Music isn't a math problem. You can't just run an equation and decide that a three-minute pop song from 1964 is objectively "better" than a hip-hop anthem from 1989. But that hasn't stopped everyone from trying. When the Rolling Stone greatest 500 songs list first dropped back in 2004, it felt like a holy text for Boomers. It was heavy on the Beatles, Bob Dylan, and the Rolling Stones. Basically, if it didn't have a guitar solo or a harmonica, it probably wasn't in the top ten.
Then 2021 happened.
The magazine realized the world had moved on from the "old white guard" of rock and roll. They blew the whole thing up. They invited over 250 artists, producers, and critics—everyone from Angelique Kidjo to Zedd—to vote on a brand-new ranking. Honestly, the results were a total shock to the system for anyone who grew up thinking "Like a Rolling Stone" was the undisputed king of music.
The 2021 Shakeup: Out With the Old?
The most jarring change wasn't just the songs themselves, but the philosophy. In the original 2004 version, Bob Dylan’s “Like a Rolling Stone” sat comfortably at number one. It felt permanent. But in the updated version, Dylan got bumped down to number four.
The new champion? Aretha Franklin’s “Respect.” It’s a move that makes sense if you look at cultural impact rather than just "rock history." Aretha didn't just sing a song; she claimed a standard. But the shifts didn't stop at the top. The new list leaned hard into hip-hop, R&B, and even Latin pop. We’re talking about Public Enemy’s “Fight the Power” jumping all the way to number two.
🔗 Read more: Person to Person Cast: Why This Indie Roster Still Hits Different
A lot of purists lost their minds. They saw it as "woke" revisionism. But if you look at the data, the 2021 list just finally acknowledged that music didn't die in 1979. More than half the songs on the new list—254 to be exact—weren't even on the original 2004 version.
Who actually made the top 10?
If you're looking for the heavy hitters, the current top ten is a wild mix of eras:
- Aretha Franklin – "Respect"
- Public Enemy – "Fight the Power"
- Sam Cooke – "A Change Is Gonna Come"
- Bob Dylan – "Like a Rolling Stone"
- Nirvana – "Smells Like Teen Spirit"
- Marvin Gaye – "What’s Going On"
- The Beatles – "Strawberry Fields Forever"
- Missy Elliott – "Get Ur Freak On"
- Fleetwood Mac – "Dreams"
- Outkast – "Hey Ya!"
Notice anything? The Beatles are still there, but they’ve been joined by Missy Elliott and Outkast. It’s a broader tent.
The "TikTok Effect" and Modern Classics
Believe it or not, the Rolling Stone greatest 500 songs list now reflects how we actually listen to music today—which includes social media. Take Fleetwood Mac’s “Dreams.” Back in 2004, it wasn't even in the top ten. Fast forward to the 2021 update, and it’s sitting at number nine.
📖 Related: Jerry Springer Season 1: What Most People Get Wrong About the Show's Origins
Why? A guy on a skateboard with a bottle of cranberry juice.
When Nathan Apodaca’s TikTok went viral in 2020, "Dreams" didn't just trend; it became a cross-generational staple again. The voters for the new list clearly felt that. It shows that "greatness" isn't just about what happened in a recording studio in 1977, but how a song lives in the culture right now.
We’re also seeing more non-English tracks. Daddy Yankee’s “Gasolina” made the cut at number 50. In the 2004 version, the only non-English song was "La Bamba." That’s a massive shift in how the industry views "global" music. It’s not just a niche anymore; it’s the center of the plate.
The songs that got "snubbed" or demoted
Not everyone survived the reboot. Some absolute classics took a massive hit:
- The Righteous Brothers’ “You’ve Lost That Lovin’ Feelin’” – It was number 34 in 2004. In 2021? It vanished from the top 500 entirely.
- The Clash’s “London Calling” – It dropped from number 15 all the way down to 143.
- Ray Charles’ “Georgia on My Mind” – Another massive fall from grace in the eyes of the new voters.
Is "London Calling" suddenly a worse song than it was twenty years ago? Of course not. But the Rolling Stone greatest 500 songs isn't a static museum. It’s a snapshot of what 250 industry experts think matters now. If you’re a 22-year-old producer today, you might find more inspiration in the production of Robyn’s “Dancing on My Own” (No. 20) than in a 1950s ballad.
How the list actually happens (It's not just one guy)
People love to yell at Rolling Stone as if one editor is sitting in a dark room picking their favorites. That’s not how it works.
They use a huge ballot system. Each of the 250+ voters (including people like Questlove, Lorde, and H.E.R.) submits a ranked list of their top 50 songs. Rolling Stone then tabulates the points. It’s basically a massive popularity contest among the people who actually make and write about music.
Because it's a committee, you get some weird results. It skews toward the "consensus" picks. This is why you see The Beatles appearing 11 times on the current list. Everyone can agree The Beatles are great, so they get a lot of mid-level votes that add up.
📖 Related: Why Power TV Series Season 2 Is Still The Show's Absolute Peak
The 2024 "Mini-Update"
Just when people were getting used to the 2021 list, a 2024 revision slipped in. It wasn't a total ground-up rebuild, but it added some 2020s hits that already felt like "all-time" material.
Harry Styles’ “As It Was” and Lana Del Rey’s “A&W” made appearances. It’s a way of keeping the list "living." If they waited another 17 years to update it, the list would be hopelessly out of touch. They're trying to avoid the trap of being a legacy-only brand.
Actionable Insights for Music Nerds
If you really want to understand why the Rolling Stone greatest 500 songs looks the way it does, don't just look at the ranks. Look at the "why."
- Listen to the top 50 in order. You’ll notice the transition from the civil rights anthems of the 60s to the hip-hop revolution of the 80s and 90s.
- Compare the 2004 vs. 2021 versions. It’s a fascinating look at how our cultural values have shifted from "Rock is King" to "Pop/Hip-Hop is the Global Language."
- Check the producer credits. A lot of the songs that climbed the most (like Missy Elliott or Outkast) are there because their production changed music forever, not just the lyrics.
The list is always going to be wrong. That’s the point. It’s meant to start a fight at a bar or a long thread on Reddit. Whether you think Nirvana deserves number five or Beyoncé should be higher, the fact that we’re still arguing about it proves these 500 songs actually did something.
Go find a song on the list you’ve never heard of—maybe something from the 1930s like Robert Johnson’s “Cross Road Blues” (No. 481)—and see if you can hear why it still matters nearly a century later. You might be surprised.
Next Steps:
- Create a "Top 50" playlist based on the 2021 rankings to hear the sonic evolution for yourself.
- Research the 250 voters to see whose musical taste aligns with yours before dismissing their choices.
- Compare the most-represented artists like The Beatles and David Bowie to see how their "lesser" hits fared in the new voting system.