History hasn’t always been kind to the man who hit 61 in '61. Honestly, if you look at the way Roger Maris was treated by the New York press and even his own commissioner, it’s a miracle the guy didn’t just walk away from the game mid-season. He was an introvert trapped in the world's loudest city, a blue-collar kid from North Dakota who just wanted to play right field and go home to his family. Instead, he became the "accidental" villain of 1961 because he dared to challenge a ghost.
Babe Ruth wasn't just a ballplayer; he was a god in pinstripes. When Roger Maris started hitting home runs at a pace that threatened the Sultan of Swat's record of 60, the baseball establishment didn't celebrate. They panicked. They looked at Maris—a guy who didn't drink with the writers, didn't give "sexy" quotes, and wasn't the beloved Mickey Mantle—and they decided he wasn't the "right" person to hold the crown.
The Myth of the Asterisk and the 154-Game Rule
You've probably heard about the asterisk. It's the most famous piece of punctuation in sports history, and yet, it never actually existed in the official record books. Not literally. But the threat of it was real enough to haunt Maris until the day he died.
In July of 1961, Commissioner Ford Frick—who, by the way, was an old friend and ghostwriter for Babe Ruth—made a ruling that felt like a personal attack. He declared that because the American League had expanded its season from 154 games to 162, any player who broke Ruth’s record after the 154-game mark would have their achievement listed with a "distinctive mark." Basically, he tried to pre-cancel the record before it even happened.
Maris was 26 years old. He was a back-to-back MVP (winning in 1960 and 1961). He was a Gold Glove fielder with an absolute cannon for an arm. But the pressure of the chase, combined with the "asterisk" ruling and the relentless hounding of the New York media, took a physical toll. His hair actually started falling out in clumps. Think about that for a second. A professional athlete, at the peak of his physical powers, was so stressed by the public's hatred of his success that his body started failing him.
He hit number 61 on the final day of the season against Tracy Stallard of the Red Sox. The crowd at Yankee Stadium—only about 23,000 people were there, weirdly enough—went wild. But for Maris, it felt less like a triumph and more like a relief. He later said that the season "nearly broke" him.
More Than Just One Season: The Underappreciated Career
The biggest knock on Roger Maris today is that he was a "one-hit wonder." People look at his .260 career batting average and his 275 home runs and say, "Yeah, he had a great year, but he’s not a Hall of Famer." That's a pretty surface-level take.
If you actually dig into the numbers, Maris was a winning machine.
He didn't just play for the Yankees. He was the missing piece that helped the St. Louis Cardinals win the World Series in 1967. In fact, he went to seven World Series in a nine-year span. You don't do that by accident.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Nike Elite Backpack Black and White is Still the King of the Court
- 1960: Wins AL MVP, beats out Mickey Mantle.
- 1961: Hits 61 home runs, wins a second straight MVP.
- 1967: Leads the Cardinals in hitting during the World Series (.385 average) to beat the Red Sox.
He was a "five-tool" player before that was a trendy buzzword. He could run, he was a brilliant situational hitter, and his defense in right field was elite. If a runner tried to take an extra base on Maris, they usually regretted it. He was the ultimate "teammate's teammate." While the fans were booing him because he wasn't Mickey Mantle, Mantle himself was Roger’s biggest supporter. They even lived together for a while in a house in Queens.
Why the Hall of Fame Debate is Changing in 2026
We are currently in an era where we look at "fame" and "impact" differently. For decades, the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA) kept Maris out because his career was relatively short—only 12 seasons. He struggled with injuries, specifically a hand injury that sapped his power in the mid-60s.
But here’s the thing: It’s called the Hall of Fame.
You cannot tell the story of baseball without a massive chapter on Roger Maris. He held the most important record in sports for 37 years. And he did it clean. When Mark McGwire and Sammy Sosa blew past 61 in 1998, it was a circus. Then we found out about the steroids. Suddenly, Maris’s 61 looked a lot more impressive. When Aaron Judge hit 62 in 2022, he went out of his way to pay tribute to the Maris family. Why? Because everyone in the game knows that doing what Roger did, in the era he did it, without any "chemical help," was a monumental feat.
The North Dakota Legend
Roger never really fit the New York mold. He was born in Hibbing, Minnesota, and raised in Fargo. He had a bit of that Midwestern bluntness that New York writers mistook for being "sullen" or "angry."
✨ Don't miss: Why Football Pants Too Revealing Became the NFL’s Most Awkward Gear Crisis
Basically, he didn't like stupid questions.
A reporter once asked him who his favorite singer was. Maris told him he didn't have one. The reporter suggested, "How about I just put down Frank Sinatra?" Maris told him no, because it wouldn't be true. He valued honesty over image, which is a rare trait for a superstar in any era.
He retired at 34 and moved to Gainesville, Florida, where he ran a beer distributorship. He stayed out of the spotlight. He didn't chase the fame he had been denied. It wasn't until 1984, just a year before he died of non-Hodgkin lymphoma, that the Yankees finally retired his number 9 and put him in Monument Park. The plaque there says it all: "Against All Odds."
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors
If you're looking to understand the "real" Roger Maris, you have to look beyond the 1961 stat line. He was a complete ballplayer who was punished for his personality.
- Watch the Postseason Tape: If you can find footage of the 1967 World Series, watch Maris. He wasn't the home run king anymore, but his baserunning and defense were clinic-level.
- Re-evaluate the "Peak" Argument: Many Hall of Famers are in because of their longevity. Maris is a "Peak" candidate. From 1960 to 1962, he was arguably the best all-around player in the American League.
- Visit the Museum: If you're ever in Fargo, North Dakota, there is a Roger Maris Museum in a shopping mall (the West Acres Mall). It sounds weird, but it was Roger's wish that the museum be free and accessible to regular people, not tucked away in a fancy building. It's an incredibly humble tribute to a man who never wanted the crown but wore it anyway.
Roger Maris wasn't a fluke. He wasn't a "lucky" hitter who caught a few breaks. He was a disciplined, powerful, and defensive wizard who happened to have the greatest single season in the history of the sport while everyone was rooting for him to fail.
💡 You might also like: Contra quien juega mexico hoy: Todo lo que debes saber sobre el calendario de la Selección
To truly appreciate the history of the game, stop looking at the career totals for a second. Look at the man who stood at home plate in 1961, his hair falling out from stress, and still swung for the seats because that was his job. That's the legacy worth remembering.
If you want to dive deeper into the statistical side of this era, check out the 1961 American League expansion draft records. It explains a lot about the "diluted pitching" argument that critics used to try and diminish Roger’s 61 home runs—and why that argument doesn't actually hold much water when you see who he was actually hitting those homers against.