Fantasy football semifinals. Honestly, if you're reading this, you've survived the chaos. You navigated the injuries, the "is he playing?" game-time decisions, and that one guy in your league who still hasn't set his lineup since October. But now, it’s win or go home. Week 16 is notoriously the "trap" week. The matchups look juicy on paper, but the weather in Chicago is turning into a frozen tundra, and half the league’s star quarterbacks are currently on a first-name basis with their team’s orthopedic surgeon.
We need to talk about sit em start em week 16 fantasy football strategies because the standard "start your studs" advice is how people lose in the playoffs. If your "stud" is playing in a 40-mph wind gust or catching passes from a third-stringer, he’s not a stud this week. He’s a liability.
The Quarterback Quagmire: Trusting the Tiers
Let’s be real about the QB position right now. Patrick Mahomes is out. Jayden Daniels is done for the year. If you’re a Lamar Jackson owner, you’re currently staring at a "back contusion" report and praying.
Start: Brock Purdy, 49ers (at Colts)
Vegas loves the Niners this week. They have a massive implied team total, and while the Colts have a decent rush defense, they’re getting shredded through the air. Purdy is leading the league in EPA (Expected Points Added) per play. He’s efficient. He’s boring. He’s exactly what you need when you just need 20 points without the drama. The Colts' defense actually forces teams to pass more than almost anyone else. Purdy is a smash.
✨ Don't miss: Charles Woodson and the Raiders: The Truth About a Legend Who Redefined Silver and Black
Sit: Marcus Mariota, Commanders (vs. Eagles)
I know, I know. He’s been a great floor play lately because of the rushing yards. But the wheels are coming off. Laremy Tunsil is out with an oblique injury. That’s a death sentence against an Eagles front that generates pressure at a top-10 rate. Mariota under pressure is… well, it’s not pretty. He’s PFF’s 32nd-ranked passer when the pocket collapses. Don’t chase the rushing floor here; the ceiling is in the basement.
Running Backs: Volume vs. Efficiency
The RB landscape in Week 16 is basically a triage unit.
Start: Michael Carter, Cardinals (at Falcons)
With Trey Benson and Bam Knight both on IR, Carter is the last man standing in Arizona. Last week he had a 72% route rate. That is insane for a guy most people found on the waiver wire two weeks ago. This game in Atlanta has "shootout" written all over it. Even if he doesn't break a 50-yarder, the receiving volume alone makes him a safe RB2 with RB1 upside in PPR leagues.
Sit: Jaylen Warren, Steelers (at Lions)
The Steelers basically gave up on Warren as their lead guy last week. Kenneth Gainwell out-snapped him, out-carried him, and—most importantly—got the targets. Now they go to Detroit as seven-point underdogs. If the Steelers are trailing, Gainwell is the one on the field. Warren is a "hope for a goal-line plunge" play, and that’s a risky bet to make with your season on the line.
Wide Receivers: Weather and Matchups
This is where sit em start em week 16 fantasy football gets tricky because of the elements.
Start: DeVonta Smith, Eagles (at Commanders)
AJ Brown and Dallas Goedert have been the focus lately, which has left Smith in a bit of a statistical drought. That ends Saturday. Washington gets destroyed by slot receivers—allowing a league-high 98 yards per game to the position. Smith spends 60% of his time in the slot. It’s a "get-right" spot if I’ve ever seen one.
Sit: Deebo Samuel, 49ers (at Colts)
This feels gross to type. But look at the data. The Eagles and Colts have both been stifling slot WRs lately. Deebo is still a beast, but he’s dealing with a specific defensive scheme that funnels everything away from the middle where he thrives. If you have a high-upside alternative like Rashid Shaheed (who is finally clicking in Seattle), I’d actually consider the pivot.
🔗 Read more: Formula One Next Race: Why the 2026 Season Opener in Melbourne Changes Everything
The Chicago Problem
Packers at Bears on Saturday night. It’s going to be freezing. We’re talking temps in the mid-20s. While the wind isn't "hurricane status," it’s enough to make deep balls a lottery. Christian Watson is "questionable" with a chest issue. If he’s out, Jayden Reed becomes a target monster, but the efficiency might suck.
Tight Ends: The Only Position That Matters?
If you don't have Travis Kelce, you're basically throwing darts at a board while blindfolded.
- Kyle Pitts (Falcons): He finally did it. 45.6 fantasy points last week. He’s the top target for Kirk Cousins right now with Drake London banged up. Against Arizona’s bottom-tier defense? You have to play him.
- Colby Parkinson (Rams): Davante Adams is dealing with a hamstring. The Rams are using more 13-personnel (three tight ends). Parkinson has seen his target share climb every single week for a month. He’s the ultimate "I need a streamer" play.
Defense and Special Teams: The "Free" Points
Most people ignore D/ST until Saturday night. Don't be that person.
- Houston Texans vs. Raiders: Kenny Pickett is starting for Vegas. The Raiders offense is a dumpster fire. They give up sacks at the highest rate in the NFL. Houston has "week-winner" written all over them.
- New York Giants vs. Vikings: J.J. McCarthy is playing better, but he still takes way too many sacks. The Giants have recorded multiple sacks in four straight. If you're desperate, they're a viable floor play.
What Really Happens With "Expert" Projections
The biggest mistake people make with sit em start em week 16 fantasy football is following projected points like they're gospel. Projections don't account for "vibes"—but they also don't account for mid-game benchings or sudden weather shifts.
Take the Dolphins-Bengals game. It's 80 degrees in Miami. Quinn Ewers is starting for the Dolphins. The Bengals' defense is historically bad against tight ends. Logic says Darren Waller should feast. But logic doesn't account for a rookie QB getting "happy feet" and dumping the ball to a check-down back 15 times.
Actionable Steps for Your Weekend
Check the Saturday inactives early. Since we have a slate of Saturday games (Eagles-Commanders, Packers-Bears, Bills-Browns), your flex spot needs to be flexible.
- Move your Saturday players into the RB/WR slots. Keep that Flex spot open for Sunday or Monday players. If a late-breaking injury happens Sunday morning, you want the freedom to plug in anyone, not just a specific position.
- Watch the Green Bay injury report. If Josh Jacobs is out, Emanuel Wilson is a top-15 RB start. Period.
- Don't overthink the weather. Unless the wind is sustained over 20 mph, elite QBs like Josh Allen usually handle it fine. The "cold" matters more for old-school kickers than it does for modern passing attacks.
Monitor the final injury reports for Tee Higgins and Christian Watson on Saturday morning to ensure you aren't starting a "decoy" who plays three snaps and heads to the bench.