If you were watching the Seattle Seahawks vs Indianapolis Colts game back in December 2025, you probably felt like you were witnessing some sort of glitch in the matrix. It was one of those games that makes modern football look like a 1940s mud bowl, but with the high-speed intensity of the 2020s. No touchdowns for the home team? A 44-year-old quarterback coming out of the literal retirement home to nearly steal a road win?
Honestly, it shouldn't have been that close. Seattle came into that Week 15 meeting on a tear, sitting at 11-3 and looking like a Super Bowl lock. Meanwhile, Indy was reeling, having lost four straight. But the NFL is weird. It’s always weird. This game proved that a kicker can sometimes be more dangerous than a dual-threat quarterback or a superstar wideout.
💡 You might also like: Oregon Ducks Football Head Coach: Why Dan Lanning Still Matters
The Jason Myers Show at Lumen Field
Most people think you need to cross the goal line to win an NFL game. Jason Myers clearly disagrees. During that specific Seattle Seahawks vs Indianapolis Colts clash on December 14, 2025, the Seahawks managed to win 18-16 without scoring a single touchdown.
Myers was a machine. He knocked down six field goals—yes, six. The highlight was a 56-yard bomb with only 29 seconds left on the clock. It wasn't just that he was accurate; he was hitting from deep. We’re talking 47, 52, 46, 32, and 30 yards. He accounting for every single point on the Seattle side. When you consider that he nearly broke the franchise record for points in a season that night, it puts the performance into perspective.
The crowd in Seattle is usually deafening, but there was a strange tension in the air for three quarters. Watching your team stall out in the red zone over and over is exhausting. Yet, the defense kept them in it. They held the Colts to just 215 total yards. When you realize the Colts have Jonathan Taylor—one of the best to ever do it—holding them to that little yardage is basically a miracle.
Philip Rivers and the 44-Year-Old Comeback
Here is the part that sounds like a fever dream: Philip Rivers.
The Colts were desperate. Their season was slipping away, and they decided to call up a man who hadn't thrown an NFL pass in nearly five years. Most people thought it was a publicity stunt or a sign of absolute surrender. Instead, Rivers came out and actually looked... decent? Sorta.
He wasn't throwing 60-yard lasers, but he was efficient. He actually led the Colts to a 13-3 lead, connecting with Josh Downs for an 8-yard score in the second quarter. It was Rivers' first touchdown pass since the 2020 playoffs. Think about that for a second. The guy was probably at home helping his ten kids with homework a month prior, and here he was carving up a top-tier Seahawks secondary in the rain.
Indy actually led for almost the entire game. They went ahead 16-15 with 47 seconds left after a massive 60-yard field goal by Blake Grupe. For about 18 seconds, it looked like the upset of the decade was happening.
Why the Seahawks Defense Still Matters
While Myers got the headlines, the Seahawks' defensive unit was the real reason they didn't get embarrassed. Ernest Jones IV was everywhere, racking up 10 tackles and crossing the 100-tackle mark for his fourth straight season.
Then you had Coby Bryant. With the game on the line and Rivers trying to force one last desperation heave downfield, Bryant snagged a tipped ball from Devon Witherspoon to clinch it. That was Bryant’s fourth pick of the year.
It’s funny how we talk about "great wins." Usually, that implies a blowout. But this Seattle Seahawks vs Indianapolis Colts game was a "great win" because it was ugly. It showed that Seattle didn't flinch when the offense disappeared. Sam Darnold finished with 271 yards, which isn't bad, but he couldn't finish drives. Jaxon Smith-Njigba was the only real bright spot in the air, hauling in 7 catches for 113 yards.
Historical Context: A Rivalry of Inches
When you look at the all-time record, the Colts actually lead the series 13-9. It’s not a rivalry we talk about as much as, say, Seahawks-Niners, but the games are almost always bizarrely close.
Before the 2025 slugfest, the last meeting in 2023 was a total blowout—Colts won that one 37-3. But usually, these teams trade punches. The scoring averages over the history of the matchup are nearly identical: 23.64 for Indy and 23.5 for Seattle. You can't get much more even than that.
Looking Ahead to the 2026 Season
The NFL schedule makers have already finalized the opponents for 2026. While the full dates won't drop until the spring, we know what the landscape looks like for both these squads.
- Indianapolis Colts 2026 Outlook: They’re set to host the Bengals, Cowboys, Dolphins, Giants, and Ravens. It’s a brutal home slate. They’ll be traveling to face the Steelers and Eagles as well. The question is whether they stick with a veteran presence or fully commit to the younger legs of someone like Anthony Richardson or the 2026 draft class.
- Seattle Seahawks 2026 Outlook: After a deep 2025 run (they even made it to the Conference Finals against the Eagles), the expectations are sky-high. With Sam Darnold looking settled and a roster featuring studs like Kenneth Walker III and a maturing Jaxon Smith-Njigba, Seattle is the team to beat in the NFC West.
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you're betting on or following these two teams in the future, keep a few things in mind. First, never count out a Seattle kicker at home. The "12th Man" effect isn't just about noise; it seems to give their special teams a weird boost in high-pressure moments.
Second, the Colts are a team that plays to the level of their competition. They can lose to a bottom-dweller one week and nearly take down a 12-win powerhouse the next.
If you want to stay ahead of the curve for the 2026 season:
- Watch the injury reports for the Colts' offensive line; when Quenton Nelson is healthy, Jonathan Taylor is a different human being.
- Monitor Seattle's red zone efficiency. If they keep settling for field goals like they did in the December '25 game, they’re going to eventually get burned by a more explosive offense.
- Check the 2026 Draft Order. Both teams are looking to solidify their depth in the secondary, which was a clear weak point for Indy during that final drive in Seattle.
The Seattle Seahawks vs Indianapolis Colts history is a reminder that in the NFL, stats don't always tell the whole story. Sometimes, it’s just about who has the guy with the strongest leg and the defense that refuses to break.