Walk into any high-end liquor store or a dimly lit speakeasy, and you’ll see the labels. They scream at you. "Single Malt." "Double Malt." It sounds like a hierarchy, right? Like double must be twice as good as single, or maybe it’s twice as concentrated. Honestly, the marketing departments in the spirits industry have done a number on our collective understanding of what’s actually in the bottle. If you’ve ever stood in an aisle wondering why one bottle costs $45 and the one next to it costs $450, you’re not alone. The debate of single malt vs double malt whiskey is often less about quality and more about legal definitions, geography, and some very clever branding.
Let’s clear the air immediately.
👉 See also: Why the Crochet Tissue Box Cover is Suddenly Everywhere Again
There is technically no such thing as a "double malt" whiskey in the official Scotch Whisky Regulations. If you're looking for a legal definition in Scotland, you won't find it. What you will find are people using the term "double malt" to describe what is actually a "Blended Malt." It’s a common mix-up. People hear "double" and think of double-distilled or perhaps aged in two different types of wood. While those things happen, they aren't what defines the category.
The single malt obsession
To understand the "double," we have to start with the "single." A single malt whiskey is the product of one single distillery. That’s the golden rule. It doesn't mean it comes from one single barrel—that would be a "single cask" bottling. A single malt like a Macallan 12 or a Glenfiddich 15 is a vatting of many different barrels, but every single drop of liquid in that bottle was fermented and distilled at that one physical location.
It has to be made from 100% malted barley. No corn. No rye. No wheat. Just barley, water, and yeast.
Why do people obsess over it? Character. When you drink a single malt from Islay, like a Laphroaig, you’re tasting the specific personality of that distillery—the peat smoke, the sea air, the copper stills that haven't changed shape in decades. It’s a snapshot of a place. It's distinct. If a distillery messes up a batch, they can't just hide it by mixing in grain whiskey from somewhere else and still call it a single malt.
What on earth is a double malt whiskey anyway?
So, if "double malt" isn't a legal term in the world of Scotch, why do we see it on labels? Usually, it's a marketing term used by brands outside of Scotland, or it's a colloquial way of describing a Blended Malt.
A blended malt (formerly known as a "vatted malt" or "pure malt") is a marriage of single malts from two or more different distilleries. Think of brands like Monkey Shoulder or Johnnie Walker Green Label. There is zero grain whiskey in these. It’s all malt. But because the liquid comes from multiple sites—say, a bit of Talisker mixed with some Caol Ila—it loses the "single" prefix.
Some drinkers use "double malt" to describe whiskey that has undergone a "double wood" or "double cask" maturation process. The Balvenie DoubleWood is a classic example. It spends most of its life in traditional oak and then gets a "finish" in sherry casks. It’s still a single malt because it all came from Balvenie, but the "double" refers to the wood. You can see how this gets confusing fast.
Then you have the international scene. In India or parts of Europe, some distillers use "double malt" to signify that they've blended two specific types of malted spirits together. It’s a bit of a Wild West out there compared to the rigid, almost religious laws governing Scotch.
The flavor profile shift
When you're comparing single malt vs double malt whiskey on the palate, the experience is wildly different.
Single malts are often "spiky." They have edges. A Highland Park is going to give you that specific heather honey and light peat every single time. It’s predictable in its complexity. You're buying into the house style. It’s like listening to a solo cellist; you hear the vibration of every string and the breath of the performer.
Blended malts (the "double malts") are more like a symphony. The master blender is trying to create balance. If one single malt is too smoky, they’ll round it out with something fruity or floral from the Speyside region. The goal is often drinkability and consistency.
- Single Malt: Focused, intense, site-specific, often more expensive due to scarcity.
- Double/Blended Malt: Balanced, approachable, often offers better value for the price point.
- The "Double Cask" Outlier: Richer, sweeter, focuses on the influence of the barrel rather than the raw spirit.
Why the price gap exists
You’ll notice single malts almost always command a premium. This isn't just snobbery. It's math.
💡 You might also like: George Thomas Stahel Farmer: What the Historical Records Actually Tell Us
Running a single distillery and maintaining a consistent profile without the safety net of blending in other spirits is risky and expensive. If a warehouse in the Highlands has a bad year because of temperature fluctuations, that distillery’s single malt output for that year is affected.
Blended malts have more flexibility. If the price of malt from one distillery spikes, the blender can tweak the recipe (within reason) to use more of a similar malt from another distillery. They have a larger "spice rack" to work with. This allows brands like Compass Box to create incredibly complex whiskies that might actually taste "better" than many single malts, even if they don't carry the same prestige.
Real world examples you should know
If you want to actually taste the difference between single malt vs double malt whiskey, you need to get your hands on specific bottles. Don't just take a salesman's word for it.
Try a Lagavulin 16. That is the quintessential single malt. It is unapologetic. It tastes like a campfire on a rainy beach. It’s one distillery, one vision.
Then, try Monkey Shoulder. It’s a blend of three different Speyside single malts: Glenfiddich, Balvenie, and Kininvie. It’s smooth. It’s malty. It’s great in a cocktail but holds up neat. You can taste the "breadiness" of the malt without the aggressive singular punch of a Highland single malt.
If you want to see what "double" means in terms of maturation, grab the Aberlour 12 Year Old Double Cask. You’ll get the crisp apple notes of the spirit alongside the heavy, dark chocolate and raisin notes from the sherry wood. It's a single malt, but it uses that "double" influence to create layers.
The myth of "purity"
There's this weird idea that single malt is "pure" and anything else is "adulterated." Honestly, it’s nonsense.
Some of the most respected figures in the industry, like Richard Paterson (The Nose) or Rachel Barrie, spend their entire lives blending. Blending is an art form. To take two distinct single malts and make them sing together is arguably harder than just letting one sit in a barrel for twelve years.
The "single malt vs double malt whiskey" debate often hides the fact that both are superior to mass-produced "Blended Scotch" (like your standard red-label bottles), which contain a large percentage of grain whiskey made from corn or wheat in column stills. Grain whiskey is cheaper and more neutral. Both single malts and blended malts avoid this, keeping the focus entirely on the more expensive, flavorful malted barley.
👉 See also: Will White Vinegar Bleach Clothes? What Really Happens to Your Laundry
How to choose what’s right for you
Don't buy a bottle just because it says "Single Malt." There are plenty of mediocre single malts out there that are thin and over-oaked.
If you're a beginner, a "double malt" or blended malt is actually a fantastic entry point. They are designed to be friendly. They won't burn your throat or taste like medicinal peat unless they're specifically designed to. They offer a "greatest hits" of what malt whiskey can be.
However, if you’re looking for a "moment"—something that tells a story of a specific glen in Scotland or a specific valley in Japan—the single malt is your go-to. It’s a conversation piece. It’s a way to travel via your glass.
Actionable steps for your next pour
Stop looking for the word "double" on labels as a marker of quality. Instead, look for the following:
- Check the "Type": If it says "Blended Malt Scotch Whisky," you’re getting a mix of high-quality single malts. If it says "Blended Scotch Whisky," it has grain whiskey in it. Know the difference.
- Look for "Non-Chill Filtered": This matters more than "single" or "double." Chill filtering removes fatty acids to keep the whiskey from getting cloudy, but it also removes flavor and texture.
- Ignore the Age Statement (Sometimes): A 12-year-old single malt isn't inherently better than an 8-year-old blended malt. Temperature and cask quality matter more than the calendar.
- Add Water: Especially with single malts. One or two drops of room-temperature water breaks the surface tension and releases the aromas. It’s not "watering it down"; it’s opening it up.
- Read the Back Label: If it says "Double Matured," look for what the second cask was. If it was Port or Sauternes, expect a very sweet, dessert-like finish.
The next time you're at the bar, ask the bartender for a blended malt and a single malt from the same region. Taste them side-by-side. You'll notice the single malt has a "point" to it—a specific direction it wants to take your palate. The blended malt will feel wider, more expansive, and perhaps a bit more forgiving. Neither is "better," but one will definitely fit your mood better than the other.