Honestly, nothing kills the vibe of a perfect island morning like realized you just handed over nearly 5,000 Bells for a piece of junk. We’ve all been there. You walk onto Redd’s Treasure Trawler, the lighting is dim, the music is slightly unsettling, and you’re trying to squint at a tiny screen to see if that ferret looks "correct."
Redd is a crook. We know this. But the serene painting acnh real vs fake dilemma is actually one of the easier ones to solve once you know exactly where to look. You don’t need to be an art history major to figure this out, though it helps to know that the actual painting is Leonardo da Vinci’s Lady with an Ermine.
In the real world, that "ermine" is a symbol of purity. In Animal Crossing, it’s the smoking gun that tells you whether you’re being scammed.
The One Big Detail: It’s All About the Ermine
If you’re staring at the serene painting and trying to decide if it’s worth the Bells, ignore the woman’s face. Don’t worry about the background. Just look at the animal she’s holding.
In the real serene painting, the ermine (that long, ferret-like creature) is solid white. It’s clean, bright, and consistent. It looks like a little snowball with eyes.
Now, if you’re looking at a fake serene painting, the ermine has a dark, grayish-black patch around its eyes and ears. It almost looks like a little raccoon mask or a Siamese cat's face. If you see any dark fur on that animal, turn around and walk right back off that boat.
It’s that simple.
- Real: Solid white ermine.
- Fake: Grey/black markings around the eyes (looks like a raccoon or mask).
Why This Specific Painting Tricky
Sometimes the lighting on the Trawler makes everything look a bit dingy. Since the fake version uses "greyish" tones for the animal's face, a lot of players get paranoid that the shadows in the real version are actually the fake markings.
🔗 Read more: Why Switch 2 Sold Out Everywhere and How You Can Actually Find One
Don’t overthink it.
The fake is very distinct. It’s not a subtle shadow; it’s a deliberate dark patch. If you have the Pro Camera app on your NookPhone, use the handheld mode to get a close-up. It makes the "raccoon" eyes on the fake version much more obvious.
Interestingly, back in the New Leaf days, the fake version was even more bizarre—the woman was holding a literal house cat instead of a ferret. For New Horizons, Nintendo decided to make it a bit more grounded in reality, which actually makes it harder to spot if you’re rushing.
Is There a Haunted Version?
You might have heard rumors about "haunted" art in ACNH. Some paintings, like the Wistful Painting or the Scary Painting, actually change at night. The girl in the Wistful Painting might close her eyes, or the man in the Scary Painting might smile.
Unfortunately (or fortunately, depending on your taste for ghosts), the Serene Painting is not haunted.
The fake version will just sit there on your wall, looking like a poorly rendered raccoon-ferret hybrid, forever. It won’t wink at you, and it won’t move. It’s just a boring, non-donatable forgery.
What Happens if You Buy the Fake?
If you messed up and bought the forgery, Blathers is going to give you that polite, soul-crushing rejection. "I'm afraid this is a forgery!"
You can’t sell fakes to Tommy and Timmy at Nook’s Cranny. They won't touch them. You basically have three options:
- Trash it: Use a literal trash can furniture item to throw it away.
- Give it away: You can mail it to a villager you don't like, though they might not be thrilled.
- Decorate: Some people actually like the look of the fakes for a "shady" area of their island or a basement art studio.
How to Get the Serene Painting Naturally
Redd shows up at your secret beach (the one at the very back of your island) at random intervals. However, if you’ve unlocked the stalls on Harv’s Island, you can pay 100,000 Bells to set up his shop permanently. This is the fastest way to complete your museum.
👉 See also: GTA Online Dispatch Work: How to Actually Make Money with Vincent’s New Missions
He refreshes his stock every Monday, but there's a trick: if you buy a piece of art (even a fake one), he will replace that spot with a new item the next day.
If you're hunting for the real Serene Painting to finish your collection, checking his boat and his Harv's Island stall daily is your best bet.
Quick Checklist for the Trawler
- Open your camera.
- Zoom in on the animal's head.
- If it's pure white, buy it.
- If it has a "mask" or grey face, skip it.
If you’re still unsure, look at the price. All of Redd's art sells for 4,980 Bells. If he's asking for that much and the animal is white, you’re looking at a genuine masterpiece.
The next time you see that fox's boat docked at the back of your island, take a breath. Don't let the "no refunds" talk get to you. Just check the ermine's face, confirm it's white, and go get that museum donation.