When you talk about the Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls, you aren't actually looking at the work of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle. That's the first thing people usually trip over. It's a common mistake because we’ve been trained to think every "Holmes" story belongs to the original canon. But this specific tale is actually a 1952 film—often called The Adventure of the Victoria Falls or Sherlock Holmes: Incident at Victoria Falls—that stars the legendary Christopher Lee.
It's weirdly fascinating.
Imagine Holmes in the African veldt. It feels wrong, doesn't it? We're used to the fog of London, the cobblestones of Baker Street, and the damp air of Dartmoor. Seeing the Great Detective under the blazing sun of colonial Rhodesia (now Zimbabwe) is a jarring shift in tone. But for fans of "The Great Hiatus"—that period between 1891 and 1894 when Holmes was supposed to be dead—this film provides a speculative look at what he might have been doing.
Why the Victoria Falls setting changes everything
The movie isn't just about a mystery; it’s about the politics of the British Empire. King Edward VII (played by Joss Ackland) asks Holmes to travel to South Africa to retrieve the "Star of Africa," a massive diamond intended for the Crown Jewels. This isn't your typical "who stole the silver spoons" case. It's a high-stakes geopolitical escort mission.
Victoria Falls serves as more than a backdrop. It's the climax. It's the chaos.
Most people don't realize that by 1952, the Sherlock Holmes brand was in a strange transition. The Basil Rathbone era was over. The world was looking for something grittier but still nostalgic. Enter Christopher Lee. He didn't just play Holmes; he embodied a more acerbic, physically imposing version of the character that felt right for the scale of the African landscape. Honestly, the Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls is basically a precursor to the modern "global adventure" reboots we see today.
The plot: Diamonds, decoys, and a lot of steam trains
The core of the incident revolves around a bait-and-switch. Holmes and Watson (played by Patrick Macnee, who many remember from The Avengers) are tasked with transporting the diamond. To keep it safe, Holmes creates a decoy. Naturally, someone steals the decoy, but then—shocker—the real diamond goes missing too.
It’s a classic locked-room mystery, but the "room" is a moving train chugging through the African wilderness.
There's a specific tension here. You've got the majesty of the Mosi-oa-Tunya (the smoke that thunders) and the claustrophobia of a train carriage. If you've ever seen the film, you know the pacing is... let's call it "deliberate." It's slow. It builds. Then it hits you with a series of double-crosses involving an Italian opera singer and various colonial officials who aren't who they claim to be.
Breaking down the cast and the "Lee" factor
Christopher Lee is the big draw here. He's one of the few actors to play both Sherlock and Mycroft Holmes (and Henry Baskerville, for that matter). In this Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls, he brings a certain weariness to the role. He looks like a man who has seen too much of the world.
📖 Related: The Walking Dead Season 1 Episode 1: Why Days Gone Bye Still Hits Different
Patrick Macnee's Watson is also a departure. He's not the bumbling comic relief that Nigel Bruce popularized. He’s more capable. He’s a veteran. Their chemistry is what carries the long stretches of dialogue where they discuss the intricacies of the diamond trade and the local political climate.
Fact vs. Fiction: Is there any Doyle in this?
Not really.
The script was an original creation for television/film. While it borrows the "feel" of The Empty House, it's purely a pastiche. Some purists hate it. They think Holmes belongs in the 221B flat and nowhere else. But if you look at the historical context of 1910 (when the story is set), the British were obsessed with their colonies. Sending Holmes to Africa was a very "period-accurate" thing to do, even if Doyle never wrote it himself.
The Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls succeeds because it uses the real history of the Star of Africa—the Cullinan Diamond—as its anchor. The real diamond was found in 1905 and presented to King Edward VII. The film plays with the "what if" scenario of its transport. Using real history makes the fiction taste better. It's a trick modern writers still use to hook audiences who want to believe the story could have happened.
What viewers often miss about the "Incident"
If you watch it closely, you'll see a lot of subtle nods to the era's changing social dynamics. There are conversations about the Boer War and the brewing tensions in the region.
- The train journey is a character in itself.
- The cinematography at the actual falls is breathtaking for its time.
- The "incident" isn't just the theft; it's the realization that Holmes is out of his element.
It’s easy to dismiss this as a B-movie. But look at the budget. For the early 90s (when it was actually produced, despite the 1952 setting of the story), the production values were surprisingly high. They filmed on location. That’s why the Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls feels so authentic. You can almost feel the heat and the spray from the water.
The technical side of the mystery
The "how" of the diamond theft involves a sleight of hand that Holmes himself admires. It’s rare to see him genuinely surprised. In most stories, he’s five steps ahead. Here, because of the travel fatigue and the unfamiliar terrain, he’s only about two steps ahead. It makes him more human. More relatable. Sorta makes you realize why people still watch these old TV movies on rainy Sunday afternoons.
The legacy of the Victoria Falls adventure
Why do we still talk about this specific film?
Maybe because it was one of the last times we saw a truly "classic" interpretation of the character before the BBC's Sherlock and Guy Ritchie’s movies turned him into a high-octane action hero or a tech-savvy genius. This was the end of an era.
If you're looking for the Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls today, you'll likely find it in bargain bins or streaming on "classic" movie channels. It holds a weird spot in the Sherlockian mythos. It's not canon, but it's "legacy." It’s a piece of 20th-century entertainment that tried to bridge the gap between Victorian mystery and modern global thriller.
How to watch and analyze the film like a pro
If you're going to dive into this mystery, don't go in expecting Inception. Expect a slow-burn detective story.
- Watch the backgrounds. The location shots are the real star.
- Compare the Watsons. If you’ve only seen Jude Law or Martin Freeman, Macnee will be a shock. He’s much closer to the "literary" Watson—a man of action who isn't an idiot.
- Note the pacing. Modern movies cut every three seconds. This movie lets the camera sit. It lets you think.
The Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls is a reminder that the character of Holmes is indestructible. You can put him in a spaceship, a 21st-century hospital, or the middle of the African bush, and he still works. The logic stays the same. The pipe stays the same. The arrogance stays the same.
Actionable steps for Sherlock Holmes fans
To truly appreciate the context of this incident, you should do a bit of legwork. It makes the viewing experience 10x better.
👉 See also: Where to Watch Uma Musume Pretty Derby: The 2026 Guide to Horse Girls
- Research the Cullinan Diamond: Read the actual history of how the Star of Africa was transported. The real-life security measures were almost as clever as the ones Holmes uses in the movie.
- Look for the "Lost Collection": This film was part of a series intended to be much longer. Finding the sister film, The Incident at Kneller Manor, gives you a better sense of Christopher Lee’s vision for the character.
- Check the map: Look at the rail lines of 1910 Africa. The film is surprisingly accurate about how someone would actually get from Cape Town to Victoria Falls in that era.
Most importantly, watch it for what it is: a love letter to a character that refused to stay in London. The Sherlock Holmes incident at Victoria Falls isn't the best mystery ever filmed, but it's one of the most unique settings the detective has ever graced. It challenges our perception of what a "Sherlock story" has to be. Basically, it’s a fun, slightly flawed, but deeply atmospheric trip into a corner of the Holmes world that most people completely overlook.