June 3, 1997. Lyon, France. The opening match of Le Tournoi, a warm-up tournament for the upcoming World Cup. Brazil’s left-back, a short, incredibly muscular man named Roberto Carlos, stands over a ball roughly 35 meters (about 115 feet) from the French goal.
He takes a massive run-up. He starts almost at the center circle.
Then, he hits it.
The ball screams off his boot, flies way to the right of the wall, and looks for all the world like it’s headed toward the corner flag—or maybe the photographers. A ball boy sitting ten yards to the right of the goal actually ducks, convinced he’s about to get thwacked.
Then the "impossible" happens.
In mid-air, the ball suddenly hooks. It doesn't just curve; it snaps back toward the goal as if pulled by an invisible string. It clips the inside of the right post and settles in the net. Fabien Barthez, the French goalkeeper, just stands there. He doesn't move. He doesn't even dive. He’s frozen because his brain literally cannot process that a ball moving that fast in that direction could end up there.
For decades, we called it a fluke. But was the Roberto Carlos impossible goal actually a mistake? Honestly, science says no.
The Physics of the Banana Shot
Most people who play soccer understand the basic curve. You hit the side of the ball, it spins, and it bends. This is the Magnus Effect. Basically, as the ball spins, it drags air around with it. On one side of the ball, the spin is moving in the same direction as the airflow, which speeds it up and lowers the pressure. On the other side, the spin fights the airflow, creating high pressure.
The ball gets pushed from high pressure to low pressure. Boom—curve.
But Carlos did something different. He didn't just curve it; he created a spiral.
In 2010, a team of French physicists led by Christophe Clanet and David Quéré published a study in the New Journal of Physics titled "The Spinning Ball Spiral." They used a slingshot to fire plastic balls into a tank of water to track their paths. What they found changed how we look at that 1997 night in Lyon.
They discovered that when a sphere is kicked with enough power and enough spin over a long enough distance, the trajectory isn't actually a circle—it’s a spiral. As the ball slows down due to air resistance, the spin (which decays much slower than the forward velocity) becomes the dominant force. The curve doesn't stay constant; it tightens.
Why Distance Was the Secret Ingredient
If Carlos had been 20 yards out, we wouldn't be talking about this. At that range, the ball is still moving too fast for the spiral to tighten. It would have just looked like a normal, albeit powerful, curling free kick.
💡 You might also like: Union Comercio vs Sporting Cristal: Why This Matchup Always Defies the Odds
Because he was 35 meters out, the ball had enough time to lose speed. That loss of speed is what allowed the Roberto Carlos impossible goal to take that sharp, late turn.
- The Velocity: Estimated at around 105 km/h (65 mph).
- The Spin: Roughly 600 revolutions per minute.
- The Strike: He hit the ball low and to the right with the outside of his left foot (the trivela technique).
Basically, he minimized the contact time with the ball to maximize the "jolt" of energy, giving it enough juice to clear the wall while still holding enough spin to whip back in later.
It Wasn't Just Luck (Mostly)
Carlos himself has been a bit humble about it over the years. He told L'Équipe that he was actually aiming for the "A" in the "La Poste" advertisement behind the goal. He knew that if he hit it hard enough, it might come back.
But he also admitted, "The ball was very light, and there was a bit of wind."
Does that make it a fluke? Sort of. He meant to curve it, but he probably didn't expect it to behave that perfectly. It was the "perfect storm" of technique, atmospheric conditions, and the specific aerodynamics of the Mitre Ultimax ball used at the time.
The Barthez Factor
People often give Fabien Barthez a hard time for not moving. But put yourself in his shoes. Every ounce of his professional experience told him that ball was going out for a goal kick. Human reaction time is fast, but it’s not faster than the laws of physics changing mid-flight. By the time the Magnus Effect took over and the spiral tightened, it was physically too late for a human to bridge that gap.
How You Can Replicate the Technique
If you’re on the pitch and want to try this, don't expect to nail it on the first go. Or the thousandth. But there is a logic to it.
- The Angle: You need a long, straight run-up. Carlos famously took about 18 steps back. This isn't just for show; it builds the momentum needed for that 100+ km/h speed.
- The Contact Point: You aren't hitting the center of the ball. You need to strike the lower right quadrant (if you're a lefty) using the outside of your boot.
- The Follow-Through: You have to "slice" across the ball. If you follow through straight, you get a knuckleball. If you slice it, you get the lateral spin.
- The Distance: Don't try this from the edge of the box. You need at least 30 yards to give the air resistance time to work its magic.
Honestly, even with the physics explained, the Roberto Carlos impossible goal remains the gold standard for set pieces. It’s the bridge between raw athletic power and the weird, beautiful world of fluid dynamics.
✨ Don't miss: NASCAR Race Today on What Channel: Getting Ready for the 2026 Season
To really master this, you have to understand that power is nothing without the right RPM. Most players can hit a ball hard. Many can spin it. Very few can find the exact intersection where a ball becomes a guided missile.
For your next session, focus on the "spiral" rather than just the "curve." It requires a harder, flatter strike than a traditional curled shot. You want the ball to start out flying straight and fast before the air "catches" it. That late movement is what kills goalkeepers.
Practice from distance, watch the wind, and maybe—just maybe—you’ll see that late snap that made Roberto Carlos a legend.
Start by recording your kicks from behind the ball. If you see the ball moving in a straight line for the first 15 yards before it starts to deviate, you're on the right track to recreating the most famous trajectory in football history.