It’s one of those movie moments that just feels... off. You’re sitting there, ready for more quippy 1940s adventuring with Rick O'Connell, but then the camera pans to Evelyn. Only, it isn’t Evelyn. Or rather, it isn’t our Evelyn. Seeing Maria Bello step into the role in The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor instead of the woman who defined the character remains a major "what if" in blockbuster history. Even years later, the Rachel Weisz Mummy 3 departure is a sticking point for fans who felt the trilogy lost its soul the second she walked away.
So, why did it happen? If you listen to the rumors, you'll hear everything from "she hated the script" to "she was being a diva about her age." The truth is actually a lot more grounded in real life, though it does involve some classic Hollywood drama.
The Mystery of the Missing Egyptologist
When The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor hit theaters in 2008, the absence of Rachel Weisz was glaring. She had won an Oscar for The Constant Gardener by then. She was a massive star. Brendan Fraser was back, looking as rugged as ever, and John Hannah returned as the lovable, bumbling Jonathan. But the chemistry—that specific, sparky magic between Rick and Evie—was just gone.
Publicly, the "official" word from her representatives was pretty straightforward: scheduling conflicts. She had just finished filming My Blueberry Nights and was moving into The Brothers Bloom. Plus, she had a tiny human to worry about. Her son, Henry, was barely a toddler, and the thought of moving to China for five months of grueling action sequences wasn't exactly a dream scenario for a new mom.
The "Too Old" Controversy
This is where things get spicy. Rob Cohen, the director who took over for Stephen Sommers, didn't exactly stick to the "scheduling" script. In some fairly blunt interviews, Cohen claimed Weisz was actually "furious" about the script. Specifically, he alleged her agent told him she would "never play the mother of a 21-year-old."
Let’s look at the math. In the first film, Evie is a librarian in her 20s. By the third movie, the story jumps forward significantly to find their son, Alex, fully grown and played by Luke Ford. Ford was about 27 at the time of filming. Weisz was 37. You do the math—it's a bit of a stretch, even by Hollywood standards, to have a 37-year-old woman playing the mother of a 27-year-old man. Honestly, she wasn't wrong to think the timeline was a mess.
👉 See also: Chelsey Reist Movies and TV Shows: The Roles You Might Have Missed
Why the Replacement Didn't Stick
Maria Bello is a fantastic actress. Let's get that out of the way. She’s brilliant in A History of Violence and The Cooler. But she wasn't Evelyn Carnahan. The film even tries to hang a lantern on the recast. Early in the movie, Evelyn is at a book signing for her adventure novels. Someone asks if the character in the book is really her, and she replies, "I can honestly say she's a completely different person."
It was a cute meta-joke, but it didn't fix the vibes.
- The Accent: Bello’s British accent felt forced to many viewers, especially compared to Weisz’s natural, effortless poshness.
- The Personality Shift: Weisz played Evie as a "clumsy librarian turned badass." Bello played her as a "polished action star who happened to like books."
- The Chemistry: Brendan Fraser and Rachel Weisz had a genuine, screwball-comedy energy. With Bello, it felt like two actors who had just met in the trailer five minutes before the cameras rolled.
Was the Script Really That Bad?
Looking back, the Rachel Weisz Mummy 3 decision looks like a stroke of genius on her part. The movie was... not great. It traded the charming Egyptian mythology for a CGI-heavy romp through China that featured yetis (yes, really) and a Jet Li who spent most of the movie as a stone statue.
Critics tore it apart. Fans felt betrayed. While it made money globally, it effectively killed the franchise until the ill-fated Tom Cruise reboot years later. Weisz reportedly read the script and simply didn't see the character she loved in those pages. Her Evelyn was a woman of wit and specific scholarly charm; the script for Tomb of the Dragon Emperor turned her into a generic "action wife."
The Career Pivot
While the threequel was flopping, Weisz was busy building a legendary resume. She chose smaller, more artistic projects like The Agora and eventually The Favourite. Looking at her career trajectory, skipping a mediocre sequel to stay home with her kid and work with directors like Yorgos Lanthimos was a massive win.
What You Can Do Now
If you’re still feeling that "what if" sting, there are a few ways to get your fix of that specific era of adventure cinema without subjecting yourself to the third movie again:
Revisit the Originals with New Eyes
The 1999 original is a masterclass in pacing. Watch it again and pay attention to how Weisz uses her physical comedy—her knocking over the library shelves is still one of the best character introductions in cinema history.
Check Out "The Brothers Bloom"
If you want to see what Weisz did instead of Mummy 3, watch Rian Johnson’s The Brothers Bloom. It captures that same whimsical, adventurous spirit that made the first Mummy so good, but with a much more sophisticated script.
🔗 Read more: Travis Scott 90210 Lyrics: What Most People Get Wrong
Follow the Brendan Fraser Renaissance
With Fraser’s recent comeback, there’s been a lot of talk about a "true" Mummy 4. Both Fraser and Weisz have expressed a fondness for their time on the first two films. While nothing is confirmed, the door is more "open" than it’s been in twenty years.
Ultimately, Rachel Weisz leaving the franchise was the first sign that the magic was fading. It serves as a reminder that sometimes, the best way to honor a character is to know when to stop playing them.