Ever wonder what actually goes on when a bunch of guys in green jackets sit down to eat? It's not just polite clapping and golf talk. Honestly, it’s one of the most guarded traditions in sports. When you win the Masters, you don't just get a trophy and a paycheck; you get the bill for the most exclusive dinner party on the planet. For the second time in three years, the Scottie Scheffler Champions Dinner took center stage at Augusta National, and let's just say, the menu was very "Scottie."
He didn't go for the caviar or the pretentious tiny portions. He went for the stuff you'd find at a Texas backyard bash or a high-end sports bar.
The 2025 "Papa Scheff" Special
Following his second win in 2024, Scheffler had to host again in April 2025. If you think a guy with his bank account would hire a Michelin-starred chef to reinvent the wheel, you don't know Scottie. He basically ran back the hits from his 2023 dinner but added some deeply personal—and slightly hilarious—tweaks.
The standout addition? Papa Scheff’s Meatball and Ravioli Bites.
There's actually a bit of a "bloody" backstory here. Back in December 2024, Scottie was at home making homemade ravioli for Christmas dinner. He wasn't just cooking; he was committed. But things went south when a wine glass broke, and he ended up slicing his hand so badly he needed surgery and had to miss the start of the 2025 season.
Including ravioli on the menu wasn't just about the taste; it was a self-deprecating nod to the injury that nearly derailed his year. During the press conference leading up to the meal, he joked that he hoped the club staff would cut his steak for him so he wouldn't have to use a knife.
What was on the 2025 menu?
- Appetizers: The "Scottie-style" cheeseburger sliders (which means fries are literally inside the burger), firecracker shrimp with sriracha mayo, and the famous meatball/ravioli bites.
- First Course: Texas-style chili. This was a change-up from his 2023 tortilla soup. Fun fact: the recipe actually came from his longtime swing coach, Randy Smith.
- Main Event: A choice between wood-fired cowboy ribeye or blackened redfish.
- The Sides: Family-style mac and cheese, jalapeno creamed corn, soy-glazed Brussels sprouts, and chipotle-lime roasted sweet potatoes.
- Dessert: A warm chocolate chip skillet cookie with vanilla bean ice cream.
Why "Scottie Style" Actually Matters
You might think putting fries on a burger is a small detail. It’s not. It’s a window into why Scheffler is so dominant right now. He knows what he likes, and he doesn't care if it’s "proper."
The Masters Club (the official name of the dinner) is filled with legends like Jack Nicklaus, Tiger Woods, and Gary Player. These guys have seen everything. When Nick Faldo served fish and chips in 1997 or Sandy Lyle served haggis in 1989, it was a statement of heritage. When Scottie serves cheeseburgers, it’s a statement of comfort.
It’s also about the vibe. Past champions have mentioned that the 2023 dinner had some tension because it was the first time the LIV Golf guys and the PGA Tour loyalists were in the same room. But by 2025? The food—and Scottie’s "freewheeling" speech style—seemed to bridge the gap.
"I usually will write a few things down that I want to say to the guys and outside of that, I don't know if I'll talk for 10 minutes or two," Scheffler said before the event.
✨ Don't miss: Is the BYU football game tonight actually happening or are we just staring at an empty schedule?
The Spice Controversy
Not everyone has a palate for Texas heat. In 2023, his tortilla soup was apparently so spicy it had some of the older legends reaching for their water. 2016 champ Danny Willett famously joked that he asked Scottie if he was "trying to kill us."
For the 2025 Scottie Scheffler Champions Dinner, he swapped the soup for chili, but he didn't exactly tone it down. The chili was loaded with jalapenos. 1979 winner Fuzzy Zoeller reportedly joked about calling the fire department.
It’s these little interactions that make the night legendary. There are no cameras. No cell phones. Just thirty-odd guys who have conquered the most famous golf course in the world, sitting in a room called the Library, drinking high-end Napa Valley wine (Scheffler chose a 2011 Vineyard 7 & 8 Cabernet) and making fun of each other's food choices.
The Real Cost of Winning
The champion pays for everything. The food, the wine, the service. While Augusta National’s kitchen staff handles the heavy lifting, the host is the one who signs the check. For a menu this extensive—serving 32 past champions—you’re looking at a bill that would make most people wince. But when you’ve just won a multi-million dollar purse and a lifetime exemption to the Masters, the price of a few dozen ribeyes is probably the last thing on your mind.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Aspiring Hosts
If you want to bring a bit of the Masters tradition to your own table, here is how you can replicate the Scheffler experience without the green jacket:
- Master the "Scottie Style" Slider: Use thin patties, plenty of cheese, and a small handful of salty, thin-cut fries tucked right under the top bun. Use a brioche bun to keep it from getting too soggy.
- The Secret to the Chili: Scheffler’s coach, Randy Smith, is the source of the chili recipe. The key is the balance of heat and heartiness—don't be afraid of the jalapenos, but serve it with plenty of cheddar and corn chips on the side to provide texture.
- The Skillet Cookie: This is the easiest part to replicate. Use a high-quality semi-sweet chocolate and serve it while the center is still slightly gooey. The contrast between the hot cookie and cold vanilla bean ice cream is the "secret sauce."
- Embrace the Nostalgia: Scheffler’s menu worked because it was authentic to his life. If you’re hosting a big event, don’t try to be fancy. Serve the meal that actually means something to you, whether that's your dad’s meatballs or a specific regional dish from your hometown.
Winning the Masters is hard. Hosting the dinner might be even more stressful for a guy who just wants to play golf. But Scottie Scheffler has proven that you can stay true to your Texas roots even in the most prestigious room in sports.
📖 Related: Who Was Vikings QB Last Year: The Chaotic Reality of Minnesota’s 2025 Season
To truly appreciate the legacy of these dinners, keep an eye on the winners of the upcoming majors; their culinary choices often reflect the mental state of a champion: relaxed, confident, and unapologetically themselves.