You know that feeling when you're watching two people "play nice" in public, but you can practically see the sparks flying? That is the exact energy of the decade-long saga involving James Corden and Ricky Gervais. It isn't just a simple Hollywood spat. It is a slow-burn clash of styles, egos, and comedic philosophies that has played out across Twitter, Netflix specials, and some of the world's biggest awards stages.
Honestly, it’s a bit of a British civil war exported to California. On one side, you have Gervais: the king of the "unfiltered" cringe-comedy movement. On the other, Corden: the musical-theater-loving, high-energy host who dominated late-night TV for years. They seem like they should be mates, right? Both are UK exports who conquered America. Both wrote era-defining sitcoms (The Office and Gavin & Stacey).
But they aren't friends. Not really.
The "Guitar Lesson" Scandal: A Joke Too Far?
The most recent explosion in the James Corden and Ricky Gervais timeline happened in late 2022, and it was a mess. It basically started when Corden delivered a monologue on The Late Late Show about Elon Musk’s Twitter takeover. He used a metaphor about a town square and a sign for "guitar lessons."
It was a good joke. Too good.
People immediately realized it was almost word-for-word a bit from Ricky Gervais’s 2018 Netflix special, Humanity. Gervais himself tweeted out the clip, essentially saying "the bit about the town square is brilliant" with a cheeky laughing emoji. He later deleted it.
Corden eventually apologized on the official show Twitter account. He claimed he "inadvertently" told the joke without knowing it belonged to Ricky. Was it a writer’s mistake? Or did Corden just have the bit stuck in his head from watching Netflix?
Gervais, surprisingly, was kinda chill about it in public. He defended Corden to a degree, suggesting a writer probably pitched it and Corden just delivered it. But the damage to Corden’s reputation, which was already taking hits from the "Balthazar restaurant ban" drama, was pretty massive.
Why the Feud Actually Matters
This isn't just about one stolen joke. It’s about a fundamental difference in how these two guys view comedy.
✨ Don't miss: Why Henry James’s The Portrait of a Lady Still Gets Under Our Skin
Back in 2011, when Corden was hosting the Brit Awards, he went out of his way to say he wouldn't be like Ricky Gervais. Gervais had just hosted the Golden Globes and roasted everyone to a crisp. Corden told the Mirror he wanted to host with "warmth and sensitivity."
Basically, he called Ricky’s style mean.
Ricky didn't forget that. Over the years, he’s taken some brutal swipes at Corden. The most famous one? The 2020 Golden Globes. Ricky stood on that stage and called Corden a "fat p****" in reference to his role in the movie Cats. He added that the world got to see James in the film, but "no one saw it" because the movie bombed so hard.
Brutal.
The Subtle Digs in "After Life"
If you’ve watched Gervais’s show After Life, you might have noticed some characters that feel... familiar. There is a character named James in Season 2 who is an "all-singing, all-dancing" guy who desperately wants to be the center of attention. Fans have long theorized this was a direct parody of Corden’s "theatre kid" energy.
Then there’s a scene where a character mentions having James Corden at a dream dinner party. Gervais’s character, Tony, simply replies, "F*** me."
It’s small stuff. But it’s constant. It feels less like a professional rivalry and more like a genuine personality clash. Gervais prides himself on being the "truth-teller" who doesn't care about being liked. Corden, for most of his career, has built a brand on being the guy everyone wants to sing carpool karaoke with.
Decoding the 2026 Perspective
Looking at James Corden and Ricky Gervais today, the landscape has shifted. Corden has moved back to the UK, stepping away from the nightly late-night grind. Gervais continues to tour and release specials that intentionally push buttons.
What most people get wrong is thinking this is a "fake" feud for PR. It doesn't feel like that. When you look at the timeline—from Corden mocking Gervais in his 2009 sketch show Horne & Corden to the 2023 "Armageddon" jokes—it’s clear there is real friction there.
- 2009: Corden does a parody of Gervais that mocks his laugh and his "Brent" persona.
- 2011: Corden publicly distances himself from Ricky's "mean" hosting style.
- 2017: Gervais criticizes Corden’s Harvey Weinstein jokes at a charity gala, calling them "light entertainment" approach to a serious subject.
- 2020: The "Cats" joke at the Golden Globes.
- 2022: The "Guitar Lesson" plagiarism scandal.
Is There a "Winner" Here?
In the court of public opinion, it's complicated. Gervais has a loyal fanbase that loves his "no-holds-barred" approach. Corden has a massive global reach but has faced a significant "vibe shift" against him in recent years.
Honestly, the "feud" represents two different eras of British comedy. One is the cynical, observational, and often harsh style that defined the 2000s. The other is the polished, celebrity-friendly, high-gloss entertainment of the 2010s.
🔗 Read more: Black Mirror Season 7 Episode 1 Cast: Who Really Stars in Common People
They are like oil and water. They both exist in the same pot, but they are never going to mix.
What You Can Learn From the Drama
If you're a creator or just someone who follows pop culture, there are a few takeaways here:
- Originality is everything. In the age of social media, people will find out if you reuse a joke. Whether it’s an "inadvertent" mistake or not, the internet never forgets.
- Reputation is a house of cards. Corden’s "nice guy" persona made the restaurant and joke-stealing scandals feel much worse because they contradicted his brand.
- Satire is a weapon. Gervais uses his shows to settle scores in a way that is legally safe but incredibly pointed.
If you want to understand the current state of British entertainment, studying the rift between these two is a great place to start. It tells you a lot about what audiences find "authentic" and what they find "performative."
To see the difference for yourself, compare a clip of Corden's 2011 Brit Awards hosting with Gervais's 2020 Golden Globes monologue. The gap between them is wider than the Atlantic.
For the most accurate look at the joke controversy, you should check out the side-by-side comparisons of the "Town Square" bit on YouTube. It's almost eerie how similar the phrasing is. Whether it was a "writing room" error or something else, it remains a fascinating case study in how modern comedy is produced—and how easily it can go wrong.
🔗 Read more: Why the Guns N Roses Metallica Stadium Tour Still Haunts Rock History
Next Steps for the Interested Reader:
You can watch Ricky Gervais's Humanity special on Netflix to see the original "guitar lessons" bit in its full context. Alternatively, looking up the 2009 sketches from Horne & Corden provides the necessary background on where James Corden's side of this friction likely began.