Sarah Casalan Bittle: What Most People Get Wrong About Modern Retail Leadership

When you think of a corporate president, you probably imagine someone in a high-rise office, buried in spreadsheets and ivory-tower strategies. Sarah Casalan Bittle isn't that person. Honestly, she’s the kind of leader who would rather be behind a counter than behind a mahogany desk.

In late 2021, when she took the helm at The UPS Store, she didn't just send out a memo. She went to work. Not in the executive suite, but in a local store. She spent a week doing the actual labor—packing boxes, handling returns, and seeing the friction points that don't show up on a quarterly report. It was there, while staring at a mountain of outdated 1980s-era training binders, that she realized the brand needed a massive digital overhaul.

She saw the binders. She laughed. Then she fixed it.

The Reality of Leading 5,000+ Franchises

Leading a massive network isn't just about logistics. It’s about people. Sarah Casalan Bittle understands that the "magic" happens over the counter. If a worker is stressed because they don't know how to handle a complex return, the customer feels it.

🔗 Read more: Dow Jones Biggest Losers Today: Why Banks and Tech are Tanking

Her background is deep in retail. Before joining UPS, she held major roles at Crate and Barrel and J. Crew. She knows the "omni-channel" world inside and out. But retail at this level is shifting. It’s no longer just about selling products; it’s about solving problems in three minutes or less.

Why Diversity Drives the Bottom Line

A lot of companies treat diversity like a checkbox. For Sarah, it’s basically a business survival tactic. She has pushed for a "virtuous feedback loop" where a more diverse range of franchisees leads to better insights.

• Feedback from the front lines: Store owners in different communities see different problems.
• Design changes: Modernized store layouts came directly from franchisee input.
• Community roots: Over 84% of the U.S. population lives within 10 miles of a UPS Store.

She often talks about small businesses being the backbone of the economy. It sounds like a cliché, but when you realize these businesses account for 40% of U.S. economic activity, the weight of her role becomes clear.

The Heart Attack That Changed Everything

Success isn't always about the climb. Sometimes, it’s about the pauses. Sarah Casalan Bittle has been incredibly open about a life-altering event: a massive heart attack.

Her heart, lungs, and brain function literally stopped. It’s the kind of "widow-maker" event that few people walk away from. But she did. After undergoing robotic-assisted bypass surgery at the University of Chicago Medicine, she didn't just return to work—she returned with a different perspective.

She’s now a major advocate for the American Heart Association. She chairs the Heart Challenge in Chicago. Why? Because she realized that women often present symptoms differently than men. She didn't know the signs. Now, she makes sure others do.

"Knowledge bears responsibility," she often says.

👉 See also: Reading the Tape: Why This Old-School Skill Still Dominates Modern Trading

This brush with mortality changed her leadership style. She’s still urgent. She’s still driven. But there’s a new focus on empathy and "assessing situations with professionals who know what they're doing." It’s a less ego-driven way to lead.

Moving Beyond the "Happy Path"

Most tech platforms are designed for when things go right. Sarah wants systems built for when things go wrong. She’s pushed for self-serve, automated solutions that handle the messy parts of e-commerce.

Take the "Happy Returns" partnership. Returns are the bane of modern retail. By focusing on "no box, no label" consolidated returns, she’s leaned into the shipping-return addiction that defines 2026.

It’s about efficiency. It’s about not making a customer wait ten minutes to drop off a pair of shoes that didn't fit.

Breaking the 1980s Legacy

One of her biggest wins was killing those training binders. In 2024, the company launched a digital, mobile-friendly training system. It sounds small. It’s actually huge. It allows a new employee to get up to speed in hours, not weeks.

She also reduced the workload for franchise consultants. They used to oversee 35+ stores. Now it’s under 30. That means more face time. More support. More "unstoppable" growth, as the brand likes to say.

What Most People Get Wrong

People think The UPS Store is just a place to mail a birthday card. Sarah sees it as a tech-enabled hub for entrepreneurs. Under her leadership, the brand has explored:

1. Smart Lockers: For 24/7 package pickup.
2. Digital Menu Boards: To keep services clear and transparent.
3. The Metaverse: Launching the "Helping You Be Unstoppable Store" to provide digital advice to small business owners.

It’s a blend of high-tech and high-touch. You can’t have one without the other in this landscape.

Actionable Takeaways for Leaders

Sarah’s trajectory offers a blueprint for modern management. If you're trying to scale a business or lead a team, look at her playbook.

Do the "In-Store" Week
Don't just read reports. Go to the floor. If you're a software lead, use the buggy version of your app for a day. If you run a restaurant, wash the dishes. You'll find the "binders" that are slowing your people down.

🔗 Read more: Office Christmas Gifts: Why Most People Get It Totally Wrong

Prioritize Self-Service for "Un-Happy" Paths
Design your customer service for when things break. Everyone is nice when the product works. Who are you when the package is lost?

Embrace the Personal Pivot
Your health and personal life aren't "distractions" from your career—they are the context for it. Sarah’s advocacy for heart health didn't make her a weaker president; it made her a more relatable and focused one.

Shorten the Feedback Loop
Empower your "middle" layer. By reducing the number of stores each consultant manages, Sarah ensured that information flows up and down the chain faster.

The UPS Store is currently ranking at the top of franchise lists for a reason. It isn't just the brand name. It’s the shift from a 20th-century "postal center" to a 21st-century "business engine." Sarah Casalan Bittle is the one holding the keys to that engine.

For those looking to get involved in franchising or improve their own leadership, the next step is clear. Evaluate your current systems for "legacy rot"—those processes you do just because "that's how it's always been done." If it’s a binder in a digital world, throw it out.