Five years have passed. The dust from the Goon Squad’s digital collapse has settled, and frankly, we’re still arguing about it. Space Jam: A New Legacy didn't just drop into theaters and HBO Max in July 2021; it exploded like a glitter bomb in a library. People were angry. People were nostalgic.
A lot of folks were just plain confused.
You’ve probably heard the standard take: "It was a two-hour long HBO Max commercial." Or maybe you’re in the "LeBron can’t act" camp. Honestly, looking back at the 163 million dollars it raked in against a 150 million dollar budget, it's easy to label it a "commercial disappointment" and move on. But that’s a bit lazy. If you actually dig into why LeBron James Space Jam 2 (as the internet insists on calling it) hit the way it did, you find a weird, messy intersection of corporate ego and genuine family heart.
Why the Michael Jordan Comparisons Miss the Point
Stop. Just stop. Comparing LeBron’s performance to Michael Jordan’s 1996 outing is a fool's errand. They aren't even trying to do the same thing. Jordan was playing a myth—a man who could fly. LeBron James in A New Legacy is playing a tired dad. He’s trying to be a "helicopter parent" who realizes he's crushing his son’s dreams. It’s actually a much heavier lift acting-wise, even if the "Notorious P.I.G." rap battle made you want to crawl under your seat.
Let's talk about that acting for a second. LeBron won a Razzie for Worst Actor. Ouch.
But was he really that bad?
In Trainwreck (2015), he was a comedic revelation. In Space Jam, he’s often stiff, sure. He looks like he’s staring at a tennis ball on a green screen—because he was. But the "King" isn't a trained thespian; he’s an athlete-mogul. The movie’s director, Malcolm D. Lee, swapped out Terence Nance early in production because the "vibe" wasn't right. That kind of behind-the-scenes chaos usually bleeds onto the screen. It did here.
The real difference? Jordan’s movie was about the Looney Tunes needing a Savior. LeBron’s movie was about LeBron needing to be Saved by his son. That’s a fundamentally different narrative structure that many fans, blinded by 90s nostalgia, simply didn't want to accept.
The "Serververse" and the IP Problem
Warner Bros. went full "Ready Player One" with this thing. You’ve got the Iron Giant, the Flintstones, and—for some reason—the Droogs from A Clockwork Orange standing in the crowd. It’s a lot.
Some call it "weaponized nostalgia."
I call it a fascinating museum of corporate acquisitions. The movie basically says, "Look at all the toys we own!" While the original 1996 film was essentially a giant Nike ad, this sequel was an ad for an entire streaming ecosystem.
- The Visuals: They ditched the classic 2D for 3D CGI halfway through. This was... controversial. Bugs Bunny with fur textures? Kinda creepy.
- The Stakes: It wasn't about "getting your talent back" like the Monstars. It was about literally being deleted from existence.
- The Cameos: That Michael B. Jordan fake-out? That was actually a top-tier troll move by the writers. You have to respect the audacity.
The Lola Bunny Controversy: Much Ado About Nothing?
Remember the internet meltdown over Lola Bunny’s redesign? People were genuinely furious that a cartoon rabbit was "less sexy."
Director Malcolm D. Lee wanted her to be "proportional" and a leader. Zendaya took over the voice acting from Kath Soucie, giving Lola a more grounded, cool-headed vibe. Looking back, the outrage feels like a fever dream. The movie had bigger issues than the length of a rabbit’s shorts—like the fact that it was nearly two hours long.
🔗 Read more: Why Nuck If You Buck Still Runs the Club Twenty Years Later
In a world where Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse exists, the "multiverse" or "serververse" concept in A New Legacy feels a bit clunky. It lacks the artistic soul of the newer animation heavyweights. But for a kid in 2021 stuck at home during the tail end of a pandemic? It was a colorful, loud distraction that actually featured some decent basketball logic—well, until the "style points" and "multipliers" started happening.
What Actually Happened at the Box Office?
Don't let the "flop" narrative fool you entirely. Yes, the movie didn't make a billion dollars. But it opened to 31.1 million dollars domestically, which actually beat the original's opening weekend (not adjusted for inflation).
It was the "best opening for a family film" during the pandemic era for Warner Bros. at that point.
The problem was the second-week drop. A 69% plunge is a "get the lights on your way out" kind of number. The simultaneous release on HBO Max definitely cannibalized the theater tickets. Why pay 15 bucks for a bucket of popcorn when you can watch LeBron get dunked on by a digital werewolf from your couch?
The Legacy of the "New Legacy"
So, does it ruin LeBron’s "GOAT" status? No. Does it ruin the original Space Jam? Also no.
It exists as a weird time capsule of 2021 culture. It shows a superstar at the peak of his off-court power trying to bridge the gap between "Global Brand" and "Relatable Human."
If you’re planning to rewatch it, here’s how to actually enjoy it:
✨ Don't miss: Fast and Furious 10 Cars: What the Movies Got Right (and Totally Faked)
- Skip the first 20 minutes. The setup is a bit of a slog. Get to the Looney World stuff.
- Look at the background. The real fun is spotting the random WB characters. Finding Pennywise next to Scooby-Doo is a trip.
- Focus on Don Cheadle. He is clearly having the time of his life as Al-G Rhythm. He understood the assignment: go big or go home.
Basically, Space Jam: A New Legacy isn't a masterpiece. It’s a chaotic, expensive, occasionally heartwarming mess that tried to do too much. It’s a movie about fatherhood wrapped in a billion dollars of intellectual property. And honestly? That’s about as "2020s" as it gets.
If you're looking to dive deeper into the technical side of things, check out the Industrial Light & Magic breakdown of how they rendered the 3D Tunes. It’s actually incredible work, even if you prefer the old-school look.
Moving forward, the best way to approach this film is to treat it like a long-form dunk contest—don't worry too much about the score, just enjoy the highlights. If you want to compare the two films fairly, try watching them back-to-back. You'll realize the original isn't quite the "Citizen Kane" you remember, and the sequel isn't quite the disaster the internet claims.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Collectors:
- Check the Secondary Market: Vintage "Tune Squad" jerseys from the 2021 release are actually becoming niche collector items, specifically the LeBron editions.
- Soundtrack Deep Dive: While it didn't have "I Believe I Can Fly," the 2021 soundtrack features Lil Baby and Kirk Franklin—it’s a solid playlist for the gym.
- Streaming Strategy: If you're a parent, this is a "background movie." It’s designed for kids to watch while playing with something else. Don't try to sit through it like it's Oppenheimer.