You're standing in your dated bathroom, eyeing that cramped 1990s alcove tub, and thinking it's finally time. You want the luxury of a deep soak—the kind where the water actually covers your knees—but you don't have the real estate for a separate walk-in shower and a standalone pedestal tub. This is where most people start looking into soaking tubs with shower combinations. It sounds like the perfect compromise, right? Honestly, it usually is, but if you don't pay attention to the literal inches, you end up with a high-walled tripping hazard that's a nightmare to clean.
Most "standard" tubs are about 14 inches deep. That’s a shallow puddle. A true soaking tub needs to be at least 17 to 20 inches deep to actually feel like a spa. But here is the kicker: when you add a shower to a deep tub, you are changing the physics of how you enter and exit that space every single morning.
The Reality of Depth and Entry Heights
Standard tub-shower inserts are built for efficiency, not comfort. When you pivot to a soaking tub with shower setup, you're usually looking at a "soaker" depth. Brands like Kohler or American Standard have specific models, like the Archer or the Cambridge, that try to bridge this gap. The problem? The rim height.
If you buy a tub with a 21-inch external height so you can have 18 inches of water, you have to lift your leg over that 21-inch wall every time you want to rinse off your hair. For a 6-foot-tall person, that’s a minor inconvenience. For someone with knee issues or a shorter gait, it’s a genuine safety concern. This is why "integrated" systems are becoming the go-to for high-end renovations.
Designers like Kelly Wearstler often lean into the "wet room" concept to bypass this. Instead of a tub with a curtain, you put a deep soaking tub inside a glass-enclosed shower area. It’s a floor-level entry into the shower zone, and then you step into the tub once you’re already "inside" the shower. It’s sleek. It’s expensive. It’s also the only way to get a deep soak without the awkward "hurdle" move every morning.
Material Science: Why Cast Iron Isn't Always King
You’ve probably heard that cast iron is the "best" because it holds heat. That’s only half true. Cast iron is a massive heat sink. When you pour hot water into a cold cast iron soaking tub, the metal actually steals the initial heat from the water. You have to let it warm up.
Acrylic and fiberglass are the lighter, cheaper cousins. People knock them for feeling "plasticky," but modern high-end acrylics (often reinforced with stone resin) are actually better at keeping water warm from the jump. Plus, if you’re installing a soaking tub with shower on a second floor, you need to calculate the weight. A cast iron tub filled with 60 gallons of water plus a 200-pound human can easily exceed 800 pounds. Your floor joists might need reinforcing. Don't skip the structural check. It’s a boring way to spend money, but it beats having your tub end up in your kitchen.
👉 See also: Why Formal Half Up Half Down Hair Is Still The Best Choice For Weddings
The Splash Factor and the Glass Dilemma
Traditional shower curtains are fine, I guess. They're cheap. You can toss them in the wash. But they're also a literal magnet for mildew when they're tucked into the corners of a deep tub. If you're going for a soaking tub with shower, you probably want glass.
Here is the catch: fixed glass panels look amazing in photos, but they are a pain in the neck if you actually use the tub. Try reaching around a fixed glass panel to turn on the water without getting your arm soaked. It sucks. If you go the glass route, look for a "hinged" splash guard. It gives you that high-end hotel look but swings out of the way so you can actually reach the faucets.
Pressure Balance and Temperature Control
When you have a deep tub, you’re filling it with a lot of water. If you have a standard 1/2-inch supply line, it’s going to take forever to fill. We’re talking 15 to 20 minutes of waiting while your "hot" water starts to cool down.
If you're doing a full gut-reno, talk to your plumber about 3/4-inch lines. It’s a niche upgrade, but it doubles the flow rate. Also, make sure your shower valve is "pressure-balanced." There is nothing worse than being mid-soak and having the water temperature spike because someone started the dishwasher. Moen and Delta both have "Posi-Temp" or "Monitor" valves that handle this, but you have to make sure the trim kit is rated for the higher flow needed for a deep tub.
Making the Layout Work in Small Squares
Most American bathrooms are 5x8 feet. That’s the "golden ratio" of tract housing. In that space, your soaking tub with shower is almost certainly going to be an alcove installation (three walls touching the tub).
- The Integral Flange: This is non-negotiable. If you're putting a shower over a tub, the tub must have an integral tiling flange. This is a raised lip on the edges that go against the wall. It prevents water from seeping behind the tile and rotting your studs. Never, ever use a drop-in tub for a shower setup unless you’re using a specialized waterproofing kit like Schluter-Kerdi.
- The Overflow Drain: Look for "slotted" overflows. Traditional round overflows sit about 2-3 inches below the rim. That’s 3 inches of wasted soaking depth. Slotted overflows sit much higher, letting you fill the tub nearly to the brim.
- Ceiling Height: If you raise the floor of the tub to accommodate a deeper soak, you are moving your head closer to the ceiling. If you’re 6'2" and you put in a deep tub, your head might hit the showerhead. Always measure from the bottom of the tub's interior to the showerhead arm.
The Maintenance Nightmare Nobody Mentions
Deep tubs have more surface area. More surface area means more soap scum. If you choose a tub with a textured "non-slip" bottom—which is legally required in many jurisdictions for shower combos—it's going to catch every bit of grime.
I’ve found that stone resin tubs are the easiest to keep clean because they’re non-porous. Acrylic is okay, but it scratches if you use abrasive cleaners. Stick to a daily spray-down or you'll be spending your Saturday mornings scrubbing a 20-inch wall.
Also, consider the "reach." If the tub is 32 or 36 inches wide, can you actually reach the back corner to clean the tile? If not, you’re going to need a handheld shower attachment. Honestly, a handheld wand is a requirement for any soaking tub with shower combo anyway. It makes rinsing the tub (and yourself) about ten times easier.
Actionable Steps for Your Renovation
Before you tear out the old tile, do these three things:
- The Sit Test: Go to a showroom. Sit in the tub. If you feel like your knees are in your chest, it’s not a soaker. If the backrest angle is too vertical, you won't be able to relax. Look for an angle around 25 to 30 degrees.
- Check Your Water Heater: A standard 40-gallon tank is not enough for a 60-gallon soaking tub. You’ll run out of hot water before the tub is half full. If you're upgrading the tub, you might need to upgrade to a 50-gallon tank or a tankless heater like a Rinnai.
- Measure the Doorway: This is the most common mistake. People buy a massive 22-inch deep tub and then realize it won't fit through the 24-inch bathroom door. Measure the narrowest point of entry before you click "buy."
The combo of a soaking tub with shower is a space-saving miracle when done right. It gives you the utility of a daily shower and the luxury of a Sunday night soak. Just don't compromise on the plumbing or the entry height, or you'll end up with a "luxury" feature that feels like a chore.
Focus on the internal depth versus the external height. Ensure your floor can handle the weight of cast iron if that’s your preference. Always verify the tiling flange exists for water mitigation. If you prioritize these technical details over the aesthetics of the faucet, the end result will be a space that actually functions as well as it looks in the brochures.