Oscar Isaac is one of those actors who just exudes "movie star" energy without even trying. You've seen it in Inside Llewyn Davis and you've definitely seen it in Ex Machina. But for a massive chunk of the world, he is, and always will be, Poe Dameron. When Oscar Isaac Star Wars news first started trickling out back in 2014, the hype was unreal. People expected a Han Solo clone. What we got was something weirder, more charismatic, and ultimately, kind of a mess in terms of writing. Honestly, looking back at the sequel trilogy now, it’s wild to see how much heavy lifting Isaac did to keep that character afloat while the scripts shifted underneath his feet like desert sand.
He wasn't even supposed to live. That’s the big secret everyone forgets.
In the original draft of The Force Awakens, Poe Dameron dies in that TIE fighter crash on Jakku. Done. Gone. See ya. But J.J. Abrams realized pretty quickly that killing off a guy with that much screen presence was a massive mistake. Isaac himself has joked about how he wasn't thrilled with being a "sacrificial lamb" for the plot. So, they kept him. They let him survive the crash, show up at the last second with the Resistance, and blow up Starkiller Base. It felt great at the time, but that last-minute decision basically set the stage for a character arc that never quite knew where it was going.
The Pilot Who Had Nowhere to Go
By the time The Last Jedi rolled around, Rian Johnson tried to give Poe some actual depth. He turned the "hotshot pilot" trope on its head. It was polarizing, to say the least. Some fans hated seeing Poe get slapped by General Leia or put in his place by Admiral Holdo. But if you look at Isaac’s performance, he’s doing some of his best work there. He’s frustrated. He’s arrogant. He’s human.
The problem is that the "Oscar Isaac Star Wars" experience became a microcosm of the trilogy's larger issues: a lack of a unified plan. In one movie, he’s a hero. In the next, he’s a reckless liability who needs to learn how to lead. By The Rise of Skywalker, he’s suddenly a former "spice runner" with a mysterious past that feels like it was lifted from a completely different character’s bio. It was a weird pivot. Why did the guy who was basically "Space JFK" in the first movie suddenly need a criminal backstory? It felt like the writers were trying to force a Han Solo vibe onto him because they didn't know how to make Poe interesting on his own merits.
Isaac played it well, though. He always does. Even when he’s delivering lines about "somehow, Palpatine returned," you can see him leaning into the absurdity with a professional’s grace. He has this way of looking at his co-stars—especially John Boyega—that sold a bromance more powerful than any actual plot point Disney put on paper.
The Finn-Poe Chemistry We Never Got
We have to talk about the chemistry. It’s the elephant in the room. From the moment Poe gives Finn his name, the internet was obsessed. Oscar Isaac Star Wars interviews during that era are legendary because he was the biggest supporter of a Finn/Poe romance. He didn't shy away from it. He leaned in.
"I was playing a romance. In the cockpit, I was playing a romance."
That's a real quote from Isaac regarding his first scenes with Boyega. He saw the spark. The fans saw the spark. Disney, however, did not see the spark—or rather, they saw it and chose to ignore it in favor of safe, heteronormative subplots that didn't really go anywhere. It’s one of those "what if" scenarios that still haunts the fandom. Imagine a Star Wars trilogy where the central emotional anchor wasn't just Rey’s lineage, but a genuine, groundbreaking relationship between a pilot and a stormtrooper. It would have changed the legacy of those films forever. Instead, we got a lot of "whooping" in X-wings and a very confused Zorii Bliss subplot.
Beyond the X-Wing: Isaac’s Legacy in the Galaxy
Despite the writing hiccups, Poe Dameron remains a Top 5 pilot in the entire franchise. The opening of The Last Jedi, where he takes down the Dreadnought’s surface cannons, is arguably one of the best-shot space battles in cinematic history. The way Isaac carries himself in the cockpit—the physical acting, the frantic energy—it’s masterclass stuff. He made flying an X-wing look cool again in a way we hadn't seen since the 80s.
But what happens now?
Isaac has been pretty vocal about his time with Lucasfilm. For a while, it sounded like he was done. He famously told Variety that he would only return to Star Wars if he "needed another house." It was a blunt, refreshing take in an industry full of PR-speak. But lately, his tone has softened. With the announcement of new films and the expansion of the "Mando-verse" on Disney+, the door isn't exactly slammed shut. He’s mentioned that he’s open to it if the story is right and the director is someone he wants to work with.
That’s the thing about Star Wars. It’s a gravitational pull.
Why Poe Deserves a Solo Project
If Disney is smart, they’ll stop trying to make Poe a supporting player in someone else’s journey. Poe Dameron is a character built for a high-stakes political thriller or a gritty war drama. Think Andor, but with more dogfights.
- The Lead-Up to the First Order: There are years of Poe’s life as a New Republic pilot that haven't been touched on screen. We know he grew up on Yavin 4. We know his parents were Rebels. There is a rich, generational story there about what it's like to grow up in the shadow of giants like Luke Skywalker and Leia Organa.
- The Spice Runner Years: Even though the "spice runner" twist was controversial, it’s canon now. Seeing a young, desperate Poe navigating the underworld could be a fascinating contrast to the polished hero we meet in The Force Awakens.
- Post-Exegol Reconstruction: What does a guy like Poe do when the war is finally over? He’s the leader of what’s left of the Resistance. He’s basically the new face of the military. Watching him struggle with the bureaucracy of rebuilding a Republic would be a great way to use Isaac’s acting range.
Navigating the Fandom
Let's be real: being a part of Oscar Isaac Star Wars discourse is exhausting. The sequel trilogy is a minefield of opinions. You have the "Legends" purists who hate everything Disney did, and you have the newer fans who adore the chemistry of the "trio" (Rey, Finn, and Poe).
Isaac somehow managed to emerge from the wreckage relatively unscathed. While other actors faced horrific online harassment, Isaac was generally spared the worst of it, partly because his performance was so undeniable. Even the harshest critics of the sequels usually admit that the casting was spot on. He brought a sense of old-school swashbuckling joy to a franchise that was starting to feel a bit too self-serious.
He’s an actor who thrives on nuance. If you look at his work in Scenes from a Marriage or Moon Knight, you see a man who wants to get his hands dirty with complex, often unlikeable characters. Star Wars didn't always give him that. It gave him a uniform and a cool ship. But every once in a while—like the scene where he realizes Leia is gone or the moment he faces down Kylo Ren in the opening of the trilogy—you see the actor he really is. He’s someone who can say everything with just a look.
The Real Impact of Poe Dameron
Poe wasn't just a pilot. He was the first major Latino protagonist in the Star Wars film universe. That matters. Seeing a guy named Oscar Isaac playing a hero whose last name is Dameron, flying the most iconic ship in the galaxy, sent a message. It expanded the "look" of Star Wars in a way that felt natural and necessary. He didn't play "a Latino pilot." He played a pilot who happened to be played by one of the best actors of his generation.
🔗 Read more: Why Timeless The Weeknd Lyrics Still Hit Different Years Later
That’s how you do representation right.
The fan art, the fan fiction, the endless debates about his jacket—it all points to a character that resonated despite the uneven writing. People wanted to be Poe Dameron. They wanted his confidence. They wanted his hair. Honestly, the hair alone deserves its own credit in the Star Wars credits.
What You Should Do Next
If you’re a fan of Oscar Isaac Star Wars but haven't engaged with the expanded universe, you’re missing out on the best versions of Poe Dameron. The movies are just the tip of the iceberg.
- Read the "Poe Dameron" Comic Series: Written by Charles Soule, this 31-issue run is fantastic. It takes place right before The Force Awakens and actually gives Poe a consistent personality and a cool crew of pilots (Black Squadron). It makes his "best pilot in the galaxy" reputation feel earned rather than just stated.
- Check out "Resistance Reborn": This novel by Rebecca Roanhorse bridges the gap between The Last Jedi and The Rise of Skywalker. It deals specifically with Poe’s guilt over the mutiny and his struggle to become a leader. It fixes a lot of the character whiplash between those two movies.
- Watch the "Resistance" Animated Series: While it’s aimed at a younger audience, Poe shows up quite a bit (voiced by Isaac himself!). It adds some nice flavor to his role as a mentor.
- Re-watch the Trilogy with a Focus on Background Details: Look at the way Poe interacts with the droids. His relationship with BB-8 is arguably the most consistent and wholesome part of the sequels. It tells you everything you need to know about his character.
The story of Poe Dameron isn't necessarily over, but even if Oscar Isaac never puts on the orange flight suit again, he’s left a permanent mark on the galaxy. He proved that you don't need a lightsaber to be the most captivating person on the screen. Sometimes, all you need is a beat-up X-wing, a loyal droid, and enough swagger to stare down a Dark Lord of the Sith without blinking.
He made us believe that the Resistance was worth fighting for, even when the odds were literally impossible. That’s not just acting; that’s Star Wars.
Stop waiting for a "special edition" to fix the sequels. Instead, dive into the Poe Dameron comics or the Resistance Reborn novel to see the depth the movies didn't have time to show. Those stories provide the connective tissue that makes Isaac's performance feel even more heroic in retrospect.