So, the dust has finally settled on the biggest "what-if" of the winter. After months of Mets fans holding their breath and Scott Boras doing his usual dance in the media, we have our answer. Pete Alonso is officially a Baltimore Oriole.
It feels weird. Seeing the Polar Bear in orange and black instead of blue and orange is going to take some getting used to. But honestly, if you looked at the numbers and the way the market was shifting, this Pete Alonso contract prediction was hiding in plain sight. He just signed a five-year, $155 million deal to anchor the middle of that terrifying Baltimore lineup. It makes him the highest-paid first baseman in the game by average annual value (AAV) for the 2026 season.
The Mets Let a Legend Walk
Look, Steve Cohen has all the money in the world. We know this. But the Mets front office has been pivoting toward a "sustainability" model that apparently didn't include a $31 million-a-year first baseman on the wrong side of 30. Pete turns 31 this year. While he played all 162 games in 2025—which is basically unheard of in today's game—the underlying metrics showed some flickers of concern.
The Mets were reportedly looking for something in the four-year range. Boras, being Boras, wanted seven. They met nowhere in the middle. Baltimore stepped in because they are in their "win-now" window and had a massive hole at first base. By snagging Alonso, they didn't just get 40 home runs; they got a guy who has averaged 158 games a season over the last five years. That kind of durability is worth its weight in gold when you're trying to hunt down a World Series.
✨ Don't miss: NCAA Wrestling Championships: Where to Watch Every Takedown in 2026
Why $155 Million Actually Makes Sense
A lot of people are choking on that $31 million AAV. It’s a lot for a guy who is primarily a power hitter and doesn't provide elite defense. However, the 2025 season was a massive "prove-it" year for Pete, and he absolutely delivered.
- 2025 Stats: .272 average, 38 home runs, and a massive 126 RBIs.
- OPS+: 144 (his best since his rookie year).
- Plate Discipline: He cut his strikeout rate slightly while maintaining that elite "damage" contact.
The Orioles are betting that his swing translates perfectly to Camden Yards. Even with the "Walltimore" left-field dimensions, Alonso’s power is mostly to center and right-center. He’s a pull-power monster who can still poke doubles into the gaps.
The Market Shift for First Basemen
The Pete Alonso contract prediction was always tied to how the rest of the league valued corner infielders. For a while, the market was depressed. Then, Vladimir Guerrero Jr. reset things with his massive extension. Once Vladdy's numbers were on the books, Alonso's camp had the leverage they needed.
Baltimore’s Mike Elias has been conservative with big free-agent splashes in the past, but the Shane Baz trade and the Taylor Ward acquisition earlier this winter signaled a shift. They are aggressive now. They realize that having a veteran presence like Pete—who already has 264 career homers—is the perfect stabilizer for a clubhouse full of young stars like Gunnar Henderson and Adley Rutschman.
What Happens to the Mets Now?
Queens is going to feel a lot quieter without the "Let's Go Pete" chants. The Mets are likely moving Mark Vientos to first base full-time or potentially looking at Ryan Clifford as the future, but that's a gamble. They saved the money, sure, but they lost the heartbeat of their offense.
Actionable Insights for the 2026 Season
If you're a fan or a fantasy manager looking at how this deal impacts the field, here is what you need to track:
- Watch the Home/Road Splits: Pete’s power traditionally played well at Citi Field, but Camden is a different beast for righties. If he starts hitting more doubles than homers early on, don't panic.
- Durability is the Key Metric: The reason Baltimore went to $155 million wasn't just the homers; it was the 700+ plate appearances. If Pete stays on the field for 155+ games, this contract is a bargain.
- The AL East Factor: He’s going from the NL East to a division with some "slugger-friendly" parks like Yankee Stadium and Fenway. Expect his counting stats (RBIs and Runs) to stay elite.
The Polar Bear has a new home. It’s a massive gamble for the Orioles and a heartbreaking "business decision" for the Mets. But in a league where power is the ultimate currency, Pete Alonso just proved he’s still one of the best investments in the game.