You know that feeling when you hear a song and it feels like a warm blanket, but also kinda like a punch to the gut? That’s the Rodgers and Hammerstein effect. Specifically, it’s the magic behind the Some Enchanted Evening musical revue.
It’s not a traditional "book" musical. You aren’t going to see a helicopter land on stage or a phantom lurking in the rafters. Instead, it's a slick, sophisticated celebration of the songs that basically invented the modern Broadway DNA. Honestly, calling it a "revue" almost feels too clinical. It’s more like a masterclass in how to write about the human heart without being totally cheesy.
Richard Rodgers and Oscar Hammerstein II were the undisputed kings of the Golden Age. Think Oklahoma!, South Pacific, The Sound of Music, and The King and I. These guys didn't just write catchy tunes; they tackled racism, war, and class struggle while everyone else was still writing about "boy meets girl" in a soda shop. The Some Enchanted Evening musical gathers the best of that catalog into one evening that somehow feels both nostalgic and weirdly relevant to our current messy lives.
What Actually Happens in Some Enchanted Evening?
Let's get one thing straight: there isn't a plot.
If you're looking for a linear narrative where a farm hand falls in love with a girl in a bonnet, go watch Oklahoma! directly. This show is different. It’s a conceptual revue, usually featuring five performers—two men and three women—who cycle through the greatest hits of the R&H library.
The beauty of this format is that it strips away the costumes and the heavy sets. You’re left with the raw power of the lyrics. When you hear "Some Enchanted Evening" sung outside the context of Emile de Becque on a South Pacific island, it changes. It becomes a universal truth about that split-second moment when you meet a stranger and your whole life shifts.
It’s intimate. It’s also surprisingly fast-paced. One minute you’re laughing at the playful wit of "Stepsisters' Lament" from Cinderella, and the next, you're genuinely moved by the quiet desperation of "Hello, Young Lovers."
The pacing is wild. It moves from high-energy ensemble numbers to solitary, heartbreaking solos. Most productions use minimal staging—maybe a piano, some elegant evening wear, and a few stools. This puts the pressure squarely on the performers. They can't hide behind a spinning barricade. They have to act the song. And that’s where the "enchantment" actually comes from.
Why the Music Still Ranks So High
People sometimes dismiss Rodgers and Hammerstein as "old-fashioned." They’re wrong.
Take a song like "Carefully Taught." In 1949, it was incredibly controversial because it called out systemic racism. Hammerstein was a visionary who used the theater as a pulpit for social justice, but he did it with a melody you could hum on the way home. The Some Enchanted Evening musical includes these deeper cuts alongside the massive hits.
🔗 Read more: Who Played Who: The Cast of The Nun and Why They Look So Familiar
The Genius of the "I Want" Song
Before every Disney princess had an "I Want" song, Rodgers and Hammerstein perfected it.
- The Sound of Music: Maria wants to find where she belongs.
- The King and I: Anna wants to bridge two totally different worlds.
- South Pacific: Nellie wants to believe in a love that defies her upbringing.
When these songs are grouped together in a revue, you start to see the patterns. You see how they used music to explore psychological depth. It’s not just "I’m happy." It’s "I’m happy but I’m also terrified of what this means for my future." That’s the nuance that keeps these shows alive in community theaters and professional houses decades later.
The Challenge for Modern Performers
Singing this stuff is hard.
Seriously. Ask any musical theater major. Rodgers wrote melodies that require a legit vocal technique—think soaring soprano lines and resonant baritones—but Hammerstein’s lyrics require a conversational, "actor-first" approach. If you just stand there and sing beautifully, you’ve failed. You have to tell the story.
In the Some Enchanted Evening musical, the cast has to switch personas every three minutes. One performer might play the innocent Laurey one second and the worldly-wise Mrs. Mullins the next. It’s a marathon of emotional agility.
A Note on the "Revue" vs. the "Jukebox"
Don't confuse this with a jukebox musical. A jukebox musical takes existing pop songs and tries to wedge them into a brand-new plot (think Mamma Mia! or & Juliet). A revue like Some Enchanted Evening doesn't pretend to be a play. It is a curated gallery of art.
It was originally conceived by Jeffrey B. Moss. He understood that the R&H catalog is so vast that you could create fifty different versions of this show and never run out of material. The standard version includes about 35 songs. That’s a lot of music packed into two hours.
Why You Should Care Now
We live in an era of "concept" musicals and high-tech spectacles. Those are great, but there's something restorative about hearing a perfectly constructed AABA song structure.
There's a reason South Pacific and Carousel keep getting massive Broadway revivals. The themes are timeless. The Some Enchanted Evening musical serves as a gateway drug for younger audiences who think old musicals are boring. When you hear the "Soliloquy" from Carousel in a cabaret setting, you realize it’s basically an eight-minute psychological thriller about a guy who realizes he’s going to be a father and has no idea how to be a good man.
It’s heavy stuff disguised as "classic" music.
Common Misconceptions
Some people think a revue is just a concert. Not quite.
A good production of Some Enchanted Evening uses the transitions between songs to suggest relationships between the performers. There are unspoken stories happening in the background. A look shared during a duet or a supportive hand on a shoulder during a ballad creates a "world" for the show, even without a script.
Practical Insights for Theater-Goers and Directors
If you’re thinking about seeing a local production or—even better—producing it yourself, keep these things in mind:
For the Audience: Don't expect a story. Expect an emotional journey. Listen to the lyrics. Hammerstein was a poet who obsessed over every syllable. If you find yourself getting bored, stop looking at the stage and just listen to the orchestration. It’s surprisingly complex.
For Directors and Producers:
The biggest mistake you can make with the Some Enchanted Evening musical is over-staging it. You don't need a massive set. You need five incredible singers who can act their faces off.
- Focus on the "Why": Why is this character singing "The Surrey with the Fringe on Top" right now? Even without the plot of Oklahoma!, the singer needs a motivation.
- Diversity of Sound: Ensure your cast has distinct vocal colors. You don't want five people who sound exactly the same. You need the contrast between a bright, "beltier" voice and a classic "legit" sound.
- Keep it Moving: Revues live and die by their transitions. If the energy drops between songs, you’ve lost the audience.
The Actionable Next Steps:
🔗 Read more: DWTS Week 2 Scores: What Really Happened on One-Hit Wonders Night
If you want to dive deeper into this specific corner of musical theater history:
- Listen to the "A Grand Night for Singing" Recording: This is another R&H revue that’s similar to Some Enchanted Evening. Comparing the two shows how different directors interpret the same material.
- Read "The Rodgers and Hammerstein Encyclopedia": It sounds dry, but it’s actually a goldmine of trivia about how these songs were written.
- Check Licensing Sites: If you’re a performer, look at the song list for the Some Enchanted Evening musical on the Concord Theatricals website. It’s basically the ultimate "what should I sing for my audition?" cheat sheet.
- Watch the 1950s Film Adaptations: To truly appreciate the "unplugged" version of these songs in the revue, you have to see the original, bloated, Technicolor versions of the shows they came from.
The brilliance of Rodgers and Hammerstein isn't that they wrote "old" music. It's that they wrote human music. As long as people are falling in love, feeling like outcasts, or hoping for a better world, these songs are going to be relevant. The Some Enchanted Evening musical is just a really efficient way to experience all those feelings in one sitting.