Honestly, when Netflix first announced they were rebooting Lemony Snicket’s miserable world, everyone had the same question. Can anyone actually top Jim Carrey? Carrey’s 2004 performance was a fever dream of slapstick and latex. It was loud. It was chaotic. But then Series of Unfortunate Events Neil Patrick Harris happened, and the conversation shifted.
Instead of a rubber-faced comedian, we got a Broadway showman. Harris didn’t just play a villain; he played a bad actor playing a villain. It’s a meta-layer that honestly fits the books way better than the movie ever did.
The Count Olaf Problem
Count Olaf is a nightmare to cast. You’ve got a guy who is supposed to be genuinely terrifying—he hits children and burns down houses—but he’s also a total buffoon who thinks he’s the greatest actor alive. If you go too scary, the whimsical tone of the books dies. If you go too funny, the stakes vanish.
✨ Don't miss: Why We’ll Be Together Grease 2 is Actually the Movie’s Best Secret
Basically, Harris found the middle ground.
His Olaf is a "ham." He leans into the theatricality. Because Harris is a literal Tony-winning host and performer, he understands the mechanics of a "bad" performance. When Olaf disguises himself as Stephano or Captain Sham, Harris isn't trying to convince us. He’s playing a character who is convinced he’s fooling everyone, even though his disguise is just a cheap wig and a fake accent.
It’s that specific brand of arrogance that makes the Netflix version so watchable.
Breaking Down the Disguises
One of the best parts of the show was seeing how many weird personas Harris could juggle. Each book in the series (usually two episodes) required a new look.
- Captain Sham: The one-legged sailor with a business card that definitely wasn't a napkin.
- Shirley: The "receptionist" at the Lucky Smells Lumbermill. Seeing Harris in a wig and heels was a vibe.
- Detective Dupin: This was Harris’s favorite. The "junk-hugging" leather pants and the gold tooth? Pure gold.
- Gunther: The vaguely European auctioneer who only said "Please" and "In."
Harris actually worked closely with costume designer Cynthia Ann Summers. He would show up to fittings already using the voice of the disguise. He didn't just put on a jacket; he built the character from the vocal cords up.
Is He Better Than Jim Carrey?
This is the debate that never ends. Carrey was a force of nature, but his Olaf felt like a Looney Tunes character. He was funny, sure, but did you ever actually think he was going to kill those kids? Maybe not.
Harris’s Olaf is different. He’s thinner, meaner, and has a coldness in his eyes that pops up when the jokes stop. There’s a scene in the first season where he slaps Klaus across the face. It isn't a "funny" movie slap. It’s mean. It’s quiet. It reminds you that despite the musical numbers, this guy is a predator.
Daniel Handler (the real Lemony Snicket) actually wanted Harris for the role after seeing him host the 2011 Tonys. He saw that Harris could be charming and mocking at the same time. That’s the "four-quadrant" appeal Netflix was looking for—something that wouldn't bore parents to death while their kids watched.
The Musical Element
You can’t talk about Series of Unfortunate Events Neil Patrick Harris without mentioning the songs. The theme song, "Look Away," changed every single episode. Harris would record new lyrics to warn the audience about what was coming.
It was a clever trick.
It utilized Harris's greatest strength: his voice. While the books weren't a musical, the show felt like a dark operetta. Olaf’s introductory number, "The Bad Beginning," set the tone immediately. He’s a narcissist who wants a spotlight, even if the "theatre" is just a dusty living room in a dilapidated mansion.
Why It Still Matters
The show wrapped up in 2019, but it’s become a bit of a cult classic for people who grew up on the books. It stayed faithful. It didn't try to "modernize" the setting with iPhones or TikTok. It kept that weird, timeless, gothic aesthetic.
Harris’s performance anchored the whole thing. He played Olaf for three seasons and 25 episodes, covering all 13 books. By the time he reached The End, you sort of felt bad for the guy, which is a testament to how much nuance Harris brought to a character that could have easily been a one-dimensional cartoon.
✨ Don't miss: Come Together Right Now Over Me Song: The Chaotic Truth Behind the Lyrics
Actionable Takeaways for Fans
If you're looking to revisit the series or dive in for the first time, keep these things in mind:
- Watch the Theme Song: Don't skip it. The lyrics are specific to the plot of those two episodes.
- Look for the V.F.D. Symbols: The production design is insane. There are "eye" symbols hidden in the background of almost every set.
- Appreciate the Guest Stars: Harris is the lead, but the show is a revolving door of comedy royalty—Catherine O’Hara, Will Arnett, and Joan Cusack all show up.
- Read the Books After: Seeing how Harris interprets the specific lines from the novels makes you realize how much he actually cared about the source material.
The show isn't just "family entertainment." It’s a masterclass in how to adapt a very specific literary voice into something visual without losing the soul of the story. Harris was the only person who could have pulled it off.