If you were anywhere near a card shop or an eBay search bar in early 2021, you know the fever. People were treating a Tatis Jr baseball card like it was a blue-chip tech stock. The 2019 Topps Series 2 base rookie in a PSA 10 slab was hitting $300. It was pure madness. Fast forward to early 2026, and that same card has been through a blender, a scandal, and a position change.
Honestly? Most people are still looking at these cards the wrong way. They see the price drop from the "COVID boom" as a sign of failure, but if you actually dig into the numbers, the story is way more interesting. Tatis is still one of the most electric players in the game, yet his market is currently behaving like a sleepy utility man's. It’s a weird disconnect.
✨ Don't miss: GA vs Tenn Score: What Really Happened in That Overtime Thriller
What Actually Happened to the Market?
Let's talk about the "Free Fall" everyone mentions. On March 20, 2021, a PSA 10 of his flagship rookie (#410) peaked at over $310. By August 2025, you could snag one for about $11. That's a 96% haircut.
You've got to understand why. It wasn't just the 80-game PED suspension in 2022 or the wrist injuries from the motorcycle accidents. It was the sheer volume. PSA has graded nearly 20,000 copies of that 2019 Topps #410 in a Gem Mint 10. That's not a rare card. It’s a commodity. When the "investors" fled the hobby, they dumped these by the truckload.
But here’s the thing: Tatis is still putting up numbers. He’s a multi-time All-Star, a Gold Glove winner in the outfield, and still hits for massive power. While the base cards cratered, the high-end stuff—the 2016 Bowman Chrome autos and the low-numbered refractors—has actually shown some grit.
🔗 Read more: Who Sings Monday Night Football Theme: The Truth Behind the New 2026 Anthem
The Cards That Still Command Respect
If you’re looking for the stuff that actually matters in a long-term collection, you have to look past the base paper.
- 2016 Bowman Chrome Prospect Autograph (#CPA-FT): This is the holy grail. It’s his first "true" card with an MLB logo. A PSA 10 base refractor version of this still fetches four figures because it’s the definitive "first" card.
- 2019 Topps Chrome Sapphire (#410): This is the high-end version of his flagship rookie. It’s got that cracked-ice finish and a much lower print run. It’s basically the "luxury" version for people who want the iconic image without the massive population count of the base set.
- 2025 Topps Home Field Advantage (#HA-10): A newer favorite. These are "case hits," meaning they are incredibly tough to pull. Even in early 2026, a PSA 10 of this card can go for over $150, which is wild considering it’s not even a rookie card. It proves that collectors still love the guy's "swag" and visual appeal.
Tatis Jr Baseball Card: The Rookie Card Minefield
If you're hunting for a rookie, you’re going to run into about fifty different options. It’s confusing. 2019 was a year where Topps and Panini went absolutely overboard with sets.
The 2019 Topps Series 2 #410 is the one everyone knows. It’s the "flagship." But collectors often overlook the 2019 Topps Heritage (#517). It uses the 1970 Topps design and is much harder to find in a perfect grade because of those sensitive edges and corners.
Then you have the Panini stuff, like Donruss Optic. These look cool, but they don't have the MLB team logos because Panini doesn't have the license. You'll see Tatis in a generic "San Diego" jersey. Some people hate it; others don't care because the "Rated Rookie" logo is so iconic. Personally, I think the "logo-less" cards are a tougher sell long-term, but they are great for budget collectors.
Comparing the "Big Three" Rookies
- Topps Series 2 #410: The gold standard for "common" collectors. High volume, high liquidity.
- Topps Chrome #203: The "shinier" version. Usually holds a premium over the paper version. A PSA 10 currently hovers around $25, which is a steal compared to three years ago.
- Bowman Chrome #26: Not his first Bowman (that's the 2016), but his first "Rookie" labeled Bowman. It's sort of the middle child of the hobby.
Why the "PED Discount" Might Be Over
Is he tainted forever? Maybe for the Hall of Fame voters, but the hobby has a short memory for anyone who keeps hitting 450-foot home runs. Look at Alex Rodriguez or Barry Bonds. Their high-end rookies still sell for a fortune.
👉 See also: Why the Real Madrid squad 2016 remains the most terrifying team in modern football history
Tatis is young enough that he could play another 12 seasons. If he hits 400 home runs and stays in the spotlight in San Diego, the "stain" of 2022 will eventually just be a footnote in his biography. We’re already seeing it. His 2025 Topps Chrome "Murakami" variations and "Superfractor" image variations are still selling for $700 to $950 raw. That’s not "dead player" money. That’s "superstar" money.
Actionable Tips for Collectors Right Now
If you're looking to pick up a Tatis Jr baseball card today, don't just buy the first thing you see on eBay. The market is nuanced.
First, stop buying base cards as "investments." They aren't. They are cool to have in a binder, but with a population of 20,000, they will never be scarce. If you want value, look for "numbered" parallels—anything where the card literally says "12/50" or "05/99" on the back.
Second, watch the grading slabs. SGC and CGC have become more popular lately, but PSA 10s still carry the biggest price premium. If you find an SGC 10 or a BGS 9.5 for significantly less than a PSA 10, that’s usually where the value is. The card is the same; the plastic is just different.
Finally, keep an eye on the "short prints." In the 2025 sets, Tatis has several variations where he’s wearing different uniforms or in different poses. These are much rarer than the standard cards and tend to hold their value better during the off-season.
Check the back of any 2019 card you buy for the "RC" logo. If it doesn't have it, it might be a 2018 or 2017 prospect card, which is a different market entirely. Stick to the 2016 Bowman Chrome for prospect value or 2019 Topps for rookie value.
The smartest move right now is targeting the "mid-tier" rarities—the Chrome Refractors or the Rainbow Foils—rather than the $10 base cards or the $5,000 1-of-1s. That's where the most stable part of the Tatis market lives.