The end of an era is always messy. When the news broke that the Superman and Lois cast was getting gutted for its fourth and final season, fans (myself included) kind of lost it. How do you make a show about Smallville without the people who live there?
It felt like a gut punch. Budget cuts at The CW meant that seven—yes, seven—series regulars were demoted to guest stars or recurring roles. We went from a massive ensemble to basically just the Kent family and a very bald, very angry Lex Luthor.
But honestly? That forced focus might be the best thing that happened to the show.
The Core Four: Holding the Fortress Together
Tyler Hoechlin and Elizabeth Tulloch aren't just playing Clark and Lois; they’ve become the definitive versions for a lot of people. Hoechlin’s Clark has this dorky, sincere "dad energy" that makes you forget he can move moons. Then you have Bitsie Tulloch, who brought a raw, terrifyingly real vulnerability to Lois, especially during that Season 3 cancer arc.
They stayed. Obviously. You can't have the show without them.
📖 Related: Why Bustin' Loose by Chuck Brown Still Runs the Streets of DC
But the real pressure landed on the kids. Alex Garfin (Jordan) and Michael Bishop (Jonathan) had to carry way more weight this time around. Bishop, who took over for Jordan Elsass in Season 3, really found his footing as the "human" son who suddenly wasn't so human anymore. Seeing Jonathan Kent finally manifest powers in Season 4 was the payoff we’d been waiting for since the pilot.
The Lex Luthor Factor
While everyone was mourning the loss of the supporting cast, Michael Cudlitz was busy becoming the most terrifying Lex Luthor we’ve seen in years. He didn't just show up; he took over. Moving him to a series regular was a genius move.
Cudlitz plays Lex with this simmering, blue-collar rage. He isn't the shiny billionaire in a penthouse; he’s a man who spent years in prison rotting because of Lois Lane’s reporting, and he wants blood. His presence turned the final season into a psychological thriller as much as a superhero show.
🔗 Read more: Luke Bryan’s Sunrise Sunburn Sunset Lyrics: Why They Hit Different After All These Years
What Happened to Everyone Else?
This is where things got tricky. To keep the lights on for ten final episodes, the production had to let go of the "regulars" status for:
- Wolé Parks (John Henry Irons)
- Tayler Buck (Natalie Irons)
- Emmanuelle Chriqui (Lana Lang)
- Erik Valdez (Kyle Cushing)
- Inde Navarrette (Sarah Cortez)
- Sofia Hasmik (Chrissy Beppo)
- Dylan Walsh (Sam Lane)
Initially, there was a lot of drama. Dylan Walsh’s wife even posted on social media that he wouldn’t be back at all because of the way the offer went down. Thankfully, we still got Sam Lane in a pivotal role—and that "sacrifice" scene? Man, it hit hard.
Lana and the Cushings felt more like "Special Guest Stars" popping in for a cup of coffee. It was weird seeing the Smallville mayor only appear in a handful of scenes, but it prevented those "filler" storylines that used to bog down the mid-season. No more town council meetings when Doomsday is literally killing God in the street.
Why the Leaner Cast Changed the Game
The "bloated" cast was a common complaint in earlier seasons. Don't get me wrong, I love Lana Lang, but did we really need forty minutes of her divorce drama while Bizarro Superman was rampaging through a portal?
Probably not.
The final season’s smaller roster meant every minute had to count. We got more intimate scenes in the Kent farmhouse. We got to see the boys actually deal with the trauma of their father’s "death" (and eventual return) without the show cutting away to a fire department subplot.
📖 Related: Why the Taylor Swift Album Cover Showgirl Aesthetic is Actually Just a Tortured Poets Variant
The Guest Stars and Surprise Cameos
Even with a skeleton crew, the showrunners managed to bring back familiar faces for the curtain call. Tom Cavanagh—yes, the Arrowverse legend—showed up, though not as the Reverse Flash. Having him direct and appear was a nice "meta" nod to the universe this show outlived.
We also saw Yvonne Chapman return as Amanda McCoy, Lex’s right hand, who honestly deserves her own spinoff. She brought a cold, corporate menace that balanced out Cudlitz’s raw brutality.
A Legacy Beyond the Budget
The Superman and Lois cast did something impossible: they made a CW show feel like a $200 million movie. Even when the money dried up and the cast list shrunk, the performances stayed top-tier.
If you're looking to revisit the series or jumping in for the first time, pay attention to the shift in Season 4. It’s a masterclass in how to tell a massive story with very few people. It’s intimate, it’s heartbreaking, and it proves that you don't need a dozen series regulars to make a show feel "super."
To really appreciate the evolution of these characters, go back and watch the Season 1 pilot immediately followed by the Season 4 finale. The growth in Hoechlin’s performance—from a hesitant father to a man facing his own mortality—is one of the best arcs in DC history. Grab the Blu-ray sets or stream the final episodes on Max to see the contrast for yourself.