He was supposed to be the best of them. When the Valar sent the Istari—the Wizards—to Middle-earth to deal with the growing shadow of Sauron, they didn't send Saruman as a backup. He was the leader. The chief. The smartest guy in the room. But if you’ve only watched the movies, you might think Saruman from Lord of the Rings was just a secondary villain who got bossed around by a flaming eyeball.
That’s not the whole story. Not even close.
Saruman the White, or Curunír as the Elves called him, wasn't born evil. He wasn't even a man. He was a Maia, a powerful spirit-being from the same "order" as Sauron himself, though a bit lower in the cosmic hierarchy. Imagine being sent on a mission to save the world, only to realize you’re better at running it than the people you’re supposed to help. That’s the core of Saruman’s tragedy. It’s a slow-burn disaster of ego and industrialization that still feels uncomfortably relevant today.
The Pride of the White Council
Saruman didn't just wake up one day and decide to breed Uruk-hai. For centuries, he was the primary defender of the West. He was the one who studied the arts of the Enemy when nobody else wanted to touch them. Tolkien makes it clear that Saruman’s greatest strength—his deep, encyclopedic knowledge of the Rings of Power—became his ultimate undoing. He looked into the abyss for too long.
Think about it. You’re the head of the White Council. You’ve got Galadriel and Elrond looking up to you for strategic advice. And then there’s Gandalf. Everyone loves Gandalf. Even Círdan the Shipwright gave Gandalf Narya, the Ring of Fire, instead of giving it to you. That’s gotta sting. J.R.R. Tolkien notes in The Unfinished Tales that Saruman’s jealousy of Gandalf started almost the moment they set foot in Middle-earth around the year 1000 of the Third Age. He hid it well, but the resentment simmered for two thousand years.
He became obsessed with the Ring because he thought he could use it for good. Or at least, his version of good. Saruman’s "good" looked a lot like perfect order. He wanted a world that was organized, efficient, and managed by him. If you look at his takeover of Isengard, he didn't start by burning things. He started by fortifying. He turned a beautiful, green valley into a machine of war because he believed that "Knowledge, Rule, Order" were the only ways to stop Sauron. He was wrong.
The Palantír and the Trap of Certainty
One of the biggest misconceptions about Saruman from Lord of the Rings is that he was Sauron's puppet. He wasn't. At least, he didn't think he was. When Saruman started using the Palantír of Orthanc—the seeing stone—he thought he was gathering intel. He was a master of "The Voice," a literal magical power that made people believe whatever he said. He thought he could outmaneuver a Dark Lord.
But the Palantír is a dangerous tool. Sauron had the Ithil-stone, and he used it to show Saruman exactly what he wanted him to see. He showed him the vast armies of Mordor. He showed him the inevitability of the West's defeat. Saruman, being a man of logic and "reason," looked at the data and concluded that victory was impossible.
He didn't "join" Sauron out of loyalty. He joined out of a calculated, cynical belief that it was the only way to survive. He planned to betray Sauron eventually. He wanted the One Ring for himself so he could overthrow the Dark Lord and rule as a "benevolent" dictator. It’s the classic "lesser of two evils" trap that people fall into every single day.
The Voice of Saruman: Why Words Mattered More than Magic
In The Two Towers book, there’s a whole chapter titled "The Voice of Saruman." It’s arguably the most important look at his character. Even after his armies are destroyed at Helm’s Deep and Isengard is underwater, he almost wins the argument just by talking.
His voice wasn't just loud or commanding. It was persuasive. It made you feel like he was the only wise person in the room and you were a total idiot for disagreeing. He didn't need to throw fireballs—though he probably could. He used rhetoric. He used half-truths. He told the Men of Rohan that they were being used by the Elves and the "meddling" Gandalf. It’s a masterclass in gaslighting.
- He wore robes that looked white but were actually woven of many colors (Saruman of Many Colors).
- He abandoned the purity of his mission for a "rainbow" of complexity that was actually just chaos.
- He broke his staff—not just a piece of wood, but a symbol of his divine authority.
The tragedy here is that Saruman was once truly great. He was the one who convinced the Council to attack Dol Guldur in 2941. He actually did help drive Sauron out for a time. But he was playing a double game even then, hoping the Ring would reveal itself in the chaos.
The Scouring of the Shire: The Petty End of a Maia
Most people who only know Saruman from the movies are shocked to find out how he actually dies. In Peter Jackson's The Return of the King (Extended Edition), he’s stabbed by Gríma Wormtongue on top of Orthanc. It’s a dramatic, cinematic death.
But in the book? It’s much more pathetic. And much more human.
After the War of the Ring is essentially over, Saruman sneaks off to the Shire. He doesn't go there to conquer the world; he goes there to be a neighborhood bully. He calls himself "Sharkey." He destroys the Hobbits' trees, ruins their economy, and turns their idyllic home into a mini-industrial wasteland. It’s pure spite.
🔗 Read more: Billie Eilish Wallpaper Laptop: Why the Aesthetic Matters
When you lose your grand dreams of being a God-King, sometimes all that’s left is the desire to break someone else’s toys. He dies on the doorstep of Bag End, his throat slit by a broken man he’d spent years abusing. His spirit rises like a gray mist, looking toward the West (Valinor), but a cold wind blows it away. He is denied return. He becomes nothing. A lingering, powerless ghost.
Why We Should Care About Saruman in 2026
Saruman represents the danger of the "intellectual elite" who lose their empathy. He’s the person who thinks that because they understand the mechanics of the world, they have the right to dictate how everyone else lives.
Isengard is the ultimate symbol of environmental destruction for the sake of "progress." He cut down the ancient forests of Fangorn to stoke the fires of his forges. He didn't care about the Ents or the history of the land; he only cared about the output. Sound familiar? Tolkien, who hated the industrialization of the English countryside, put all of his fears into Saruman.
He is the warning that knowledge without wisdom is a death sentence.
Getting the Most Out of the Lore
If you really want to understand the depth of Saruman from Lord of the Rings, don't just stop at the main trilogy. There’s a lot of nuance tucked away in the appendices and other texts.
- Read "The Voice of Saruman" in The Two Towers. Pay attention to how he manipulates the King of Rohan. It's a lesson in psychological warfare.
- Check out The Silmarillion. Specifically the section "Of the Rings of Power and the Third Age." It explains the backstory of why the Wizards were sent in the first place.
- Compare him to Denethor. Both were corrupted by using Palantíri, but in different ways. Denethor fell into despair; Saruman fell into ambition.
- Re-watch the "Scouring of the Shire" concept. Even if it's not in the movies, understanding that Saruman ended up as a small-time crook in a vest helps contextualize how far his ego fell.
Saruman’s fall isn't a straight line. It’s a series of small compromises. He thought he was the hero of his own story until the very moment his spirit was blown away by the wind. He’s a reminder that even the brightest light can be extinguished if it stops reflecting the truth and starts trying to be the sun.
To truly grasp the character, look at your own "Isengards"—those places where you might be sacrificing your values for the sake of efficiency or "the win." Saruman's story is a mirror. It's not a comfortable one to look into.
Next time you see him on screen or read his dialogue, listen for the pride. It’s in every word.
Actionable Insights for Tolkien Fans:
- Analyze the Rhetoric: Study the "Voice of Saruman" to recognize real-world logical fallacies and manipulative speech patterns.
- Explore the Geography: Use a map of Middle-earth to trace the strategic importance of Isengard; it wasn't just a tower, it was a choke point for the entire Gap of Rohan.
- Deep Dive into the Istari: Research the other two "Blue Wizards" (Alatar and Pallando) to see how Saruman’s failure compared to the rest of his order.