Television used to take massive swings. Sometimes those swings resulted in something like Preacher, a show so fundamentally unhinged that it’s honestly a miracle it survived for four seasons on basic cable. Based on the legendary Vertigo comics by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon, the series follows Jesse Custer, a Texas preacher with a criminal past, a drinking problem, and a literal God-sized hole in his heart.
He gets possessed. Not by a demon, but by Genesis—an entity born from the forbidden love between an angel and a demon. This gives Jesse "The Word," the ability to make anyone do exactly what he says. It’s a terrifying power.
Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg, along with showrunner Sam Catlin, didn't just adapt a comic; they built a bloody, blasphemous sandbox. It’s messy. It’s loud. It’s frequently disgusting. But beneath the exploding heads and the vampire drug binges, the Preacher tv series was a deeply human exploration of what it means to actually have faith when the creator of the universe has basically ghosted humanity.
The Problem With Adapting Unadaptable Comics
Everyone said this comic was impossible to film. For years, names like Kevin Smith and Mark Steven Johnson were attached to a potential movie. It was too big, too expensive, and way too offensive for Hollywood's "safe" bets. Then AMC, riding high on The Walking Dead, decided to gamble on it in 2016.
The first season is a weird prequel. It keeps Jesse in the small town of Annville, Texas, even though the comic is a road trip story from page one. Fans were confused. Honestly, the pacing was a bit sluggish at times, but it established the stakes. You’ve got Jesse (Dominic Cooper), his gun-toting ex Tulip O'Hare (Ruth Negga), and a 119-year-old Irish vampire named Cassidy (Joseph Gilgun).
Negga is the soul of this show. While Dominic Cooper does a solid job as the brooding, conflicted Jesse, Negga’s Tulip is a whirlwind of trauma and charisma. She makes you believe that a woman could build a bazooka out of tin cans and moonshine.
Then there’s the Saint of Killers.
He’s the show’s version of the Terminator, but from hell. Played by Graham McTavish, he is a silent, unstoppable force of nature that kills everything in his path. The show treats him with a grim reverence that balances out the slapstick gore. It's this tonal whiplash—going from a goofy fight scene involving a chainsaw to a heartbreaking flashback of 19th-century tragedy—that makes the Preacher tv series so distinct from its peers like The Boys or American Gods.
Why Faith is the Real Villain
Most "religious" shows treat God as a benevolent mystery or a cruel puppet master. Preacher treats Him like a deadbeat dad. Literally. In this universe, God has abdicated the throne because He's bored and wants to be "loved" on His own terms, often while wearing a latex dog suit.
It’s bold.
It’s also why the show works so well as a character study. If God isn't watching, does being "good" even matter? Jesse Custer is trying to be a good man, but he’s naturally a violent one. He uses "The Word" to help people, but he often ends up ruining their lives because he doesn't understand the nuance of human desire. When he tells a man to "open his heart," the guy literally carves his chest open. Jesse’s journey isn't just about finding God to get answers; it's about holding God accountable for the mess He left behind.
This isn't just edgy for the sake of being edgy. It's a critique of organized religion, bureaucracy (represented by The Grail), and the inherent selfishness of the "chosen" few.
The Casting Was Lightning in a Bottle
Let’s talk about Joseph Gilgun.
Without him, the show probably fails. His Cassidy is a tragic figure hidden behind a mask of hedonism and "shite" jokes. He’s the best friend who will help you bury a body but also the guy who will sleep with your girlfriend because he's fundamentally broken. Gilgun brings a vulnerability to the role that wasn't always present in the comics. You feel for him, even when he’s doing something unforgivable.
The chemistry between the core trio—Jesse, Tulip, and Cassidy—is what anchors the insanity. Whether they are trapped in a diner or driving through the desert, their bond feels earned.
- Dominic Cooper: Tense, coiled, and surprisingly funny when playing the straight man.
- Ruth Negga: Deserves every award for making Tulip both terrifying and deeply empathetic.
- Joseph Gilgun: The chaotic neutral heart of the series.
- Pip Torrens: As Herr Starr, he provides some of the best deadpan villainy ever put on screen.
Herr Starr is a masterpiece of character design. The leader of The Grail, an organization dedicated to protecting the bloodline of Jesus (who turns out to be an inbred man named Humperdoo), Starr is a bureaucrat of evil. His hatred for the world's incompetence makes him strangely relatable, even as he’s committing mass genocide.
Season Breakdown: Where it Peaked
The show changed its identity every year.
Season 1 was a slow-burn Southern Gothic. Season 2 turned into a New Orleans road trip with a higher body count. Season 3 went full "voodoo horror" at Angelville, Jesse’s childhood home. Season 4 was the apocalyptic finish line in Australia.
Most critics agree that Season 3 is where the show found its final, most confident form. Bringing in Betty Buckley as Marie L'Angelle (Jesse's grandmother) added a layer of personal stakes that the previous "villains of the week" lacked. The trauma Jesse faced as a child—being drowned in a coffin repeatedly as "discipline"—explains his desperate need for control. It makes his use of Genesis feel less like a superpower and more like a coping mechanism.
Technical Brilliance in the Bloodshed
The action sequences in the Preacher tv series are underrated. Look at the "Angel Fight" in Season 1, Episode 6. It’s a single-take (style) sequence in a cramped motel room where two angels keep respawning every time they are killed. It’s hilarious, inventive, and technically proficient.
The show’s visual palette also deserves a mention. It uses high-contrast colors and wide, cinematic shots that mimic the comic book panels without feeling like a literal carbon copy. Bill Pope, the cinematographer who worked on The Matrix, set the tone for the pilot, and that "graphic" look stuck.
Everything feels dusty, sweaty, and lived-in.
What the Show Got Wrong (and Right) About the Source Material
If you're a comic purist, the Preacher tv series might annoy you. It moves things around. It keeps characters alive longer than they should be and kills others off instantly. It softens some of Jesse’s more "macho" traits to make him more palatable for a modern audience.
But it gets the spirit right.
Garth Ennis’s work is often dismissed as "juvenile," but it’s actually deeply sentimental about friendship and honor. The show keeps that sentimentality. It knows that even if the world is ending and God is a coward, the most important thing is the person standing next to you.
📖 Related: Why Might Guy and Kakashi Hatake are the Best Example of Rivalry in Anime History
The ending of the series is actually more poignant than the comic. It offers a sense of closure that feels earned rather than forced. It doesn't shy away from the fact that these people are "monsters" in their own way, but it grants them a moment of peace that feels like a genuine miracle in a world that usually only offers violence.
Why You Should Rewatch It Now
In an era of sanitized superhero content, Preacher feels like a relic from a wilder time. It doesn't care about being part of a "cinematic universe." It doesn't have a toy line. It just wants to tell a story about a guy, a girl, and a vampire who go on a road trip to beat up the Creator.
It’s cynical. It’s hopeful. It’s messy as hell.
The Preacher tv series remains one of the most daring adaptations ever put on television. If you missed it during its original run, or if you only watched the first season and dropped off because of the pacing, go back. Start with Season 2. Let the madness wash over you. It’s worth it for the Humperdoo tap-dancing scenes alone.
Honestly, we might never get another show this brave—or this weird—again.
Actionable Insights for Your Next Binge:
- Skip the expectations: Do not expect a beat-for-beat remake of the comics. Treat the show as a "remix" that focuses more on character dynamics than plot geometry.
- Focus on the background: The show is packed with "Easter eggs" for comic fans, but also tiny visual gags that reward a second viewing. The Grail’s bureaucracy is particularly funny if you pay attention to the paperwork.
- Start with Season 2 if Season 1 feels slow: If the small-town drama of Annville isn't clicking, Season 2 kicks the "road trip" aspect into high gear immediately.
- Watch for the performances: Even if the plot gets convoluted in Season 4, the acting stays top-tier. Pip Torrens and Ruth Negga carry the later episodes with sheer force of will.
- Check the Soundtrack: The music supervision is incredible, blending classic country with punk and obscure blues that perfectly matches the "Southern Fried" aesthetic.