Jeff Probst loves a theme. Honestly, some of them are a bit of a stretch—I’m looking at you, Worlds Apart—but when Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers dropped in 2017, it actually tapped into something real about how we view ourselves. It wasn't just about jobs. It was about identity.
The show's 35th season took us back to Fiji, specifically the Mamanuca Islands, and split 18 strangers into three tribes based on their perceived "dominant" traits. Were they courageous (Heroes), compassionate (Healers), or just relentlessly gritty (Hustlers)? It sounds simple. It wasn't.
The Breakdown of the Tribes
The Levu Tribe (Heroes) were defined by high-stress jobs and a supposed moral compass. Think Ben Driebergen, a Marine veteran, or Chrissy Hofbeck, an actuary. The show framed them as people used to being looked up to. But here’s the thing: being a "hero" in the real world is a massive target in a game about deception. They started with this burden of expectation that didn't always mesh with the cutthroat reality of Fiji.
Then you had the Soko Tribe (Healers). These were the folks like Dr. Mike Zahalsky or Roark Luskin. They were supposed to be the "caretakers." Interestingly, this tribe became a massive threat early on because they were just too good at sticking together. They had this internal bond that terrified the others.
Finally, the Yawa Tribe (Hustlers). These were the grinders. Ryan Ulrich, the bellhop who became a strategic powerhouse, and Ali Elliott. They were the people who had to work twice as hard to get half as far. In Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers, the Hustlers often felt like the scrappy underdogs, which is a dangerous narrative to let someone carry into the merge.
👉 See also: Screen Actor Guild Winners: Why This Year's Ballot Changed Everything
The Controversy That Changed the Game Forever
We have to talk about the fire-making twist. If you ask any hardcore fan about this season, they won’t talk about the "Healer" mentality or the "Hero" spirit. They’ll talk about the final four.
For 34 seasons, the final four worked a certain way. You vote. One person goes home. Done. But in Season 35, the game shifted beneath the players' feet. Ben Driebergen, who had played an incredibly loud, idol-heavy game, was the clear target. He lost the final immunity challenge. He was gone. Or he should have been.
Instead, Chrissy Hofbeck—who won that final challenge—was informed of a new "advantage" that was actually a massive disadvantage for her. She had to pick one person to take to the end, while the other two fought it out in a fire-making challenge. Ben won the fire. Ben won the game.
The backlash was instant. Fans felt the "Heroes" narrative was being forced by production. Whether you believe it was a "fix" or just a poorly timed twist, it fundamentally altered Survivor strategy. Now, every player knows that the "Final Four Fire-Making" is a permanent fixture. You can't just vote out the big threat at the end anymore. You have to beat them with a flint and a piece of steel.
Why the Social Dynamics Were So Weird
The social politics of this season were fascinatingly messy. You had Chrissy, a brilliant strategist who was often criticized for being "cold," a classic double standard that female players frequently face. She played a "Heroic" game by the numbers—winning four individual immunities—but the jury didn't connect with her the way they did with Ben’s "Hustle."
And what about the Healers? They got absolutely decimated at the merge. It was a literal "Healer-cide." Because they entered the merge with the most numbers, the Heroes and Hustlers put aside their differences to wipe them out. It’s a classic lesson in Survivor history: entering the merge with a clear majority is often a death sentence. You're too visible.
The Legacy of the "Hustler" Mentality
What Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers really showed us is that labels are mostly nonsense once the hunger sets in. Ryan Ulrich didn't play like a "Hustler" in a physical sense; he played like a chess grandmaster. Devon Pinto, a surfer dude labeled a "Hustler," ended up being one of the most low-key brilliant social players the show has ever seen.
The season proved that your "archetype" is just a starting point. The players who survived the longest were the ones who could transcend those labels. Ben used his "Hero" background to build trust, but he used "Hustler" tactics to find three consecutive idols.
Key Takeaways for Future Players
If you're ever heading out to the island—or just trying to navigate a corporate office—there are actual lessons here:
👉 See also: What Really Happened With Trump, Larry David, and the SNL Heckle
- The "Middle" is the safest place to be. The Healers were too strong, so they died first. The Heroes were too prominent, so they became targets. The Hustlers, specifically Ryan and Devon, controlled the flow because people underestimated them.
- Adapt to the "New Era" mindset. This season was the bridge to the current "faster" game. You have to assume there is a twist you don't know about. If you're relying on a simple majority vote at the final four, you’ve already lost.
- Visibility is a currency. Ben spent his currency on idols. Chrissy spent hers on immunity necklaces. In the end, the jury valued the "struggle" of the idols over the "dominance" of the necklaces.
- The Jury's perception is the only reality. It doesn't matter if you think you're a Hero. If the jury thinks you're a villain, you're a villain.
Actionable Insights for Fans and Aspiring Players
Don't just watch for the challenges. Watch the camp life in the episodes leading up to the merge. In Season 35, the small conversations between Devon and Ryan early on set the stage for the entire endgame.
If you're analyzing the game, look for the "swing" votes. In this season, the people who moved between the labels—the ones who weren't "too much" of any one thing—lasted the longest. Ben was the outlier because he found a mechanical way to bypass the social game (idols), but that's a high-variance strategy that rarely works twice.
To truly understand Survivor: Heroes vs. Healers vs. Hustlers, you have to look past the branding. It wasn't a battle of professions. It was a study in how people react when the rules they've relied on for thirty days suddenly vanish in the fire of the final four.