Walk into a Target on a Tuesday morning and you’ll notice it. The red carts are there, the Starbucks is brewing, and the Bullseye’s Playground is stocked with five-dollar seasonal trinkets. But something is off. There are fewer people bumping into each other in the pajama aisle. This isn't just a vibe or a localized fluke; Target foot traffic decline has become a legitimate headache for the Minneapolis-based retail giant.
Retail is a brutal game of numbers. For years, Target was the "cool" older sister of Walmart—the place where you’d go for one thing and leave with a $200 receipt and a sense of accomplishment. Lately, that magic has hit a snag. According to data from firms like Placer.ai, which tracks mobile pings to measure how many humans actually step foot in a store, Target saw significant dips in visits throughout 2023 and early 2024. While they've clawed back some ground, the trajectory isn't the straight line up that investors crave.
Why? It’s not just one thing. It's a messy cocktail of inflation, shifting consumer habits, and some very public PR stumbles that didn't sit well with certain demographics. People are picky now. They have to be.
The High Cost of "Target Runs"
Money is tight. It’s the elephant in the room that no amount of clever marketing can hide. When the price of eggs and bread skyrocketed, the "Target Run" became a luxury many families had to audit.
✨ Don't miss: Walmart Current Stock Price: What Most People Get Wrong
Target leans heavily into discretionary spending. Think about it. You go to Walmart because you need laundry detergent and cheap milk. You go to Target because you want a new throw pillow, a Magnolia-branded vase, and maybe a cute sundress. When inflation eats into disposable income, the "wants" are the first thing to get chopped from the budget.
Target’s CFO, Michael Fiddelke, has been transparent about this in earnings calls. He's noted that consumers are being "incredibly resilient" but also "purposeful" with their spending. "Purposeful" is corporate-speak for "they aren't buying the extra stuff." If you aren't buying the extra stuff, you might just order your essentials on Amazon or pick them up at a discount grocer like Aldi instead of making the trek to the big red bullseye.
The Pride Month Backlash and Its Real-World Impact
We have to talk about the 2023 Pride collection. Regardless of where anyone stands politically, the business impact was undeniable. Target faced a massive wave of backlash regarding some of its LGBTQ+ merchandise, leading to confrontations in stores and a coordinated boycott.
This wasn't just online chatter.
Foot traffic data showed a measurable cooling off during the summer of 2023. CEO Brian Cornell later acknowledged that the company had to adjust its approach to ensure guest and team member safety. But the damage to the "brand halo" was real. For a company that prides itself on being the inclusive, trendy alternative to "boring" big-box stores, getting caught in the crosshairs of the culture war was a lose-lose situation. It alienated long-time fans on one side and angered conservative shoppers on the other.
✨ Don't miss: Setting Up Online Payment for Small Business: What Most People Get Wrong
When you give people a reason not to come in, they usually find somewhere else to go. Habit is a powerful thing in retail. Once a shopper breaks their weekly Target habit, getting them back is twice as expensive.
The Rise of "Boring" Essentialism
People are tired. Seriously. There is a growing trend of consumers prioritizing speed and utility over the "treasure hunt" experience that Target pioneered.
- The Curbside Revolution: Target’s "Drive Up" service is arguably the best in the business. It’s fast. The employees are usually great. But there's a catch. If I buy my paper towels and Gatorade through the app and have someone put them in my trunk, I am—by definition—not walking through the store. That is a 100% decline in foot traffic for that transaction. Target is cannibalizing its own floor traffic to save its sales figures.
- The "Dupe" Culture: TikTok is obsessed with finding cheaper versions of Target-style goods at Five Below or on Temu. The exclusivity of Target’s in-house brands like Good & Gather or All in Motion is being challenged by a global supply chain that brings "trendy" to your doorstep for half the price.
- Safety and Shrink: It’s an uncomfortable topic, but retail theft (or "shrink") and safety concerns have affected traffic in certain urban markets. Target shuttered nine stores in 2023, citing theft and organized retail crime as a threat to the safety of workers and shoppers. When a store feels chaotic or has half its inventory behind plexiglass, the "joy" of the Target run evaporates.
Can the Bullseye Bounce Back?
Target isn't sitting still. They’ve announced plans to launch or renovate hundreds of stores over the next few years. They are leaning into larger formats that can handle more e-commerce fulfillment while still offering a decent browsing experience.
They are also doubling down on "Newness." The recent partnership with Diane von Furstenberg and the expansion of Ulta Beauty shops inside Target locations are desperate, yet calculated, attempts to give people a reason to actually park their cars and walk through the front doors.
But honestly? The competition is fiercer than ever. Walmart has cleaned up its act, improving its private-label quality to compete with Target’s "Greatest Hits." Meanwhile, Amazon’s same-day delivery makes a 15-minute drive to Target feel like a chore.
Real Solutions for a Changing Retail World
If Target wants to fix the foot traffic problem, it has to move beyond just being a "pretty version of Walmart." It needs to solve the friction points that make people choose the couch over the cart.
Focus on the "Third Place" Vibe
Target used to be a destination. To get people back, they need to lean into the experiential side. More in-store events, better cafe integrations beyond just a basic Starbucks counter, and interactive displays that can't be replicated on a smartphone screen.
Price Perception vs. Reality
Target has a "pricey" reputation that isn't always fair. They need to be louder about their value. The "Dealworthy" brand, which launched with hundreds of items under $10, is a start. But they have to prove to the budget-conscious mom that she isn't paying a "style tax" just to shop in a cleaner building.
Personalization Overload
The Target Circle app is good, but it can be better. Using data to offer "in-store only" rewards that trigger when a customer is nearby could bridge the gap between digital browsing and physical visiting.
Mastering the "Small-Format" Store
Not every neighborhood needs a massive warehouse. The smaller, boutique-style Target stores in college towns and dense urban areas are the future of foot traffic. They fit into the daily flow of life rather than requiring a dedicated "trip."
Actionable Steps for Retail Observers and Investors
If you’re tracking this trend—whether as a competitor, a retail worker, or an investor—keep your eyes on three specific metrics. First, look at the "attachment rate" of curbside pickups. If people are picking up orders but never entering the store, Target’s high-margin impulse sales will continue to crater. Second, watch the "comparable store sales" specifically for discretionary categories like home decor and apparel. If those don't recover, the foot traffic decline is permanent, not cyclical.
Finally, pay attention to the store layout changes. Target is currently experimenting with moving their "Dollar Spot" and changing how the pharmacy area looks. These aren't random. They are calculated moves to force your eyes onto high-margin products the second you walk in.
The era of the "mindless Target wander" might be over, replaced by a more surgical, price-sensitive way of shopping. Target has to decide if it's okay being a glorified warehouse for app orders, or if it can still be the place where we all go to buy things we didn't know we needed.
👉 See also: WTW Q1 2025 Earnings: What Most People Get Wrong
Logistically, Target's infrastructure is built for high-volume physical browsing. If the aisles stay quiet for too long, the red-and-white empire will have to undergo a much more painful transformation than just a few store closures. They need the crowds. They need the noise. Most importantly, they need you to put that extra candle in your cart.
Next Steps for Businesses Facing Similar Declines:
- Audit your "Digital-to-Physical" Pipeline: Ensure your online presence incentivizes in-store visits via "pick up in store" coupons that are only valid for additional items purchased at the counter.
- Focus on High-Touch Categories: Invest in departments that require physical interaction—fitting rooms that don't suck, beauty consultations, or tech demos.
- Review Safety Protocols: Transparency about store safety is no longer optional; if shoppers feel uneasy, they will default to home delivery every single time.
- Evaluate Pricing Tiers: Introduce an "entry-level" private label to capture the inflation-strained demographic without diluting your premium in-house brands.