If you’re reading chapter 4 lord of the flies, you’ve probably realized things are getting weird on the island. Fast. It’s not just about the boys being bored or missing their parents anymore. This is where the civilization facade starts to crack, and honestly, it’s mostly because of a bit of clay and charcoal.
William Golding titled this chapter "Painted Faces and Long Hair," and he wasn't being subtle. The hair is long because time has passed—maybe several months—and the "painted faces" represent the moment Jack discovers he can hide his conscience behind a mask. You’ve got these kids who were choirboys and students, but now they’re vibrating with a different kind of energy. It’s scary.
The Moment the Smoke Went Out in Chapter 4 Lord of the Flies
The biggest plot point here is the fire. Or rather, the lack of it. Ralph, who is basically the only one still clinging to the idea of "home," sees a ship on the horizon. It’s a literal lifeline. But the signal fire is dead. Why? Because Jack took the twins, Sam and Eric, away from their watch duty to go kill a pig.
This is the central conflict of chapter 4 lord of the flies. It’s the tension between the "littluns" who just play all day and the "biguns" who are splitting into two camps: the builders and the hunters. Ralph represents the social contract—the boring stuff like shelters and sanitation. Jack represents the lizard brain. He wants blood. He wants the thrill of the kill.
✨ Don't miss: Cast of TV Batman: What Most People Get Wrong
When Jack returns, he’s triumphant. He’s got a carcass. He’s chanting. But Ralph is standing there, looking at a ship that is disappearing over the horizon. The contrast is gut-wrenching. You can feel the frustration. Ralph is shouting about rescue, and Jack is babbling about how the blood spurted when he slit the pig's throat. They are no longer speaking the same language.
Why the Mask Matters More Than the Meat
Let's talk about the mask. Jack paints his face with white and red clay and a slash of black charcoal. Golding describes this as a "liberation from shame and self-consciousness." That is a huge takeaway for anyone analyzing chapter 4 lord of the flies.
When Jack looks in the water and sees his reflection, he doesn’t see Jack anymore. He sees a "formidable stranger." This is psychological armor. It’s a lot easier to break the rules of society when you don’t look like yourself. Think about how people act online when they’re anonymous. Same thing. The mask allows Jack to become a predator without the baggage of being a "proper English boy."
The Cruelty of the Littluns and Henry
There is a smaller, often overlooked scene in this chapter involving a kid named Henry. He’s down by the water, playing with these little translucent creatures that wash up with the tide. He’s poking them, trapping them, and feeling a sense of "mastery" over them.
Then you have Roger.
Roger is the guy who eventually becomes the island's executioner, and we see his "origin story" here in chapter 4 lord of the flies. He starts throwing stones at Henry. But—and this is the key detail—he purposefully misses. He throws them so they land in a circle around the boy. Golding explains that there is still an invisible space around Henry "protected by the parents and school and policemen and the law."
Roger’s arm is conditioned by a civilization that doesn't exist on the island, but the habits of that world are still holding his arm back. For now. It’s a chilling foreshadowing of what happens when that conditioning finally wears off.
Piggy’s Glasses: The Breaking Point
The tension between Ralph and Jack finally explodes into physical violence, and poor Piggy is the target. Piggy is the intellectual. He’s the one who suggests making a sundial. He’s the one who tries to keep everyone rational. Naturally, Jack hates him.
In the heat of the argument over the fire, Jack punches Piggy and smacks him in the head, which causes Piggy’s glasses to fly off. One lens shatters. This is a massive symbol. In chapter 4 lord of the flies, the "vision" of the group is literally halved. They are losing their ability to see clearly, to think scientifically, and to look toward the future.
- Ralph’s Perspective: Fire = Rescue = Future.
- Jack’s Perspective: Meat = Power = Now.
When the lens breaks, the balance of power shifts. Ralph is still the chief, but Jack has the meat. And on a deserted island, meat is a powerful currency. Even Ralph can’t help but eat the pork Jack provides, even though he’s furious. It’s a total "power move" by Jack. He uses the food to humiliate Piggy by refusing to give him a share initially, asserting his dominance over who gets to survive.
🔗 Read more: Monte Walsh 1970 Cast: Why This Aging Cowboy Story Still Matters
Misconceptions About This Chapter
A lot of people think the "beast" is the main problem in the book. But if you look closely at chapter 4 lord of the flies, the beast isn't even the main focus yet. The real "beast" is the internal shift in the boys.
Some readers assume Jack is just being a "bad kid" because he's mean. It's deeper than that. Jack is reacting to the loss of structure. In the real world, he was a head chorister. He had a title. On the island, that title means nothing. He had to invent a new hierarchy based on skill and fear.
Another misconception? That the boys are "turning into savages" because they are away from adults. Golding’s point is actually more cynical: the boys are just mirroring the adult world. Remember, the reason they are on the island is that a global nuclear war is happening. The "civilized" adults are currently blowing each other up. The boys aren't becoming something else; they’re becoming exactly what the human race is when the lights go out.
Actionable Insights for Analysis
If you are writing an essay or preparing for a test on this chapter, don't just summarize the plot. Focus on the sensory details Golding uses.
- Analyze the "Mask": Connect Jack’s face paint to modern concepts of anonymity and tribalism. How does hiding your identity change your ethics?
- The Fire vs. The Hunt: This is the core binary. One is about communal survival; the other is about individual gratification.
- The Role of Percival: There’s a "littlun" named Percival Wemys Madison who starts crying and can’t stop. He represents the total breakdown of the youngest boys who can't even remember their names or addresses anymore.
- Watch the Sun: Golding uses the heat of the sun in this chapter to describe how it "pounded" the boys. It’s an oppressive force that wears down their willpower.
Basically, by the end of this chapter, the honeymoon phase is over. The boys are no longer playing "Coral Island." They are in a struggle for the soul of their small society. Ralph has called a meeting at the very end of the chapter, and he’s determined to "put things straight." But you can tell, even as he walks down the beach, that the momentum has already shifted toward the hunters.
To truly understand the trajectory of the novel, you have to sit with the image of that ship sailing away. It was the only chance they had at a "clean" rescue. Everything that happens after this is the result of that one missed opportunity.
Next Steps for Your Study
- Track the Glasses: Keep a note of every time Piggy’s glasses are mentioned from here on out. They are the barometer for how much "civilization" is left.
- Compare Jack and Ralph: Write down three things Jack values in this chapter and three things Ralph values. Notice where they never overlap.
- Re-read the Henry Scene: Look at the "circles" of protection Golding mentions. It’s the most important paragraph for understanding the theme of inherent versus learned morality.
The shift is permanent now. The paint won't come off easily.