Sit ups for beginners: Why your core workout isn't working and how to fix it

Sit ups for beginners: Why your core workout isn't working and how to fix it

Let's be real. Most people think they know how to do a sit up because they were forced to crank them out in third-grade gym class while a coach blew a whistle in their ear.

It’s the classic move. You lock your fingers behind your head, yank your neck toward your knees, and hope for the best. Honestly? That’s exactly how you end up with a strained neck and a lower back that feels like it’s been through a trash compactor. If you’re looking into sit ups for beginners, you need to forget almost everything you saw in those 1990s fitness videos.

Doing it right is actually harder than doing it fast.

Most beginners fail because they rely on momentum or their hip flexors rather than their actual abdominal muscles. It’s a common trap. When you swing your arms or hook your feet under a heavy couch, your "six-pack" muscles—the rectus abdominis—basically take a nap while your hips do the heavy lifting. We want to change that.

The anatomy of why sit ups for beginners actually matter

If you look at the research from experts like Dr. Stuart McGill, a world-renowned spine biomechanist, there is a lot of debate about the traditional sit up. McGill famously pointed out that repetitive spinal flexion (bending the back) can put significant pressure on your intervertebral discs. This doesn’t mean sit ups are "bad." It just means they require a level of precision that most beginners ignore.

Your core isn't just one muscle. It's a complex system.

Think of your torso as a cylinder. You have the rectus abdominis (the front), the obliques (the sides), and the transverse abdominis, which acts like a deep internal corset. When you start sit ups for beginners, the goal is to teach these muscles to work together without letting your spine take the brunt of the force.

You've probably heard that planks are better. In many ways, they are. But the sit up still has a place in functional fitness because it mimics the "getting out of bed" movement. It's a foundational human pattern.

Stop pulling your neck

This is the biggest mistake. Period.

When you lace your fingers behind your head, you instinctively pull. This creates "forward head posture" and puts massive stress on the cervical spine. Instead, try grazing your temples with your fingertips or crossing your arms over your chest. It feels weirder at first because you can't "cheat" your way up, but your neck will thank you.

Another thing: keep your feet flat. If you feel like your feet are flying off the floor, you're likely using your hip flexors (the muscles at the top of your thighs) to pull yourself up. This is usually a sign that your abs aren't quite strong enough for the full range of motion yet. That is totally fine.

The "Crunch" vs. The "Sit Up"

People use these terms interchangeably. They shouldn't.

A crunch involves lifting just your shoulder blades off the floor. It’s a small, controlled movement that targets the upper abs. A sit up is a full-range movement where your chest comes all the way toward your thighs. For a beginner, starting with a crunch is often smarter. It builds the mind-muscle connection. You learn what it feels like when your abs actually "fire."

  1. Lie down on your back.
  2. Bend your knees at a 90-degree angle.
  3. Exhale as you lift.
  4. Inhale as you lower.

Wait, the breathing is actually the most important part. If you hold your breath, you create internal pressure that can actually push your abdominal wall outward—the opposite of what you want. You want to "exhale the air out" to allow your ribs to drop and your core to engage deeply.

Let’s talk about the "Hip Flexor Takeover"

Ever notice how your thighs get tired during an ab workout? That’s the hip flexor takeover.

The psoas muscle connects your spine to your femur. When you do a sit up, especially if someone is holding your feet down, the psoas does the bulk of the work. The problem? A tight psoas pulls on your lower spine. This is why many beginners complain of lower back pain after a workout.

To fix this, try the "Janda Sit Up." It’s a technique named after Dr. Vladimir Janda. Basically, you try to pull your heels toward your butt without actually moving them. This activates the hamstrings. Because of a biological principle called reciprocal inhibition, when your hamstrings turn on, your hip flexors are forced to relax. This leaves your abs to do 100% of the work. It’s much harder. You might only be able to do three.

That’s good. Three perfect reps beat fifty "cheated" ones any day.

A realistic routine for the first two weeks

Don't do sit ups every day. Muscles need recovery. Your core is no different than your biceps or your quads.

📖 Related: Can non identical twins have different fathers? The Science of Heteropaternal Superfecundation

Monday: Focus on form. Do 3 sets of 8 reps. Go as slow as possible. Count to three on the way up and three on the way down.

Wednesday: Try the "Dead Bug" exercise instead. Lie on your back, arms up, legs in the air at 90 degrees. Lower the opposite arm and leg. This stabilizes the spine so your next round of sit ups is safer.

Friday: Back to sit ups for beginners, but try the "Butterfly" version. Put the soles of your feet together and let your knees fall open. This position naturally deactivates the hip flexors, forcing your core to take over.

Common myths that need to die

"Sit ups burn belly fat." Nope.

You cannot spot-reduce fat. Doing a thousand sit ups won't give you a visible six-pack if there’s a layer of fat over the muscle. Body composition is handled in the kitchen and through total-body movement. Sit ups build the muscle underneath.

"You need to do high reps." Also no.

If you can do 50 sit ups easily, you aren't doing them right. You're likely using momentum or your back. Increase the difficulty by slowing down or adding a tiny weight to your chest, rather than just adding more and more reps.

"Your back should be perfectly flat." Actually, a slight natural curve is fine, but you want to avoid "arching" into a bridge. Think about pressing your belly button down into the floor before you start the movement.

When to stop immediately

Pain is a signal, not a challenge.

If you feel a sharp, stabbing pain in your lower back, stop. If you feel a "clicking" in your hip, adjust your foot position. If your neck feels like it’s being strained, you’re pulling with your arms.

Beginners often ignore these signs because they want to finish the set. Don't be that person. Your spine is a non-renewable resource. Treat it with some respect.

The surface matters more than you think

Don't do these on a hard hardwood floor. Your tailbone will hate you. Use a yoga mat or a thin carpet. However, don't use a bed. A bed is too soft and won't provide the resistance your spine needs to stay stable.

👉 See also: The Magic Pill: Why This Polarizing Documentary Still Sparks Health Debates

If you find the floor too difficult, start on a slight incline. Some gyms have slant boards. These can actually be adjusted to make the movement easier or harder depending on which way you're facing.

Progressive overload: What comes next?

Once you've mastered the basic sit ups for beginners, you'll get bored. Your body will adapt.

You can move to:

  • Weighted Sit Ups: Holding a 5lb plate against your chest.
  • V-Sits: Lifting your legs and torso simultaneously to form a "V" shape.
  • Bicycle Crunches: Adding a rotational element to hit the obliques.

But honestly? Most people never actually "master" the basic sit up because they stop focusing on the tension. Even elite athletes can find a basic sit up challenging if they focus on maximal voluntary contraction—basically, squeezing the muscle as hard as possible during the entire move.

Actionable steps for right now

If you’re sitting at your desk or on your phone, you can start preparing for your first set right now.

First, practice the "Brace." Imagine someone is about to poke you in the stomach. You naturally stiffen. That stiffness is what you need during a sit up.

Next, check your hip mobility. Sit on the floor and see if you can keep your feet flat with your knees bent without falling backward. If you can't, you might have tight hamstrings or a weak lower back. Start stretching your hip flexors (the lunge stretch is great for this) before you attempt your workout.

Finally, commit to a "Quality Over Quantity" mindset.

  • Set a timer for 2 minutes. * Do as many perfect sit ups as you can. * If you feel your form slipping, stop and rest for 10 seconds. * Record that number. Next week, don't try to do more sit ups. Try to do the same amount with even more control. That is how you actually build a core that looks good and, more importantly, functions well.

The journey from a beginner to someone with a rock-solid core isn't about doing the most; it's about doing the best. Stop yanking your neck. Start breathing. Turn your abs on. That's the whole "secret" right there.