Honestly, it’s hard to imagine anyone else as Elizabeth Bennet now, but back in 2004, the director almost passed on her. Joe Wright actually thought Keira Knightley was "too pretty" for the part. He wanted someone a bit more ordinary, someone who didn’t fit the "period ideal" of a porcelain beauty.
Then he met her.
She showed up looking like a "scruffy little kid" with a tomboy energy that changed everything. That’s the thing about the Pride and Prejudice Keira Knightley cast—it wasn't about finding the most polished actors. It was about finding people who felt like real, messy humans.
The Drama Behind Casting the Bennet Sisters
You’ve probably seen the movie a hundred times, but did you know half the sisters were basically brand new to the industry?
Carey Mulligan, who is now an Oscar-nominated powerhouse, made her entire acting debut as Kitty Bennet. She was terrified. Meanwhile, Jena Malone, the only American in the core group, had to drive seven hours from Lake Tahoe just to audition for Lydia. She nailed the British accent so well that most people still don't realize she’s from Nevada.
Then there’s Jane. Rosamund Pike was cast specifically because she looked like the "ideal" woman of the time. Funny enough, she actually turned down a role in Harry Potter and the Goblet of Fire (the Rita Skeeter role) just to play Jane Bennet. She felt the sisterly bond was more important.
The chemistry you see on screen wasn't faked. The girls spent three weeks living together and rehearsing in the actual house where they filmed.
They weren't just actors in corsets. They were sisters.
Even the costumes reflected this. Knightley has mentioned that her corset in this film was "mild" compared to the rib-crushing ones she wore in Pirates of the Caribbean. Joe Wright wanted them to be able to run, jump, and walk for miles through the mud.
Why Matthew Macfadyen Almost Quit
Mr. Darcy is supposed to be this untouchable, brooding icon. But Matthew Macfadyen? He felt totally miscast.
He recently admitted that he didn’t really enjoy the filming process because he was so worried he wasn't "dishy" enough. He felt like he wasn't the "hunk" people expected after Colin Firth’s legendary 1995 performance.
It’s kind of ironic. That exact feeling of inadequacy and social awkwardness is what made his Darcy so relatable. He wasn't just being mean; he was painfully shy.
A Few Weird Facts From the Set:
- The Red Flag: Matthew has terrible eyesight. In that famous scene where he walks through the morning fog toward Elizabeth, he couldn't see where he was going. Joe Wright had to stand behind the camera waving a giant red flag so Matthew knew which direction to walk.
- The Hand Flex: That iconic shot where Darcy’s hand flexes after touching Elizabeth’s hand? Completely improvised. Macfadyen just did it, and Wright was smart enough to keep the camera rolling.
- The Teeth Issue: Donald Sutherland, who played Mr. Bennet, was obsessed with the idea that his teeth were "too modern." He was so self-conscious about them that he would often cover his mouth when he laughed on camera.
The Legends in the Room
Getting Donald Sutherland and Judi Dench was a massive win for the production. Sutherland didn't just show up and say his lines. He entered into a massive email correspondence with Joe Wright about the history of agricultural farming in the 18th century. He wanted to know exactly what kind of man Mr. Bennet was.
He also got super protective of "his" daughters. On the day he met the actors playing Darcy and Bingley, he acted cold and jealous. He wasn't being a jerk; he was just staying in character as a father who wasn't ready to give his girls away.
Judi Dench, playing the terrifying Lady Catherine de Bourgh, was exactly as formidable as you’d expect. She actually wrote a letter to Joe Wright asking for the role. When Lady Catherine descends on Longbourn at night to yell at Elizabeth, that scene was shot in the middle of a freezing cold night, but Dench didn't complain once.
💡 You might also like: Cineplex Odeon Courtney Park: What Most People Get Wrong
The Realism of 1797
Most Jane Austen movies are set in 1813, which is when the book was published. But this Pride and Prejudice Keira Knightley cast was placed in 1797.
Why? Because that’s when Austen wrote the first draft.
Joe Wright hated the "chocolate box" look of most period dramas. He wanted mud. He wanted pigs in the house. He wanted people with messy hair and dirty hemlines. This caused a huge stir among "Janeites" (the hardcore fans), who thought the Bennets looked too poor.
But for a modern audience, it worked. It made the stakes feel higher. If these girls didn't get married, they weren't just going to lose a fancy house—they were going to be destitute.
Actionable Tips for Your Next Rewatch
If you want to appreciate the cast even more, try looking for these specific details next time you turn the movie on:
✨ Don't miss: What Genre Is Mom Jeans? The Truth Behind the Most Misunderstood Band in Modern Emo
- Watch the Background: In the Longbourn scenes, look for the "lived-in" details. You’ll see crumbs on the table, unmade beds, and actual laundry. It wasn't a set; it was a real house (Groombridge Place).
- The Hand Flex: Keep an eye on Darcy’s hand after he helps Elizabeth into the carriage. It’s the turning point for his character’s internal struggle.
- The Eye Contact: Notice how Elizabeth and Darcy almost never look at each other directly during the first half of the film. Their chemistry is built entirely on what they don't say.
- The American Ending: If you're in the UK, find the US version of the ending (the "Mrs. Darcy" scene). It’s much sappier, and the cast has mixed feelings about it.
The 2005 adaptation survived the initial "it’s not as good as the 1995 version" criticism to become a classic in its own right. It’s because the cast felt like a family, and that's something you just can't manufacture with a big budget and CGI.
Check out the "making of" features if you can find them. Seeing Keira Knightley practice her nunchuck skills for the movie Domino while wearing a 1790s Regency gown is a mental image you won't soon forget.