Ever watch a scene in Outer Banks and think, "There is no way that guy is sixteen"? You aren't alone. It's a classic Hollywood trope. Shows like Grease or Dawson's Creek paved the way for thirty-year-olds playing freshmen, and Netflix's hit treasure-hunting drama is no different. Honestly, the outer banks cast age is one of the most searched things about the show because the physical maturity of the "Pogues" often clashes with the high-school-aged problems they're supposed to be facing.
The disconnect is real.
👉 See also: Mr. Hulot’s Holiday: Why Jacques Tati’s Classic Still Matters in 2026
When you're watching John B outrun the SBI or Ward Cameron's latest scheme, it’s easy to forget these characters are theoretically teenagers. But they aren't. Not even close. Most of the cast was well into their twenties when the pilot dropped, and now that we're several seasons deep, the gap has only widened. It's kinda wild when you look at the birth certificates versus the scripts.
The Pogue Leader: How Old Is Chase Stokes Really?
Chase Stokes, who plays the charismatic John B, is the biggest outlier in the group. When Season 1 premiered back in 2020, John B was supposed to be 16 or 17 years old. In reality? Chase Stokes was born on September 16, 1992. Do the math. He was 27 when the world first saw him on the Marsh. By the time Season 4 rolled around in late 2024 and early 2025, he was pushing 32.
Playing a teenager for five years while your thirties are knocking on the door is a feat. He’s basically playing a character half his age. It works, mostly because of his lean build and that shaggy hair, but you can definitely see the maturity in his face compared to the pilot. He brings a certain gravitas to John B that a literal 16-year-old probably couldn't pull off, especially with the heavy themes of grief and survival the show leans into.
Madison Bailey, on the other hand, is a bit closer to the mark, though still firmly an adult. Born in 1999, she was 21 when the show started. She plays Kiara Carrera, the moral compass of the group. While a five-year gap isn't as jarring as a ten-year one, there’s still a distinct "adultness" to her performance that makes the Pogue lifestyle feel more like a gritty action movie than a middle-school field trip.
Looking at the Rest of the Crew
Then there’s Rudy Pankow. JJ Maybank is arguably the heart of the show—the loose cannon with a tragic backstory. Rudy was born in 1998, making him just a year older than Madison Bailey. He’s 26 now. His energy is so chaotic and youthful that he actually sells the "teenager" vibe better than most. He’s got that restless, wiry movement that feels very much like a kid who hasn't quite grown into his own skin yet.
Jonathan Daviss, who plays the brainy Pope Heyward, follows the trend. Born in 1999, he’s the same age as Bailey. Watching Pope transition from a kid worried about a scholarship to a guy literally hunting for cross-continental gold has been a journey. Seeing him age in real-time alongside his character makes the progression feel a bit more organic, even if he’s technically been an adult the entire time the cameras were rolling.
- Madelyn Cline (Sarah Cameron): Born December 21, 1997. She was 22 at the start and is now 27.
- Austin North (Topper): Born in 1996. He’s 28.
- Drew Starkey (Rafe Cameron): Born in 1993. He’s 31.
Starkey is a fascinating case. Rafe is one of the most complex, terrifying, and sympathetic villains on TV right now. Because Rafe is John B's peer (sort of) but also clearly more "grown," the fact that Drew Starkey is in his thirties actually helps the character. Rafe should feel like he’s on the edge of a different life stage, and Starkey’s real age adds a layer of simmering, adult intensity that a younger actor might have missed.
👉 See also: Chip and Dale Male Dancers: Why the Bow Tie Brand Still Rules Las Vegas
Why Does Netflix Cast Older Actors for Teens?
You might wonder why they don't just hire actual 16-year-olds. It seems simpler, right? It isn't. Labor laws in California and other filming locations (like Charleston, South Carolina, where OBX is filmed) are incredibly strict regarding minors.
Kids can only work a certain number of hours. They need on-site tutors. They require breaks that can stall a multimillion-dollar production. By hiring the outer banks cast age range of 20 to 30, Netflix avoids all of that. They can film 12-hour days. They can shoot late at night without worrying about curfew laws.
Plus, there’s the emotional weight. The show deals with murder, drug use, intense physical stunts, and heavy romance. Casting a 25-year-old to play these scenes is much less ethically murky than asking a 15-year-old to do it. It’s about maturity and the ability to handle the grueling schedule of a high-octane action show.
The 18-Month Time Jump and Closing the Gap
The showrunners, Josh Pate, Jonas Pate, and Shannon Burke, actually addressed this "age problem" cleverly. At the end of Season 3, there was a significant 18-month time jump. Suddenly, the Pogues weren't just kids running from the law; they were slightly older, more seasoned treasure hunters.
This was a brilliant move.
It allowed the characters to catch up—at least a little bit—to the actors' real-life appearances. When Season 4 kicked off, the characters were around 18 or 19. It’s still not 32, but it makes the beard stubble and the broader shoulders a lot easier to swallow for the audience. It shifts the show from "teens playing hooky" to "young adults trying to build a life in Pogueland."
Honestly, the fans don't seem to care that much. The chemistry between the cast is so palpable—partly because many of them lived together during the early seasons—that the age discrepancies fade into the background. You’re watching for the "P4L" (Pogue for Life) vibes, not to check their IDs.
Comparing the Ages: A Reality Check
To really see the spread, you have to look at where everyone stands as of 2025.
Chase Stokes is the veteran of the group at 32. Drew Starkey is right behind him at 31. Then you have the "mid-twenties" block: Austin North at 29, Madelyn Cline at 27, and the trio of Rudy Pankow, Madison Bailey, and Jonathan Daviss all hovering around 26.
Carlacia Grant, who joined later as Cleo, was born in 1991. She’s actually the oldest member of the main Pogue group at 33. Her character, Cleo, always felt a bit more "street smart" and experienced than the others, so her real-life age fits the character's energy perfectly. She brings a necessary "older sister" vibe to the group that balances out JJ's impulsiveness.
What This Means for the Future of the Show
As the show moves toward its final chapters, the outer banks cast age will continue to be a talking point. There’s a limit to how long you can play a "teen." Eventually, the stories have to evolve into full adulthood. We’re already seeing that with the characters starting businesses and dealing with more "grown-up" stakes like taxes (sorta) and permanent housing.
💡 You might also like: The Last Dance Showtimes: Why You Can’t Find the Michael Jordan Movie
If you’re a fan looking to track these stars, the best thing to do is follow their projects outside the show. You’ll notice that when they aren't in John B’s dirty t-shirts or Sarah’s crop tops, they look exactly like the successful twenty-and-thirty-somethings they are.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
- Don't get hung up on the numbers: Suspension of disbelief is part of the fun. Enjoy the performances for what they are.
- Watch the evolution: Go back and watch Season 1, then jump to Season 4. The physical changes in the cast are a fascinating "time-lapse" of their real-life twenties.
- Check the credits: Many of these actors are now moving into producing and directing because they’ve spent their most formative professional years on this set.
- Follow the time jump: Pay attention to how the writers use time jumps to bridge the gap between the actors' ages and the story's requirements.
The "Pogue" life might be about staying young and reckless, but the actors bringing it to life are seasoned professionals who have grown up right alongside their audience. Whether they are 18 or 32, the treasure hunt stays the same. Keep an eye on how the show handles the inevitable transition into the characters' twenties—it’s likely where the most interesting drama still lies.