You’ve probably seen the postcard. That one with the white lighthouse against a perfect blue sky or the row of "gingerbread" houses that look like they were plucked from a Hansel and Gretel fever dream. Honestly, most pictures of Martha’s Vineyard you see online are beautiful, but they’re also kinda... samey. Everyone stands in the exact same spot on the Aquinnah Cliffs. Everyone takes the same photo of the Edgartown Harbor Light.
But if you actually want to capture the soul of the island, you have to look past the "Instagram spots."
The Menemsha Sunset Trap
Let’s talk about Menemsha. It’s a tiny fishing village in Chilmark, and it’s famous for its sunsets. Like, "people-actually-clap-when-the-sun-goes-down" famous. If you head there in July, you’ll be shoulder-to-shoulder with hundreds of people holding iPhones and expensive DSLRs.
It’s a vibe, for sure. You get the smell of salt air and the sound of boat horns. But the best pictures of Martha’s Vineyard aren't always the ones of the sun hitting the water. Turn your camera around. Capture the stacks of lobster traps at Larsen’s Fish Market. Look at the weathered wood of the fishing shacks. The texture of the rusted anchors and the tangled nets tells a much more interesting story than a standard orange sky ever could.
Pro tip: Grab a lobster roll from the Galley, sit on a pile of ropes, and wait for the "blue hour" after the crowds leave. That's when the harbor lights reflect on the water and the place feels real again.
🔗 Read more: Colombia: What Most People Get Wrong
Why Edgartown is More Than Just White Paint
Edgartown is basically a movie set. In fact, it was the movie set for Jaws. It’s all white clapboard houses, black shutters, and manicured roses. It’s easy to take "pretty" photos here, but it’s hard to take great ones.
Most people walk straight to the Edgartown Harbor Light. It’s iconic, yeah, but try wandering down North Water Street first. You'll see the old Captain’s houses. If you’re lucky, you’ll catch the light hitting the 1828 architecture just right.
- The Harbor View Hotel porch: A classic wide-angle shot.
- The Chappy Ferry: It’s one of the shortest ferry rides in the world. Catch it as it moves across the 527-foot channel.
- Memorial Wharf: Head to the top deck for a bird's-eye view of the sailing yachts.
Honestly, the best shots in Edgartown happen when you focus on the details—the brass knockers on the doors or the way the privet hedges create deep shadows on the sidewalk.
Getting the "Real" Aquinnah Cliffs
The Aquinnah Cliffs (formerly Gay Head) are a National Natural Landmark. They are massive, colorful clay cliffs that drop off into the Atlantic. Most visitors stand at the overlook by the shops.
It's okay. But it's not the shot.
To get the most dramatic pictures of Martha’s Vineyard coastline, you need to hike down to Moshup Beach. You have to pay for parking ($15 usually), and it’s a bit of a trek, but standing at the base of those red and orange clay walls makes the cliffs look like they’re from another planet.
📖 Related: La Paz BCS Mexico: Why It’s Better Than Cabo (And How to Keep It That Way)
Just a heads-up: the Wampanoag Tribe of Aquinnah manages this land. It’s sacred to them. Don’t be that person climbing on the cliffs for a selfie. It’s illegal, it causes erosion, and it’s just disrespectful. Stay on the sand and use a wide-angle lens to capture the scale of the erosion and the greenery clinging to the edges.
The Gingerbread Houses of Oak Bluffs
If Edgartown is the "stately" town, Oak Bluffs is the "fun" one. The Martha’s Vineyard Camp Meeting Association (MVCMA) is home to over 300 Victorian cottages. They call them Gingerbread Houses because of the ornate, colorful woodwork.
Walking through the "Campground" feels like being inside a dollhouse.
Every house has a different color scheme—pinks, teals, purples.
- Trinity Park Tabernacle: This is the iron-wrought center of the community.
- The Illumination Night: If you happen to be there in August, the houses are covered in paper lanterns. It’s a nightmare to photograph because of the low light and crowds, but it’s magical.
- Flying Horses Carousel: It’s the oldest platform carousel in the country. Capturing the motion of the wooden horses with a slow shutter speed is a classic island challenge.
The Hidden Spots: Chappaquiddick and Beyond
If you want to escape the tourists and get some moody, lonely pictures of Martha’s Vineyard, you have to get on the Chappy Ferry. Chappaquiddick is technically part of Edgartown, but it feels a world away.
Mytoi Garden is a Japanese-style garden tucked into the woods of Chappy. It’s weirdly peaceful. You’ve got native New England plants mixed with Japanese maples and a koi pond. The reflections here are insane, especially in the fall when the colors turn.
Then there’s the Cape Poge Wildlife Refuge. You need an "oversand" vehicle permit or a tour to get deep into it. It’s miles of sand dunes, salt marshes, and the lonely Cape Poge Lighthouse. This is where you go for those "edge of the world" shots.
Technical Stuff for the Photography Nerds
You don't need a $5,000 setup, but a few things help.
The light on the Vineyard is different because you're surrounded by water. It’s "bouncier." A polarizing filter is basically mandatory if you want to see through the glare on the water at places like South Beach or Sengekontacket Pond. It also makes the colors of the Aquinnah clay pop.
If you’re shooting at South Beach in Katama, watch out for the wind. It’s constant. If you’re using a tripod for long exposures of the waves, make sure it’s weighted down. Salt spray is also a lens killer. Keep a microfiber cloth in your pocket and use it constantly.
What Most People Miss
People forget about the "Up-Island" farms.
The Allen Farm in Chilmark is the oldest continuously operating family farm on the island. You can see sheep grazing with the Atlantic Ocean in the background. It’s a pastoral scene that looks more like Scotland than Massachusetts.
📖 Related: The Dakota Apartment Building in New York City: What Most People Get Wrong
Also, the West Tisbury Farmers Market. It’s a riot of color. Stacks of heirloom tomatoes, local flowers, and the faces of the people who actually live here year-round. These are the pictures of Martha’s Vineyard that feel lived-in.
Actionable Tips for Your Photo Trip
- Check the Tides: Places like Lucy Vincent Beach change completely based on the tide. At high tide, the "rocks" might be underwater. At low tide, you get incredible tide pools.
- Morning over Evening: Everyone does sunset. If you want empty beaches and soft, "blue-pink" light, hit the East Chop Lighthouse at 5:00 AM.
- Respect the "Private" Signs: A lot of the best beaches (like Lambert’s Cove) are restricted to residents only during the summer. Don't try to sneak in; the "beach bouncers" take their jobs very seriously.
- Look for the Jaws Bridge: It’s the bridge between Oak Bluffs and Edgartown. Catching a shot of a local kid jumping off the bridge is a rite of passage.
Basically, the island is a giant playground for anyone with a camera. Just remember that the best shot is usually the one everyone else is walking past while they're looking for the "famous" view.
Pack your extra batteries. Charge your phone. Make sure you have a waterproof bag for your gear if you're heading out on a boat. The weather changes in ten minutes here. You might start with a foggy harbor in Vineyard Haven and end with a blindingly bright afternoon in Aquinnah. That's the beauty of it.