.jpg)
Walk down SE 12th Avenue and you'll smell it before you see it. That's the hallmark of a real bakery. Honestly, Piece of Cake Bakery Portland Oregon isn't just another shop trying to hop on the latest TikTok trend with over-the-top milkshakes or gold-leaf donuts. It is a staple. It's the kind of place that has survived the rapidly shifting landscape of the Sellwood-Moreland neighborhood because it actually delivers on the fundamental promise of a bakery: making things that taste like they were made by someone who cares about you.
Portland's dessert scene is crowded. You've got the high-end patisseries in the Pearl and the late-night donut spots that tourists flock to. But Piece of Cake occupies a specific, cozy niche. It’s been around for decades. Marilyn Harrison, the force behind the flour, started this whole thing with a focus on "natural" and "wholesome" before those were just marketing buzzwords used to jack up prices at Whole Foods.
Why the Sellwood Location Matters
Location is everything, but for this bakery, it’s about the vibe. Sellwood feels like a small town tucked inside a city. You’ve got antique shops, the theater, and then this little yellow house of sugar. It’s approachable. You can walk in wearing your gardening clothes or a suit, and nobody blinks.
Most people don't realize that Piece of Cake Bakery Portland Oregon actually specialized in vegan and gluten-free options long before it was trendy. Back in the day, if you wanted a vegan cake, you usually ended up with something that had the structural integrity and flavor of a damp brick. Marilyn changed that. She figured out the chemistry.
The bakery is famously known for its "Bumpy Cake." Now, if you aren't from the Midwest, you might not get the reference. It’s a nod to a Detroit classic—chocolate cake topped with rows of buttercream and then draped in a rich chocolate ganache. It is decadent. It is messy. It is exactly what a cake should be.
The Science of the "Natural" Cake
Let’s talk ingredients. Many commercial bakeries use "plastic" fats. You know the ones—shortenings that stay solid at room temperature and leave a film on the roof of your mouth. Piece of Cake leans into butter, real fruit, and natural flavorings. This isn't just a health choice; it’s a physics one. Real ingredients behave differently under heat.
- Butter vs. Oil: They use butter for the crumb structure in their traditional cakes, providing that "melt-in-your-mouth" feel that oil-based cakes can't replicate.
- The Vegan Pivot: For their vegan line, they often use fruit purees and high-quality oils to ensure the cake remains moist without the help of eggs.
- No Preservatives: This is the big one. Because they don't load their batter with shelf-stabilizers, the cakes have a shorter window of "perfect" freshness. You eat it now, or you freeze it. You don't leave it on the counter for a week.
One of the most impressive things about the menu is the sheer variety. They have over 50 flavors. Think about the logistics of that for a second. Keeping that many ingredients in stock and maintaining consistency across fifty different recipes is a nightmare for most kitchen managers. Yet, they pull it off. You can get a classic Red Velvet, or you can go weird with something like their "Champagne" cake or a boozy "Kahlua" flavored slice.
🔗 Read more: Cup to tsp converter: Why your measurements are probably a little off
Customization and the Portland Wedding Scene
If you've lived in Portland for more than a minute, you’ve probably been to a wedding catered by Piece of Cake Bakery Portland Oregon. They are the workhorses of the local wedding industry.
While other bakeries might limit you to three "signature" styles, this place is basically a "yes" factory. You want a three-tier vegan cake that looks like a forest floor? They’ve done it. You want a traditional white cake with raspberry filling that looks like it belongs in a 1950s sitcom? Done.
The pricing is also surprisingly grounded. In a city where a custom cake can easily run you the price of a used Honda Civic, Piece of Cake stays accessible. They offer "cutting cakes" for couples who want the photo op but plan to serve sheet cakes to the masses—a savvy move that shows they actually understand their customers' budgets.
Addressing the "Old School" Reputation
Some critics—usually the ones who only want "deconstructed" desserts served on a piece of slate—call the style "dated." They're wrong.
There is a difference between "dated" and "timeless." Piece of Cake focuses on the American tradition of baking. This means generous frosting, substantial layers, and flavors that are recognizable. When you order a lemon cake, it tastes like lemons, not a "whisper of citrus zest with a hint of lavender smoke."
There's a comfort in that.
Navigating the Menu: What to Actually Order
If it’s your first time walking into the shop, the display case can be overwhelming. Don't panic.
- The Marionberry Cake: You’re in Oregon. If you aren't eating marionberries, what are you even doing here? This cake captures the tartness of the berry perfectly against a sweet cream base.
- The Vegan Chocolate: Even if you aren't vegan, try a slice. It’s arguably more moist than the dairy version.
- The Poppyseed: It's a classic for a reason. Great texture, not too sweet, perfect with a cup of coffee from one of the nearby roasters.
They also do "Cake Cups," which are basically the scraps and frosting layered in a container. It’s the ultimate "I’m driving home and need a sugar hit" snack. No judgment.
The Reality of Small Business in Portland
Running a bakery in 2026 isn't easy. The cost of eggs fluctuates wildly, flour prices have spiked, and the labor market is tight. Piece of Cake has had to adapt. They've streamlined their ordering process and leaned more into their online presence. But the core remains the same.
It’s about the community. On any given Saturday, you'll see families who have been coming there for three generations. The kid who got their 1st birthday cake there is now ordering their graduation cake. That kind of longevity doesn't happen by accident. It happens because the product is consistent.
Piece of Cake Bakery Portland Oregon stands as a testament to the idea that you don't need to reinvent the wheel to be successful. You just need to make a really, really good wheel. One made of sugar and flour.
Actionable Tips for Your Visit
- Order Ahead for Holidays: If you think you can walk in on the day before Thanksgiving and grab a pumpkin cheesecake, you're going to be disappointed. Their holiday pre-order window usually closes a week in advance.
- Check the "Day Old" Shelf: If you're on a budget, they often have discounted items that are still perfectly good. High-quality cake freezes remarkably well.
- Parking Hack: Don't try to park right in front on 12th. It’s a mess. Circle around to the residential side streets a block or two East. It'll save you ten minutes of frustration.
- Dietary Restrictions: Always disclose the severity of an allergy. While they offer gluten-free and vegan options, it is a shared kitchen. They are great about cross-contamination protocols, but it’s always better to communicate clearly with the staff.
- Sampling: If they aren't slammed, ask about flavors. The staff knows these recipes inside and out and can help you navigate the 50+ options based on whether you like "light and airy" or "dense and rich."
Whether you’re a lifelong local or just passing through the Pacific Northwest, skipping this spot is a mistake. It’s a slice of Portland history that you can actually eat. Go for the Bumpy Cake, stay for the nostalgia, and leave with a box of cookies for the road.
Next Steps for Your Sugar Fix
To get the most out of your visit to Piece of Cake Bakery Portland Oregon, start by browsing their online gallery to narrow down your flavor preferences—it’s much easier than deciding at the counter when there’s a line behind you. If you’re planning an event, book a tasting consultation at least three months out, especially during the summer wedding surge. For a casual visit, aim for a weekday morning when the cases are fully stocked and the atmosphere is quiet enough to actually chat with the bakers about the daily specials.