Everyone says you need to think out of the box to survive in business. It’s a cliché. It’s on every LinkedIn "thought leader" banner and plastered across startup office walls next to the bean bags. But honestly? Most people have no clue what it actually means to step outside the box, mainly because they don't even realize they’re sitting in one.
Boxes are comfortable. They are the standard operating procedures, the "this is how we've always done it" mentalities, and the industry benchmarks that keep us safe. Breaking out of that isn't just about having a "wild idea" during a Friday brainstorm. It’s about a fundamental shift in how you process information.
The Problem with the Out of the Box Cliche
Let's be real. If you tell a team to "think out of the box," they usually just come back with a slightly more expensive version of what they were already doing. Or worse, they suggest something so detached from reality that it’s unmarketable.
True out of the box thinking isn't about ignoring the box. It’s about understanding the box so deeply that you know exactly where the cardboard is thin enough to poke a hole through.
Take the 1970s airline industry. Everyone was competing on meals, seat width, and hub-and-spoke models. Herb Kelleher at Southwest didn't just "think outside the box" by adding a new snack. He threw the box away. He looked at the "box" of hub airports and realized the real efficiency was in point-to-point flights using a single type of aircraft (the Boeing 737). That’s the difference. One is a gimmick; the other is a paradigm shift.
Why Brainstorming is Usually a Waste of Time
Most corporate brainstorming sessions are the enemy of original thought. You’ve been there. A group of ten people sits in a room, and the loudest person dominates. Everyone else just nods. This is called "groupthink," and it is the absolute opposite of being out of the box.
🔗 Read more: DPH8 Amazon Delivery Station: What Most People Get Wrong About Working or Delivering There
Research by psychologists like Adrian Furnham has shown that individuals often generate better, more diverse ideas when working alone than when "brainstorming" in a group. Why? Because the group dynamic creates a new box. You start self-censoring. You don't want to look stupid. You want to fit in.
To get actual results, you have to break the social pressure. Try "brainwriting" instead. Have everyone write ideas on slips of paper in total silence for ten minutes. No talking. No judging. Just raw, unfiltered thoughts. You'll find that the quietest person in the room often has the most disruptive idea.
The Cognitive Science of Originality
Your brain is a pattern-recognition machine. It loves shortcuts. This is great for not getting hit by a bus, but it's terrible for innovation.
When you encounter a problem, your prefrontal cortex immediately searches for "analogous solutions." It looks at what worked yesterday. To think out of the box, you have to manually override this system. You have to force your brain to stop taking the path of least resistance.
Constraints are Actually Your Best Friend
It sounds counterintuitive. How can limits help you think outside the box?
Think about Dr. Seuss. His editor bet him he couldn't write a book using only 50 different words. The result? Green Eggs and Ham. If he had every word in the English language at his disposal, he might have written something forgettable. Because he was trapped in a tiny box of 50 words, he had to get incredibly creative to make it work.
In business, we see this with "Bootstrap Innovation." When a company has zero budget, they are forced to find out of the box ways to acquire customers. They can't just buy a Super Bowl ad. They have to engineer virality or build a community from scratch.
- Financial constraints force efficiency.
- Time constraints eliminate overthinking.
- Resource constraints lead to multi-purposing.
Real Examples of Thinking Out of the Box (That Actually Worked)
Stop looking at "best practices." If it's a best practice, it's already in the box. Everyone is doing it. You want to look at the outliers.
Consider the "Slow Elevator Problem," a classic case study in lateral thinking. Tenants in an office building complain the elevators are too slow. The "in the box" solution? Buy a faster motor. Replace the cables. Spend $200,000.
The out of the box solution? They put mirrors next to the elevators. People stopped complaining. Why? Because they weren't actually annoyed by the speed; they were bored. Giving them something to look at (themselves) solved the psychological problem without touching a single piece of machinery.
The Netflix Pivot
Reed Hastings didn't just decide to "stream movies" one day. The original box was the video rental store with late fees. Netflix started by fixing the late fee problem with DVD-by-mail. But the real out of the box move was recognizing that they weren't in the DVD business—they were in the content delivery business.
When they pivoted to streaming, they were cannibalizing their own successful mail-order business. Most CEOs are too scared to do that. They stay in the box until the box catches fire. Hastings set the fire himself so he could build a better house.
How to Cultivate an Out of the Box Culture
You can't just demand creativity. You have to build an environment where it doesn't get strangled.
- Reward Failure. If you only reward success, people will only take safe bets. Safe bets stay in the box. You need to celebrate the "smart failures"—the experiments that were well-executed but didn't pan out.
- Cross-Pollinate. Bring the accounting team into the marketing meeting. Let the engineers talk to the customer service reps. Creative friction happens when two different "boxes" rub against each other.
- The "Kill the Company" Exercise. Gather your leaders and ask: "If we were a competitor starting today with unlimited funds, how would we put ourselves out of business?" This forces you to see your own vulnerabilities and think of out of the box ways to disrupt yourself before someone else does.
The Role of Lateral Thinking
Edward de Bono coined the term "lateral thinking" back in the 60s, and it’s still the best framework for this. Vertical thinking is moving a step forward from where you are. Lateral thinking is moving to the side to look at the problem from a different angle.
Imagine you're trying to win a race. Vertical thinking says: "Run faster." Lateral thinking says: "Why are we racing on foot? Let's take a bike." Or even: "Why is the finish line over there? Let's move it."
Reverse the Assumptions
Try this: list every "truth" about your industry.
- "Restaurants must have tables."
- "Software must have a monthly subscription."
- "Lawyers must bill by the hour."
Now, pick one and assume the opposite. What does a restaurant without tables look like? You get Ghost Kitchens—a multi-billion dollar industry. What does a law firm without hourly billing look like? You get flat-fee, result-oriented legal tech. This is how you find the out of the box opportunities that others miss because they're too busy following the rules.
Practical Steps to Expand Your Thinking
It’s a muscle. You have to train it. If you spend all day reading the same news and talking to the same five people, your "box" is going to be very small.
Change your inputs. Read a magazine about a topic you hate. Go to a conference for an industry you know nothing about. If you’re a coder, go to a pottery class. If you’re a chef, read a book on game theory. Innovation happens at the intersection of unrelated fields.
📖 Related: Dow Jones Industrial Average Open Today: What the Weekend Numbers Really Mean
Ask "What If?" constantly. What if we gave our product away for free? What if we only sold to people over the age of 80? What if we doubled our prices tomorrow? Most of these ideas will be garbage. That's fine. You only need one to be gold.
Practice "Oblique Strategies." Brian Eno, the famous producer, used a deck of cards with cryptic instructions to help musicians break out of creative ruts. Instructions like "Honor thy error as a hidden intention" or "Ask your body." It sounds hippie-dippie, but it works because it breaks the logical loop your brain is stuck in.
Where People Get it Wrong
There is a danger here. Some people get so obsessed with being out of the box that they forget the box exists for a reason. Standards often exist because they are efficient.
You don't need to reinvent the wheel for every single task. If you try to be "disruptive" about how you file your taxes or how you organize your email, you’re just wasting time. Save your out of the box energy for the problems that actually matter—the ones where the current solution is fundamentally broken or stagnant.
Also, realize that "different" is not the same as "better." Standing on your head during a board meeting is different, but it’s probably not better. True innovation must provide value. It must solve the problem more elegantly, cheaply, or faster than the "in the box" method.
Actionable Next Steps
To actually start thinking out of the box, don't just wait for a lightbulb moment. Use these specific tactics today:
- The Five Whys: When you hit a roadblock, ask "Why?" five times. Usually, the first three answers are superficial. By the fifth "Why," you've usually uncovered a fundamental assumption that you can challenge.
- The "Worst Idea Possible" Technique: If you're stuck, try to come up with the worst, most disastrous way to solve the problem. Paradoxically, this often reveals a creative path you were too "professional" to see before.
- Dopamine Breaks: Stop staring at the screen. Insights often happen during "incubation" periods—when you're doing something mundane like showering or walking. This is when your subconscious mind connects the dots.
- Audit Your Circle: Look at the last five people you've had a deep conversation with. If they all think exactly like you, your box is a fortress. Seek out a "contrarian" and ask them to tear your current strategy apart.
Thinking out of the box isn't a gift some people are born with. It’s a deliberate choice to be uncomfortable, to risk looking foolish, and to relentlessly question the status quo. Start by questioning one "standard" thing you do today. You might be surprised at how flimsy the walls of your box actually are.