New York City is a pressure cooker. It’s loud, expensive, and smells like a mix of roasted nuts and subway steam. But if you walk down 24th Street or head over to the Loft, you’ll find a place where that pressure turns into something actually useful: laughter. I’m talking about the People’s Improv Theater, or as everyone actually calls it, The PIT.
It started back in 2002. Ali Farahnakian, who basically eats, sleeps, and breathes the philosophy of "Yes, And," founded it after spending time at SNL, Second City, and iO. He wanted a space that felt less like a cold institution and more like a community center for weirdos. It worked.
The PIT isn't just a building; it’s a specific vibe. While other theaters in the city might feel like they're scouting you for a sitcom, The PIT feels like they’re inviting you to a chaotic, brilliant dinner party where the main course is a sketch about a talking toaster.
What Actually Happens at the People’s Improv Theater?
People get confused about what improv actually is. They think it's just "Whose Line Is It Anyway?" with more flannel shirts. At the People’s Improv Theater, it’s deeper than that. You’ve got long-form improv, which is basically a 20-minute play made up on the spot based on a single word from the audience. Then there’s sketch comedy, which is written, rehearsed, and polished—sort of.
The PIT has different stages. You’ve got the Striker, which is the big one, and then the Underground. Each has a different energy. The Underground is intimate. If you’re in the front row, you’re basically in the show. You can see the sweat on the performer's forehead when they realize their teammate just decided the scene takes place on the moon and they have no idea how physics works.
But it’s not just shows. The classes are where the real magic (and the real awkwardness) happens. You see lawyers, baristas, and retirees all trying to "find the game" of a scene. It’s vulnerable. It’s terrifying. It’s the most fun you can have for $300 and eight weeks of your life.
Why the PIT Matters for NYC Culture
Honestly, the NYC comedy scene is cutthroat. We’ve seen legendary spots like the Upright Citizens Brigade (UCB) go through massive changes, closures, and relocations. Through all that, the People’s Improv Theater has remained a steady heartbeat for the community.
Why? Because they lean into the "People" part of their name.
✨ Don't miss: Sweet Dreams: Where to Watch the Most Talked About Films and Series of the Year
They have these things called "jams." A jam is basically an open mic for improv. You show up, put your name in a bucket, and get on stage with strangers. It’s a leveling of the playing field. A seasoned pro might be paired with a Level 1 student who is shaking so hard they can barely remember their own name. That’s where the best comedy comes from—that friction.
The Loft and the Evolution of the Space
The PIT moved. It expanded. It shifted. For a while, the 24th Street location was the undisputed HQ, but the "PIT Loft" on 29th Street added a new dimension. It’s a smaller, 50-seat black box theater. If the Striker is the stadium, the Loft is the garage band space.
It’s where "Solocom" happens. Solocom is this massive festival where artists debut new solo shows. Imagine 100+ new shows in one weekend. It’s a marathon of ego, brilliance, and occasionally, very confusing interpretive dance. But that’s the point. The People’s Improv Theater provides the safety net for people to fail spectacularly. And in comedy, if you aren't willing to fail, you’re never going to be funny.
The "Farahnakian" Philosophy
Ali Farahnakian’s influence is everywhere in the building. He often talks about the idea that "the PIT is a place for the people, by the people, and of the people." It sounds a bit like the Gettysburg Address, but for fart jokes.
He emphasizes "Level 0." The idea is that you don't need a resume to start. You just need to be present. This philosophy has birthed some massive talent. Look at the alumni. People like Ellie Kemper (The Office, Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt), Kristen Schaal (Bob's Burgers), and Hannibal Buress have all moved through these doors.
But if you ask a regular at the bar (yes, there’s a bar, and yes, it’s essential), they don't care about the celebrities. They care about their "house team." House teams are groups of performers who are selected by the theater to perform regularly. They practice for months. They develop a shorthand. Watching a top-tier house team at the People’s Improv Theater is like watching a jazz quintet. They know when to take a solo and when to back off.
Misconceptions About the PIT
A lot of people think you have to be "funny" to take a class at the People’s Improv Theater.
That’s a lie.
In fact, the "class clown" types are often the hardest to teach because they’re trying too hard to get a laugh. The best improvisers are the ones who listen. Improv is 10% talking and 90% reacting to what your partner just said. If I say, "I’m leaving you, and I’m taking the cat," and you say, "I don’t have a cat," you’ve killed the scene. If you say, "Not Mr. Whiskers! He’s the only one who knows where the gold is buried!"—now we have a show.
Another misconception: It’s only for actors.
Nope. The PIT’s corporate training wing is huge. Companies bring their executives here to learn how to communicate better. It turns out that "Yes, And" is a pretty good way to run a boardroom, too. It’s about building on ideas instead of shutting them down.
The Logistics: How to Actually Experience It
If you’re just visiting NYC or if you’ve lived here for a decade and finally want to check it out, here’s how you do it without looking like a total tourist.
- Check the schedule for "Old School Game Show" or "The Joycie Hesselberth Show." These are staples.
- Go to a Wednesday night. It’s often house team night. You get to see the people who are there every single week grinding it out.
- Don't sit in the front row unless you’re ready to talk. You might become a character's "estranged father" or "the guy who sells cursed clocks."
- Visit the bar. The Love Bar at the PIT is where the post-show post-mortem happens. It’s where the community is built.
The People’s Improv Theater isn't just about the 60 minutes you spend watching a show. It’s about the three hours you spend afterward talking about what went right and what went horribly, hilariously wrong.
Survival of the Funniest
The pandemic hit NYC theaters like a freight train. Many didn't make it. The PIT had to navigate the same brutal landscape of rent, safety protocols, and the sudden disappearance of live audiences.
But they pivoted. They did virtual shows. They did outdoor classes. They survived because the community refused to let them go. There is something primal about sitting in a dark room with 40 strangers and laughing at the same stupid thing. You can’t replicate that on Zoom, no matter how good your internet connection is.
Today, the People’s Improv Theater is back to a full schedule. It’s gritty, it’s a little bit messy, and it’s perfectly New York. It doesn’t have the corporate sheen of some of the larger comedy entities, and that’s exactly why it works. It feels human.
How to Get Involved Right Now
If you're reading this and thinking, "Maybe I should try that," you should.
- Take a "Joy of Improv" workshop. It’s a low-stakes way to see if you like it.
- See a show. Tickets are usually cheap ($10-$20). That’s less than a cocktail in Midtown.
- Volunteer. Like many independent theaters, they often need help with front-of-house stuff. It’s a great way to see shows for free and meet the performers.
The People’s Improv Theater remains a cornerstone of the American comedy landscape because it refuses to be anything other than a place for people to play. In a world that’s increasingly digital and isolated, the PIT is a reminder that being present, listening to others, and being willing to look like an idiot is actually a superpower.
Actionable Next Steps
If you want to dive into the world of the People’s Improv Theater, start by attending a "Free Intro to Improv" class, which the theater occasionally hosts to lower the barrier for entry. If you’re more interested in watching, look for the "Super Free Wednesday" lineups, which offer a high volume of comedy for almost no cost. For those looking to sharpen professional skills, investigate their corporate workshops which specifically translate improvisational techniques into leadership and communication tools. Whether you end up on stage or just in the audience with a cheap beer, the goal is the same: show up and see what happens when nobody has a script.