Hollywood is weird. One minute you’re standing on top of the Empire State Building with a diamond ring, and the next, you’re releasing a joint statement about "conflicting schedules" and "opposite coasts." That’s the shorthand for the saga of Peter Facinelli and Jaimie Alexander, a couple that seemed like a perfect match—until they suddenly weren’t.
It’s been years since they called it quits. Still, people keep digging. Why? Because the timeline was messy. Because they were both at the heights of their respective TV powers. And honestly, because everyone wanted to know if the Twilight doctor had actually found his real-life "forever" after a very public divorce.
The Loosies Connection: How They Actually Met
Forget the red carpets for a second. The real spark happened on the set of an indie film called Loosies back in 2011. Peter Facinelli didn’t just star in it; he wrote and produced it. At the time, he was still married to Jennie Garth. That’s the part that always gets people talking. While the movie was filming, everything seemed professional, but by the time the film was being promoted in late 2012, the vibe had shifted.
Facinelli and Jaimie Alexander didn’t just work together once. They were also on Nurse Jackie. You’ve got to wonder if those long days on set are where the friendship turned into something heavier. They officially went public in November 2012, which was only about eight months after Peter and Jennie Garth announced their split.
"It was one of those things where I’d been single for a very long time and he was going through a lot," Jaimie told People at the time. She admitted it was scary. Rebounding in the public eye usually is.
That Empire State Building Proposal
Fast forward to March 2015. Peter goes full An Affair to Remember. He proposes to Jaimie at the top of the Empire State Building. It was a literal movie moment. They both posted photos, looking absolutely ecstatic in matching leather jackets.
At that point, she was the star of Blindspot and he was doing Supergirl. They were the ultimate "it" couple of the Comic-Con circuit. Jaimie even talked about having a "stunt" at their wedding because she’s an adrenaline junkie. She wanted something spectacular.
✨ Don't miss: Olsen Sisters Now: Why They Disappeared and What They’re Actually Doing
But here is the catch.
Even then, the cracks were showing in the logistics. They only got engaged because their work schedules happened to overlap in New York for a few days. That’s a red flag most people ignored. If you have to wait for a production schedule to align just to see each other long enough to get engaged, when are you going to have time for a marriage?
The 2016 Breakup: Not Just a Schedule Issue?
In February 2016, less than a year after the proposal, it was over. The official line was the classic: "Due to conflicting family and work commitments on opposite coasts... Peter and Jaimie have chosen to part ways."
🔗 Read more: Huda Kattan and Her Ex: What Most People Get Wrong
- Geography: Jaimie was filming Blindspot in New York.
- Family: Peter had three daughters in Los Angeles with Jennie Garth.
- Career: He was recurring on Supergirl, which filmed in LA.
Bi-coastal relationships are brutal. But was it just the flights? Fans have speculated for years that the pressure of his "blended family" and the lingering drama from his previous divorce played a role. It’s hard to build a new life when you’re still heavily tethered to the old one—especially when that old one involves three kids and an ex-wife who admitted the new relationship "stung."
Where Are Peter Facinelli and Jaimie Alexander Now?
They both moved on. It wasn't a "wait for me" situation.
Peter Facinelli eventually found love with Lily Anne Harrison. They got engaged on New Year's Day in 2020 and welcomed a son in 2022. It seems like the stability he was looking for finally clicked. Interestingly, his relationship with Jennie Garth has also improved significantly. They’ve been seen co-parenting and even appearing on podcasts together, proving that time really does heal most things.
👉 See also: Who is Jennifer Lopez New Boyfriend? The Real Story Behind the Rumors
Jaimie Alexander has kept her private life a bit more... well, private. She returned to the Marvel Cinematic Universe as Lady Sif and continues to be a powerhouse in the industry. She doesn’t talk about Peter much anymore. Why would she? It’s a closed chapter.
The Reality Check
So, what’s the takeaway here? Peter Facinelli and Jaimie Alexander were a case of "right person, wrong time." Or maybe just "right person for a specific season."
- Don't ignore the logistics. If you live in New York and they live in LA, and neither can move, the "love conquers all" mantra usually fails.
- Rebounds are risky. Starting a high-profile relationship while a decade-long marriage is still being dismantled is playing on "Hard Mode."
- Amicable is possible. Despite the rumors, there was never a massive public blowout. They kept it classy, which is rare in Hollywood.
If you're looking for lessons in their story, look at how they handled the end. No messy "tell-all" books. No social media shade. They just realized the math didn't add up and walked away. Sometimes, the most expert move you can make in a relationship is knowing when to call it.
To keep track of where they are today, you can follow Peter's directing projects or catch Jaimie's latest appearances in the MCU. Both have proven that while a high-profile engagement is a big deal, it doesn't have to define your entire career or your future happiness.