You’ve probably driven past it a dozen times if you live on the South Shore. It’s quiet. Honestly, if you didn’t know the history of Sandy Ground Staten Island NY, you might just think it’s another leafy neighborhood near Rossville. But it isn't. Not even close. This tiny patch of land represents something massive—the oldest continuously inhabited free Black settlement in the entire United States.
Think about that for a second.
✨ Don't miss: Current Road Conditions in Denver: What Most Drivers Get Wrong This Winter
Long before the Civil War ended, and well before the Great Migration changed the face of Northern cities, a group of free African Americans was building a self-sufficient powerhouse right here. They weren't just surviving; they were thriving. They owned land. They built churches. They created an industry that literally fed New York City.
The Oystermen Who Built a Legacy
It all started around 1828. Captain John Jackson, a free Black man, bought land in the area. Soon after, New York State abolished slavery (fully) in 1827, and the community began to swell. But the real catalyst wasn't just freedom—it was oysters.
Southern states like Maryland and Virginia were making life increasingly impossible for free Black people. Laws were tightening. Tensions were high. Many of these families were skilled oystermen from the Chesapeake Bay. They saw an opportunity in the rich, brackish waters of the Arthur Kill and the Raritan Bay. So, they moved.
Families like the Landins, the Purnells, and the Robbinses brought their boats and their expertise to Staten Island. They planted oyster beds. They harvested. They sold their catch at the foot of Manhattan. It was backbreaking work, but it bought them something rare: total independence.
By the mid-1800s, Sandy Ground was a bustling hub. It wasn't just a place to live; it was an economic engine. The community was centered around the Rossville A.M.E. Zion Church, which was founded in 1850. The church was—and still is—the heartbeat of the neighborhood. It served as a school, a meeting house, and a spiritual anchor. During the dark years of the Fugitive Slave Act, it’s widely believed that Sandy Ground served as a stop on the Underground Railroad. It makes sense. It was a community of people who knew the water, knew the woods, and looked out for their own.
What Most People Get Wrong About Sandy Ground
People often assume Sandy Ground was a "refugee camp" or a place of poverty. That’s a total misconception.
The residents were landowners. In a time when property ownership was the ultimate key to political and social power, the people of Sandy Ground were ahead of the curve. They had a post office. They had a blacksmith shop. They had a schoolhouse.
It was a middle-class community.
They weren't hiding from the world; they were engaging with it on their own terms. When the New York City Draft Riots of 1863 turned Manhattan into a war zone for Black residents, many fled to Staten Island. Sandy Ground offered a level of security that didn't exist in the city. You had a community of armed, organized, and economically stable families. That changes the dynamic.
The Decline of the Oyster
Nothing lasts forever, though. By the early 20th century, the very thing that built Sandy Ground began to fail.
Industrialization was a double-edged sword. As factories popped up along the Jersey shore and Staten Island’s waterfront, the water got dirty. Pollution started killing the oyster beds. Then came the typhoid outbreaks linked to contaminated shellfish. In 1916, the health department stepped in and shut down the industry for good.
It was a devastating blow.
Imagine your entire local economy vanishing overnight. Some families stayed and turned to farming—Sandy Ground became known for its strawberries and pears—but the "Golden Age" was over. Then came the fires. The infamous 1963 brush fire on Staten Island destroyed several historic homes in the area. It was a miracle the church survived.
Seeing Sandy Ground Today
If you go there now, you have to look closely. The modern world has pushed right up against the edges of history.
The Sandy Ground Historical Society is located on Woodford Road. It’s run by descendants of the original settlers. Sylvia D'Alessandro, who served as the longtime executive director, is a direct link to that past. When you walk through the museum, you aren't looking at generic artifacts. You’re looking at the actual tools used by the oystermen. You’re seeing the quilts made by the women who lived there 150 years ago.
The church, now known as African Methodist Episcopal Zion Church, still stands as a powerful monument. It was designated a New York City Landmark in 2011. Standing in front of it, you get a sense of the permanence these families achieved. They weren't just passing through. They planted roots in the sandy soil—hence the name—and refused to be moved.
Why It Still Matters in 2026
We talk a lot about "Black Excellence" today. Sandy Ground is the blueprint for it.
It’s a story of environmental history, economic grit, and architectural preservation. But mostly, it's a story about the South Shore of Staten Island that usually gets ignored in favor of the borough's later, more suburban narrative.
There are challenges, obviously. Development is constant. Land values in New York City are insane, and keeping a historic district intact is a constant battle against developers who want to put up townhomes. The Sandy Ground Historical Society works tirelessly to ensure that the stories don't get buried under new asphalt.
Realities of Visiting and Preservation
If you’re planning to visit, keep a few things in mind. This is still a residential neighborhood. People live here. It’s not a theme park.
👉 See also: Skiing Into the Ocean: What Makes the Camden Snow Bowl Actually Different
- The Museum: Check the hours before you go. It’s a small, community-run operation. It's best to call ahead.
- The Cemetery: The cemetery is one of the most moving parts of the site. Seeing the names on the headstones that match the names in the history books is a surreal experience.
- The Architecture: Some of the original homes are still standing, like the Reverend Isaac Coleman and Mary Elizabeth Coleman House. They are private residences, so be respectful.
Is it "hidden"? Sorta. But it shouldn't be.
Sandy Ground represents a version of the American Dream that was carved out of necessity and defended with iron wills. It's a reminder that Staten Island’s history is far more diverse and complex than the stereotypes suggest. It’s about more than just the ferry or the mall. It’s about a group of people who looked at a patch of sandy land and saw a future.
Practical Steps for History Buffs and Locals
Don't just read about it; go see it.
Start by visiting the Sandy Ground Historical Society. They often host events, especially during Black History Month, but the history is there all year. Support the museum through donations or by purchasing their publications. Small local museums live or die on community support.
Second, advocate for the preservation of Staten Island’s historic sites. The city's Landmarks Preservation Commission is the main gatekeeper here. Keep an eye on their agendas.
Finally, if you’re a teacher or a parent, bring the kids. Most NYC schools focus heavily on Manhattan’s history. Showing them that a major piece of the American story is right in their own borough—on the South Shore, no less—changes their perspective on where they live.
The oyster beds are gone, and the strawberry fields have mostly been paved over. But the spirit of Sandy Ground Staten Island NY is still very much alive in the families that remain and the stones of the church that refuses to crumble.
To truly understand Staten Island, you have to understand the sand. You have to understand how a group of people took a marginal piece of land and turned it into a sanctuary of freedom and a powerhouse of industry. It’s a story of survival, yes, but more importantly, it’s a story of success. It's a legacy that deserves to be known by every New Yorker.
Actionable Next Steps
- Visit the Site: Navigate to 1538 Woodrow Rd, Staten Island, NY 10309. This is the heart of the community and the location of the Historical Society.
- Contact the Society: Call (718) 317-5796 to verify museum hours or schedule a guided tour for a group.
- Explore the Archives: Look into the "Sandy Ground Collection" at the Schomburg Center for Research in Black Culture if you want to dig into the primary source documents and photographs.
- Support Local Preservation: Follow the Friends of Sandy Ground on social media to stay updated on preservation efforts and community festivals.