the top for the better part of 75 years without a major "down" period.
But there’s a new variable: the Big Ten is now a coast-to-coast conference. Ohio State is playing Oregon, USC, and Washington regularly. Tennessee is dealing with a Texas and Oklahoma-infused SEC. Both teams are more battle-tested than ever before they even hit the postseason.
The Recruiting War for the South
You can't talk about these two without talking about the "raiding" of the South. Ohio State has made a living recently by going into Georgia, Florida, and even Tennessee to grab players.
When Ohio State lands a kid from Nashville or Memphis, it burns the Vols.
Conversely, Tennessee is starting to push back. They are looking at the Midwest and saying, "Why not us?" They want those big, physical linemen from Ohio and Michigan to bolster their defensive front. This off-field battle is what actually makes the on-field Ohio State vs Tennessee matchup so spicy. It’s not just a game; it’s a business trip for the coaches to prove whose "brand" is more valuable to a 17-year-old kid.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Bettors
If you’re looking at a future matchup between these two, stop looking at "conference prestige" and start looking at specific position groups.
🔗 Read more: Swiss Hockey Players in the NHL: Why the Tiny Alpine Nation is Now a Powerhouse
- The Quarterback Depth: Both schools have moved toward a "transfer portal plus blue-chip" model. If one team is starting a freshman, the other team's veteran defensive coordinator will exploit it, as we saw with Jim Knowles vs Nico Iamaleava in late 2024.
- Weather Matters (But Not Why You Think): People thought the cold in Columbus would kill Tennessee. It didn't. The Vols handle cold fine. What killed them was the speed on the turf. Fast, dry tracks favor the Buckeyes' wide receiver room, which is arguably the best in NFL-feeder history.
- Historical Trends are Dead: Don't bet based on what happened in the 90s. The 2024 game proved that the "SEC speed" narrative is outdated. Modern Big Ten teams are built for track meets.
- Watch the Trenches: In the last meeting, Ohio State had 4 sacks and 8 tackles for loss. Tennessee had zero sacks. Until the Vols can protect the QB against elite Big Ten edges, the scoreboards will stay lopsided.
The next time these two meet, expect a much closer game. Tennessee has learned the hard way what it takes to play in the new playoff era. Ohio State has proven they can take a punch and stay standing.
To stay ahead of the curve, keep a close eye on the mid-February recruiting rankings. Specifically, look at how many "trench players" Tennessee pulls from the Midwest and how many "skill players" Ohio State pulls from the SEC footprint. That’s where the next game will be won.