You’ve probably seen them grouped together in a crossword puzzle, a trivia night, or maybe just floating around in your head after a late-night Shakespeare binge. Slug frog newt bat. It sounds like the start of a very strange joke or a recipe for something you definitely shouldn't eat.
Honestly, it’s a weird collection of critters. One is a slimy invertebrate, two are amphibians that can’t decide if they like land or water better, and one is a furry mammal that flies with its hands.
Why do we link them?
Usually, when someone mentions these four together, they are tapping into a deep-seated cultural memory of the "Witches' Brew" from Shakespeare’s Macbeth. But if you look closer, there is a fascinating intersection of biology, folklore, and even modern gaming (hello, NYT Connections) that keeps this quartet in our collective consciousness.
The Macbeth Connection: Why We Blame Shakespeare
If you ever had to suffer through high school English, you know the scene. Three witches standing around a bubbling cauldron in a dark cave. They aren't just making soup.
They are tossing in "Eye of newt and toe of frog, wool of bat and tongue of dog." While "slug" isn't in that specific couplet, it often gets lumped in by association because, let's face it, slugs fit the "slimy and gross" vibe the Weird Sisters were going for.
It’s Not Actually Animal Parts (Mostly)
Here is the kicker that most people get wrong: the witches probably weren't animal abusers. In old-school herbalism, these "gross" names were actually code for plants.
- Eye of newt? That was likely just mustard seed.
- Toe of frog? Usually referred to buttercup leaves.
- Wool of bat? That’s holly leaves, which are prickly like bat fur.
It makes sense. If you were an herbalist or a "witch" back in the day, you used nicknames to protect your recipes—sort of like how Coca-Cola keeps its formula a secret today. But the imagery stuck. We see a slug frog newt bat lineup and we immediately think of dark magic and bubbling pots.
The Biology of the "Gooey Four"
Outside of a cauldron, these animals actually share some pretty interesting real-world real estate. If you’ve ever gone for a hike in a damp, temperate forest—think the Pacific Northwest or a soggy morning in England—you’ve likely stepped over at least three of these in a single mile.
The Slug and the Frog: A Predator's Snack
Did you know frogs and toads are basically the cleanup crew for your garden? Common frogs (Rana temporaria) absolutely love eating slugs.
Slugs are 96% water and covered in a thick, hygroscopic mucus. Most animals hate the texture, but a hungry frog doesn't care. Interestingly, slug slime is currently being studied by medical researchers. According to the New York Almanack, the way slug mucus adheres to wet surfaces has inspired new types of surgical glues that could literally patch a hole in a human heart.
Newts and the Tetrodotoxin Trap
Newts are the "cool cousins" of the frog. While they look harmless, some species, like the Rough-skinned Newt, are walking biological weapons. They secrete tetrodotoxin—the same stuff found in pufferfish.
If a dog or a large bird tries to eat one, it’s game over. It's ironic that Shakespeare put them in a pot; in reality, the newt is probably the most dangerous thing in that cave.
Bats: The Outlier?
The bat seems like the odd one out here. While the others are tethered to the mud and the damp earth, the bat takes to the sky. But ecologically, they are all connected. Bats are insect-eating machines. In a healthy wetland or forest ecosystem, you have the slug eating the plants, the frog and newt eating the insects (and the slugs), and the bat sweeping the air for mosquitoes.
It’s a perfect, albeit slightly slimy, circle of life.
Why This Grouping is Trending Again
If you’ve been frustrated lately by a certain 16-word grid on the New York Times website, you aren't alone. The grouping of slug frog newt bat recently made a splash in the Connections game.
Puzzles like this rely on "red herrings." You see "slug" and you think of "hitting someone" (to slug them). You see "bat" and you think of baseball. But the real connection—the "Blue" or "Purple" category level—usually points back to that Shakespearean brew or a general "witchy" theme.
👉 See also: Finding Nail Ideas on Pinterest That Actually Work for Your Real Life
It’s a testament to how deeply these specific animals are ingrained in our heads as a set. We don't group "slug, eagle, lion, and dolphin." It just doesn't feel right. There’s a specific "damp and mysterious" energy that links our four friends together.
Folklore and the "Ick" Factor
Culturally, we've been conditioned to find these creatures a bit repulsive. In medieval Europe, frogs and toads were often viewed as "familiars" or companions to witches. Bats, being nocturnal and living in caves, were naturally associated with the underworld.
But this "ick factor" is mostly just bad PR.
- Slugs are vital decomposers. They turn rotting leaves into soil.
- Frogs are "indicator species." If the frogs in your local pond start disappearing, it means the water is toxic. They are the canary in the coal mine for the environment.
- Bats save the US agricultural industry billions of dollars every year by eating pests that would otherwise destroy crops.
We might joke about them being ingredients for a curse, but honestly, we’d be in big trouble without them.
Practical Insights: How to Help Your Local "Witchy" Wildlife
If you want to support these animals (and maybe keep them out of your own "cauldron"), there are a few simple things you can do in your own backyard.
- Build a "Log Hotel": Both newts and frogs need damp, dark places to hibernate during the winter. A pile of old wood in a corner of your yard is like a 5-star resort for them.
- Stop Using Slug Pellets: Most commercial slug killers are toxic to the frogs and hedgehogs that eat the slugs. If you kill the slugs with poison, you might accidentally kill the frog that was coming to help you for free.
- Put Up a Bat House: If you have a mosquito problem, a bat house is a much better solution than a bug zapper.
- Check the Water: If you have a garden pond, make sure it has a "ramp" or a shallow edge. Frogs and newts need to be able to climb out easily so they don't drown.
The next time you hear the phrase slug frog newt bat, don't just think of a spooky poem or a difficult word game. Think of the damp, hidden corners of the world where these four very different creatures are busy keeping our ecosystems running.
Whether they are mustard seeds or actual animals, they’ve earned their place in history—and in our puzzles.
Next Steps for Nature Lovers:
Take a look at your local wildlife trust's guide on identifying amphibians. Identifying a "Smooth Newt" versus a "Palmate Newt" is a great way to start noticing the small details in your local environment. If you’re feeling ambitious, you can even record your sightings on apps like iNaturalist to help scientists track population shifts in real-time.