If you’ve ever stood on the edge of Lake Erie when the wind picks up, you know it doesn't feel like a lake. It feels like an ocean. The grey-blue water churns, the horizon disappears, and honestly, it’s a bit intimidating. Most people visiting Erie, Pennsylvania, stick to the generic strips of Peach Street or the standard motels near the interstate because they’re easy. But if you’re actually looking for the "Erie experience," you end up at the Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel. It’s the only place that actually makes sense if you want to be on the water without literally being in a boat.
It’s weirdly positioned. In a good way.
You’re basically perched on the Sassafras Pier. To your left is the massive Bicentennial Tower, which looks like a giant, futuristic chess piece. To your right is the bay. Most hotels claim a "waterfront view" and then give you a sliver of blue between two parking garages. Here, the water is the whole point. It’s right there. You can smell the lake air the second you hop out of your car, which—fair warning—can be bracing if you're visiting in February. Erie winters are no joke.
Why the Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel is the Anchor of the District
The location isn't just about the scenery; it’s about the logistics of the Bayfront Convention Center. They’re connected by a skybridge. This is a massive deal for anyone attending a conference because, as I mentioned, Erie weather can go from "pleasant afternoon" to "sideways sleet" in about four minutes. Being able to walk to your seminar in socks if you really wanted to—though I wouldn't recommend it—is a luxury you don't appreciate until you see people struggling with umbrellas in 40 mph gusts outside.
🔗 Read more: Is There a Travel Ban to Mexico? What You Need to Know Before Booking in 2026
Most people don't realize how much the Bayfront has changed. Twenty years ago, this area was mostly industrial grit. Now, it’s the heartbeat of the city’s tourism. The Sheraton was the first big anchor that signaled Erie was serious about reclaiming its shoreline. It’s not just a place to sleep; it’s the gateway to the Presque Isle State Park, which is just a short drive or a summer water taxi ride away.
Let's talk about the lobby. It’s open. It’s airy. It actually feels like a maritime lounge rather than a corporate check-in desk. You see a mix of people here: suits closing deals, wedding parties in full "chaos mode," and families heading to Waldameer Park with sunscreen already smeared on their noses. It’s the central hub for the whole waterfront.
The Room Situation: Lake View vs. City View
Here is the thing about the rooms. You have a choice. You can look at the city of Erie, which has its charms—the historic architecture and the sloping hills—or you can look at the Bay.
Get the Bay view.
Honestly, it’s worth the extra few bucks. Watching the Presque Isle Isle Express or the Victorian-style Victorian Princess paddleboat cruise past your window at sunset is therapeutic. The rooms themselves are what you expect from a Sheraton—clean lines, those heavy Marriott-standard white duvets, and desks that are actually large enough to work on. But the windows are the star. They’re huge.
If you’re lucky enough to be there during a summer thunderstorm, turn off the lights and just watch the lightning hit the lake. It's better than anything on the TV.
- Bayfront King Rooms: These are the sweet spot. You get the orientation toward the water and enough space to not feel cramped.
- Club Level: If you’re a frequent traveler, the Club Lounge access is a lifesaver. It’s on the top floor. Free breakfast, evening hors d'oeuvres, and—most importantly—a quieter place to drink your coffee while staring at the horizon.
- Suites: They’re massive. If you're doing the "wedding in Erie" thing, this is where the bridal party inevitably ends up.
Dining and the "Bayfront Grille" Experience
Eating at the hotel is usually a "last resort" for travelers. Not here. The Bayfront Grille is actually a destination for locals, which is always the best sign. They have this outdoor patio that, during the summer, is arguably the best place in the county to have a drink.
They do the Great Lakes classics. You’ll see Walleye on the menu. If you haven't had Walleye, it’s a flaky, mild whitefish that basically defines the local diet. It’s better than perch. Yeah, I said it.
The bar scene is surprisingly social. Because the hotel is connected to the convention center and near the UPMC Park (where the SeaWolves play), the bar is often a melting pot of baseball scouts, tech presenters, and locals who just want to watch the sunset with a craft beer. Pennsylvania has a massive craft beer scene, and you’ll find plenty of Voodoo Brewery or Erie Brewing Company cans moving across the mahogany.
The Pool and Fitness Factor
I’ve stayed at a lot of places where the "indoor pool" is basically a lukewarm bathtub in a windowless basement. The Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel actually put some thought into this. The pool area has floor-to-ceiling windows. You can be swimming laps while watching the ice floes on the bay in January. It’s a trip.
The fitness center is standard, but again, the view makes the treadmill slightly less soul-crushing. If you’re a runner, don't use the treadmill. Go outside. The "Baywalk" trail runs right past the hotel. You can run all the way to Dobbins Landing and back, getting a face full of lake breeze that will wake you up better than any espresso.
What People Get Wrong About Erie Travel
People think Erie is just a stopover between Buffalo and Cleveland. That’s a mistake. The Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel puts you in a position to see that this is a maritime city with deep roots. You’re steps away from the Erie Maritime Museum and the U.S. Brig Niagara. This is a massive, dual-masted sailing ship that fought in the Battle of Lake Erie in 1813.
Most travelers miss the "history" part of the waterfront. They see the modern hotel and the shiny convention center and forget that this water was a major theater of war and a massive hub for the fishing industry. Staying here puts that history right in your backyard.
Also, don't sleep on the winter. Everyone wants to visit in July. July is great. It’s 80 degrees and perfect. But Erie in the winter is hauntingly beautiful. The lake freezes into these jagged plates of ice, and the Sheraton becomes this warm, glowing sanctuary against the white-out conditions outside. It’s cozy. It’s "hygge" before people started using that word for marketing.
Navigating the Area Like a Local
If you’re staying at the Sheraton, you’re centrally located, but you still need a plan.
- The Water Taxi: During the warmer months, there’s a water taxi that runs from Dobbins Landing (right by the hotel) over to Presque Isle. It’s cheap, it’s fun, and it saves you from the traffic jam that can happen at the park entrance.
- Dobbins Landing: Go to the top of the Bicentennial Tower. Yes, it’s a tourist thing. Yes, you should do it anyway. You can see all the way to Canada on a clear day.
- Lower State Street: Walk up the hill. You’ll find local spots like the Brewerie at Union Station. It’s an old train station turned into a brewpub. The architecture is stunning.
The Business Side of Things
If you're here for work, the Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel is basically the only logical choice. The meeting rooms within the hotel itself are high-end—think dark woods and ergonomic chairs—but the real value is the seamless transition to the Bayfront Convention Center.
The Wi-Fi is fast. I’ve tested it. You can run a Zoom call with a blurred background while the actual bay is behind you. It’s a flex.
One thing to keep in mind: the parking situation. They have a parking garage. It’s convenient, especially in the snow, but make sure you check your booking to see if parking is included or if it’s an extra daily fee. It catches some people off guard.
Final Practical Insights for Your Stay
Don't just book the first rate you see. If you’re a AAA member or a government employee, the rates here fluctuate wildly. Also, if there is a massive concert at the nearby Erie Insurance Arena or a major convention, the place fills up fast.
The "Sheraton Sleep Experience" beds are legitimately good. It’s one of those things where you realize your mattress at home is actually terrible.
Actionable Next Steps:
- Book the Harbor Side: When reserving your room, specifically request a "Bay View High Floor." The lower floors are fine, but the perspective from the 5th floor and above is where the magic happens.
- Check the Event Calendar: Before you go, look at the Bayfront Convention Center’s schedule. If there’s a 5,000-person event, the elevators will be slower and the bar will be packed. Plan accordingly.
- Bring a Windbreaker: Even in August, the wind off Lake Erie can be chilly once the sun goes down. If you plan on sitting on the Bayfront Grille patio, you’ll want a light layer.
- Explore Beyond the Hotel: Use the Sheraton as your "base camp." Spend one day at Presque Isle State Park (it’s free entry!) and another exploring the downtown food scene.
Staying at the Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel is about leaning into the lake life. It’s about realizing that Erie isn't just a point on a map; it’s a coastal city in the middle of the country. Get the lake view, eat the walleye, and watch the weather roll in. You won't regret it.