You've been paying your student loans for a decade. Or maybe longer. You check your Public Service Loan Forgiveness (PSLF) tracker on the Federal Student Aid (FSA) website, and your heart sinks. You see gaps. Months where you were in deferment or forbearance that don't count toward your 120 required payments. It feels like a punch in the gut because you were working at a non-profit the whole time.
This is where the PSLF buy back comes into play. It’s not some hidden loophole or a scam you’ll find in a sketchy Facebook ad. It is a legitimate, albeit somewhat clunky, process introduced by the Department of Education to help borrowers who were steered into long-term forbearances or deferments instead of being told about income-driven repayment plans.
Basically, if you have months that don't count because of specific "ineligible" statuses, but you were working for a qualifying employer during that time, you might be able to pay the amount you would have owed back then to make those months count now.
It's a game-changer.
What Exactly Is the PSLF Buy Back?
Most people get this confused with the "IDR Account Adjustment" (often called the "Fresh Start" or "Payment Count Adjustment"). They aren't the same thing. While the one-time adjustment automatically gives people credit for certain periods of forbearance or deferment, it doesn't cover everything. Specifically, it often leaves out shorter periods of forbearance or certain types of deferment that happened years ago.
The PSLF buy back allows you to "purchase" those months. You aren't paying your current monthly bill for those old months. Instead, you're paying the amount that would have been due under an income-driven repayment (IDR) plan at that specific time. If your income was $30,000 back in 2014, your "buy back" price for those months might be $0 or something very small.
📖 Related: Do They Still Make 2 Bills? The Truth About the Rarest Note in Your Wallet
You can't just buy back any month you want. There are strict rules. You must have been working full-time for a qualifying employer (like a 501(c)(3) or a government agency) during the months you want to buy. Also, you can only request a buy back if doing so will officially put you at or over the 120-payment mark.
Think of it as the "finish line" tool. You don't use it when you're at 60 payments. You use it when you're at 110 payments and realize those 10 months of "economic hardship deferment" from five years ago could get you to the end immediately.
The Strict Eligibility Gates
Honestly, the Department of Education is pretty picky about this. You can't buy back months if your loans were in an "In-School" status. If you were back in grad school and your loans were paused, those months are gone. You also can't buy back "Grace Period" months—that six-month window after you graduate is effectively a dead zone for PSLF.
What can you buy back?
- Ineligible forbearances (like discretionary or administrative forbearance).
- Ineligible deferments (like those for unemployment or economic hardship).
The catch is that your loans must currently be Direct Loans. If you still have old FFEL (Federal Family Education Loan) program loans, you have to consolidate them into a Direct Consolidation Loan first. But—and this is a huge but—you can only buy back months that occurred after consolidation. If you consolidate today, you cannot use the PSLF buy back for months that happened before today. This is a massive nuance that catches people off guard.
How the Math Actually Works
The government doesn't just guess what you owe. They look at your tax returns from the year in question. If they can't find them, you have to provide them.
Let's look at an illustrative example.
Imagine Sarah. In 2016, Sarah worked for the City of Austin. She was struggling with bills and put her loans into a 12-month forbearance. Today, Sarah has 108 qualifying payments. She needs 12 more. If she uses the PSLF buy back, the Department of Education will look at her 2016 tax return. Because her income was lower back then, they determine her IDR payment would have been $45 a month.
Sarah pays $540 ($45 x 12 months).
Suddenly, her count jumps to 120.
She’s done. Her remaining $40,000 balance is forgiven.
If Sarah's income had been low enough that her IDR payment would have been $0, she still has to go through the buy-back request process, but she won't actually have to send any money. The months will just be updated to "qualifying."
The "One-Time Adjustment" Conflict
A lot of borrowers are waiting for the big IDR Account Adjustment to hit their accounts. The Department of Education has been rolling this out in waves. If you think the automatic adjustment will get you to 120 payments, you should wait.
The PSLF buy back is really meant for the people who have been through the adjustment and still don't have enough payments because their specific type of deferment didn't qualify under the broad rules. It’s the surgical strike for the remaining gaps.
✨ Don't miss: Kansas City Wheat Futures: Why Hard Red Winter Prices Are Actually Moving
The Process is Not Automated
You cannot just click a button on the Mohela or StudentAid.gov dashboard. It’s manual. It’s slow.
You have to submit a PSLF Reconsideration Request. You do this through the StudentAid.gov website. In the description box, you have to explicitly state that you are seeking a PSLF buy back and list the specific months you want to pay for.
Wait times are long. We are talking months.
During this time, you should keep paying your loans if you are still working for a qualifying employer. Why? Because if the buy-back is denied, you don't want to have lost time. If the buy-back is approved and you’ve made "extra" payments since you hit 120, you will eventually get those extra payments refunded.
Why People Fail the Buy Back Request
The biggest reason for rejection is timing. People submit the request when they are at 100 payments, hoping to get to 110. The system will kick it back. You must be able to prove that the bought-back months will result in immediate forgiveness.
Another reason is the "Consolidation Trap." If you consolidated your loans in 2022, you cannot buy back months from 2018. When you consolidate, you create a brand new loan. The "history" of the old loans exists for the one-time adjustment, but for the specific PSLF buy back program, the clock effectively started when that new consolidation loan was born.
🔗 Read more: How to Create a Good Infographic That Actually Gets Clicks
It seems unfair. It kind of is. But those are the current rules under the Higher Education Act interpretations used by the current administration.
Practical Steps to Get Your Forgiveness
Don't just jump into the portal. You need a paper trail.
First, download your "My Student Aid" data file from the FSA website. It’s a giant, confusing text file. You’re looking for the section that lists your "Loan Status History." You need to identify the exact codes—like "FB" for forbearance or "DA" for deferment—and the dates they started and ended.
Compare those dates with your employment certification forms (ECF). If you weren't working for a qualifying employer during those "FB" months, don't even bother. The buy back won't work.
Once you have the dates, check your old tax returns. If you don't have them, you can request a transcript from the IRS. You need to know your Adjusted Gross Income (AGI) from those years to estimate what the "buy back" price will be. If your income was high back then, the buy back might be more expensive than just continuing to work and pay for a few more months now.
The Action Plan:
- Verify your employer: Ensure you have an approved ECF on file for every single month you intend to buy back. If the employment isn't "certified" in the system, the request will be ignored.
- Wait for the adjustment: If you haven't seen the one-time IDR account adjustment applied to your account yet, wait. It might give you those months for free. Most accounts should be updated by the end of 2024 or early 2025.
- Submit the Reconsideration: Go to the StudentAid.gov "Feedback Center." Choose "Public Service Loan Forgiveness Reconsideration."
- Be Specific: In your request, use this phrasing: "I am requesting a PSLF buy back for the following months: [List Months/Years]. I have certified employment for these periods and believe these payments will bring my total count to 120."
- Watch your email: FSA will eventually email you a "Buy Back Offer." You usually only have 30 days to accept it and pay the full amount. If you miss that window, the offer expires.
There is no guarantee this program will exist forever. Administrative changes or court challenges can shift the landscape of student loan forgiveness overnight. If you are eligible now, gathering your documents today is better than waiting until next month. Check your payment counts, find those gaps, and see if the math works in your favor.