Basketball in Queens is different. It’s gritty. It’s loud. For decades, the St. John's Red Storm wasn’t just a team; it was the pulse of New York City hoops, a program that defined Big East toughness from the days of Lou Carnesecca to the heights of Chris Mullin. But then, things got quiet. Real quiet.
Honestly, the last twenty years for the Red Storm felt like a long walk through a desert. Coaching changes, recruiting misses, and the shifting landscape of college athletics left the Johnnies looking like a relic of the past rather than a powerhouse of the future. You’ve seen it happen to other legacy programs, where the weight of history starts to feel more like an anchor than a sail. But right now, something is shifting at Carnesecca Arena and Madison Square Garden. It isn't just about winning games anymore. It’s about cultural relevance.
With Rick Pitino at the helm, the Red Storm is suddenly the loudest thing in the room again. Love him or hate him, Pitino brings a level of tactical obsession and sheer theater that the program has lacked since the 1980s. But is this just a flashy short-term fix, or is the Red Storm actually back?
The Heavy Weight of the 1985 Ghost
To understand where the Red Storm is going, you basically have to understand where they’ve been. In 1985, St. John’s reached the Final Four. Think about that for a second. It was the peak of the Big East’s golden era. Chris Mullin, Bill Wennington, and Mark Jackson weren’t just college players; they were icons of the city. The problem is that for a kid entering college today, 1985 feels like the Stone Age.
The program struggled for a long time to find an identity that resonated with the modern era. The transition from the "Redmen" moniker to the "Red Storm" in 1994 was supposed to be a fresh start, but the results on the court were a mixed bag of NCAA tournament appearances and long stretches of mediocrity. Coaches like Mike Jarvis had their moments, but the consistency just wasn't there. Then came the Steve Lavin era—lots of hype, some decent wins, but no deep runs. After that, the Chris Mullin homecoming felt like a movie script that unfortunately ended in a rewrite. Then Mike Anderson brought a frantic "40 Minutes of Hell" style that worked... until it didn't.
Now, the program is leaning into the "New York's Team" branding harder than ever. It’s a bold claim in a city with millions of distractions, but the Red Storm is the only high-major program actually located in the five boroughs. That matters for recruiting.
✨ Don't miss: What Is The Current Super Bowl Score: The Result That Stunned New Orleans
The Pitino Factor: More Than Just X’s and O’s
When Rick Pitino took the job, everyone knew the basketball would get better. The guy is a Hall of Famer for a reason. His defensive schemes—that relentless, ball-pressure matchup zone—are legendary. But what most people get wrong about Pitino’s impact on the Red Storm is that it’s not just about what happens during the 40 minutes of game time.
It’s about the infrastructure. It’s about NIL (Name, Image, and Likeness) collectives. Pitino arrived and immediately started demanding upgrades to everything from the practice facilities to the way the school engages with big-money boosters. He’s essentially acting as a CEO, not just a coach. He understood that in 2026, you can't win on history alone. You need a war chest.
He basically gutted the roster in his first year. It was ruthless. He brought in a fleet of transfers, looking for "dogs" who could handle the pressure of playing under the bright lights of MSG. Some people thought it was too much too fast, but Pitino isn't interested in a five-year rebuild. He’s 70-plus years old. He’s in a hurry.
The Big East Isn't the Same Neighborhood Anymore
The Big East is a weird, beautiful beast. It survived the conference realignment chaos of the early 2010s by doubling down on basketball. No football. Just hoops. For the Red Storm, this is both a blessing and a curse.
On one hand, they aren't getting overshadowed by a massive football program. On the other hand, the neighborhood is tougher than ever. UConn is a back-to-back national champion juggernaut. Marquette is a model of modern efficiency. Creighton has a system that's nearly impossible to scout.
💡 You might also like: Mariners Game Time Today: Why Everyone Is Searching for Baseball in January
- UConn: The gold standard.
- Villanova: Post-Jay Wright, they are still a threat but searching for a new soul.
- Providence: A blue-collar rival that always plays the Red Storm tough.
- Georgetown: The other "sleeping giant" trying to wake up under Ed Cooley.
When St. John's plays at the Garden, it's the best atmosphere in college basketball. Period. But the Red Storm has to win those games. You can't be "New York's Team" if you're losing to Creighton at home by fifteen. The rivalry with Georgetown is particularly interesting right now because both schools are trying to reclaim their 80s glory at the exact same time. It’s a race to see who can become relevant first.
Recruiting the Five Boroughs and Beyond
For years, the "fence around NYC" was broken. The best players from Brooklyn, the Bronx, and Queens were leaving for Kentucky, Duke, or even Rutgers. It was painful for local fans to watch.
The Red Storm is finally starting to make inroads again, but the strategy has changed. It’s no longer just about the local high school star. It’s about the transfer portal. Pitino has mastered the art of finding the "disgruntled high-major player" or the "mid-major breakout" and bringing them to Queens.
Take a look at the roster composition over the last two seasons. It’s an eclectic mix of veteran guards and athletic wings. They play fast. They gamble on steals. They make you uncomfortable. That’s the brand. If you come to play for the Red Storm, you aren't just joining a team; you're joining a 24/7 reality show where the expectations are sky-high and the margin for error is razor-thin.
Why the Garden Still Matters
There’s a lot of debate about whether St. John’s should play more games at Carnesecca Arena (on campus) versus Madison Square Garden (the world's most famous arena).
Carnesecca is loud, cramped, and intimate. It’s a true home-court advantage. But MSG is the stage. To be a national brand, the Red Storm needs the Garden. They need the celebrities courtside. They need the subway commuters catching a 7:00 PM tip-off.
The split schedule is a delicate balance. If they play too many games in Queens, they feel like a small-time program. If they play too many at MSG and the seats are empty, it looks depressing on TV. The current administration seems to have found a sweet spot, saving the "big" games—the Big East battles—for Manhattan while keeping the non-conference slate in Queens. It keeps both the alumni and the students happy, mostly.
The NIL Reality: Keeping the Storm Brewing
Let's talk about the elephant in the room: money. In the current era of college sports, "culture" is important, but NIL is the engine. The Red Storm has benefited from a surprisingly robust donor base that finally woke up.
Wealthy alumni who remember the glory years are opening their wallets because they see a winner at the helm. This has allowed St. John's to compete for top-tier talent that previously would have been out of reach. It’s a cycle. Winning brings donors, donors bring players, players bring winning.
The "St. John's Red Storm" brand is being marketed more like a professional team than a college one. You see the merch everywhere now. You see the social media clips going viral. It’s a coordinated effort to make sure that when a recruit thinks of New York basketball, they don't just think of the Knicks or the Nets—they think of the Johnnies.
Tactical Nuance: The Press and the Pace
If you watch a Red Storm game today, you'll notice they don't really let you breathe. It's not the old-school "40 Minutes of Hell" exactly, but it's a sophisticated version of it. They use a "deflection" chart—a Pitino staple. If the team doesn't hit a certain number of deflections, they hear about it. Loudly.
The offense is built on spacing and quick decisions. They aren't looking to grind out 30-second possessions. They want to turn your turnover into a layup in three seconds. It’s an exhausting way to play, which is why Pitino often plays a deep bench. You'll see 10 or 11 guys getting minutes in the first half just to keep the pressure high.
What Most Fans Get Wrong
A lot of people think that just because Pitino is there, the Red Storm will automatically be in the Final Four. That's not how it works in the modern Big East. The floor has been raised, but the ceiling is harder to hit.
The real measure of success for this program isn't a single deep tournament run. It's being "in the conversation" every single year. It's being a top-25 mainstay. It's making the NCAA tournament five years in a row. That’s how you build a sustainable program. One-off Cinderella runs are fun, but the Red Storm is aiming for blue-blood status.
Future Outlook: The Next Steps for the Johnnies
The trajectory is clearly pointing up, but there are hurdles. The Big East's TV deal, the ever-changing NCAA rules, and the sheer volatility of the transfer portal mean that nothing is guaranteed.
👉 See also: NY Giants Football Score: What Really Happened This Season
However, the Red Storm has something most programs don't: a clear identity. They know who they are. They are the tough, pressing, New York-centric team that's going to make your life miserable for 40 minutes.
If you're looking to follow the program or want to see what the hype is about, here is how you should engage with the Red Storm right now:
- Watch a game at the Garden: If you can, go in person. The energy when the Big East tournament rolls around or when a top-10 team comes to town is unmatched.
- Monitor the Transfer Portal: The Red Storm is very active here in the spring. This is where their seasons are often won or lost before they even start.
- Follow the "Deflections": When watching, don't just look at the score. Look at how many times St. John's players get their hands on the ball defensively. That's the best indicator of whether they are playing "Pitino ball."
- Check the KenPom Rankings: For the analytics nerds, this is the best way to see if the Red Storm is actually improving or just riding a wave of luck. Look for their "Adjusted Defensive Efficiency" to be in the top 30 nationally.
The Red Storm isn't a finished product. It's a work in progress, but for the first time in a generation, the progress is visible. New York basketball is better when St. John's is good. The Big East is better when St. John's is good. And right now, the Johnnies are finally making a lot of noise.