Honestly, if you were a baseball fan in October 2016, you probably aged about a decade in three weeks. It wasn't just another playoffs. It was a collision of history, hexes, and some of the most stressful relief pitching ever televised. Looking back at the 2016 MLB postseason bracket, you see a path that seems almost scripted, yet it felt chaotic every single night.
We had the Chicago Cubs. A 108-year drought. A goat. A black cat. A fan named Steve Bartman who just wanted a foul ball. Then you had the Cleveland Indians (now the Guardians), who hadn't won since 1948 themselves. It was a "something has to give" scenario that lived up to every bit of the hype.
People forget how the bracket actually laid out before the madness started. It started with a bang in the Wild Card games, and by the time Rajai Davis hit that home run in Game 7 of the World Series, the original bracket was basically a piece of confetti.
How the 2016 MLB Postseason Bracket Shook Out
The bracket was split between the blue-blooded powerhouses and the "it’s finally our year" underdogs. In the American League, the Texas Rangers took the top seed with 95 wins. They were supposed to be the team to beat. Behind them were the Cleveland Indians and the Boston Red Sox. Over in the National League, the Cubs were the absolute juggernaut. They won 103 games. They were the favorites from the day spring training started in Mesa.
The Wild Card games set a frantic tone. In the AL, the Toronto Blue Jays hosted the Baltimore Orioles. That game ended on an Edwin Encarnación walk-off homer in the 11th inning that nearly took the roof off the Rogers Centre. It's still remembered for Buck Showalter leaving Zach Britton—the best closer in baseball that year—in the bullpen while Ubaldo Jiménez got lit up. A total head-scratcher.
💡 You might also like: Cal State Wrestling Rankings: Why the West Coast Grinds Harder Than You Think
On the NL side, the San Francisco Giants went into New York and beat the Mets. Madison Bumgarner threw a complete-game shutout because, well, that’s just what he did in October back then. Conor Gillaspie hit a three-run homer in the ninth off Jeurys Familia, and just like that, the "Even Year Magic" for the Giants felt very, very real.
The Division Series: Crushing Dreams Early
The ALDS was a slaughter. Most people expected the Rangers to handle the Blue Jays, but Toronto swept them. Rougned Odor—famous for punching Jose Bautista earlier that year—made a throwing error in the bottom of the 10th in Game 3 that allowed the winning run to score. Poetry, sort of.
Cleveland swept Boston. This was David Ortiz’s final season. Big Papi went out with a whimper as Cleveland’s pitching, led by Terry Francona’s aggressive use of Andrew Miller, shut down one of the best offenses in the league. Miller was a cheat code. He’d come in the fifth, the sixth, the eighth—it didn't matter.
The NLDS was where things got weird. The Cubs played the Giants. In Game 4, the Cubs were down three runs in the ninth inning. They were facing a Game 5 against Bumgarner. The season was on the brink. Then, they put together a four-run rally for the ages. Kris Bryant, Ben Zobrist, Willson Contreras, and Javier Báez all came through. It was the largest ninth-inning comeback in postseason clinch-history.
Meanwhile, the Dodgers and Nationals went the full five games. It ended with Clayton Kershaw coming out of the bullpen on two days' rest to get the final two outs in D.C. It was a rare "Kershaw is a hero in October" moment that silenced the critics for at least a few days.
The Championship Series and the Rise of the Bullpen
By the time we reached the LCS, the 2016 MLB postseason bracket had narrowed to four teams: Toronto vs. Cleveland and Los Angeles vs. Chicago.
Cleveland basically revolutionized how we think about bullpens in this series. Cody Allen and Andrew Miller were untouchable. They beat the Jays in five games. Ryan Merritt—a guy nobody had heard of—started Game 5 and threw four scoreless innings. Before the game, Jose Bautista said Merritt would be "shaking in his boots." He wasn't. Cleveland was going to the World Series despite losing two of their best starters, Danny Salazar and Carlos Carrasco, to injuries earlier in the year.
The NLCS was a heavyweight fight. The Dodgers actually led the series 2-1 at one point. People started whispering about the curse again. But the Cubs' bats woke up in Los Angeles. They outscored the Dodgers 23-6 over the final three games. Kyle Hendricks outdueled Kershaw in Game 6 at Wrigley Field. When Anthony Rizzo caught that final out from a double play, Chicago didn't just celebrate; the city exhaled.
The World Series That Broke the Internet
If you look at the 2016 bracket today, the final line reads: Chicago Cubs 4, Cleveland Indians 3. Those numbers don't do it justice.
✨ Don't miss: Reggie Miller Choking Picture: What Really Happened at the Garden
Cleveland took a 3-1 lead. They were dominant. Corey Kluber was pitching like a cyborg. But Joe Maddon’s Cubs scratched back. They won Game 5 at home. They blew out Cleveland in Game 6 behind an Addison Russell grand slam.
Then came Game 7.
It’s widely considered the greatest baseball game ever played. Dexter Fowler hit a lead-off home run. The Cubs built a 5-1 lead. It looked over. Then Maddon pulled Hendricks early and went to Jon Lester, then eventually a gassed Aroldis Chapman. Rajai Davis hit a two-run, game-tying homer in the bottom of the eighth that moved the camera because the stadium was shaking so hard.
Then, the rain.
A 17-minute rain delay before the 10th inning gave the Cubs a chance to huddle in a weight room. Jason Heyward gave a speech. They came out, scored two runs, and held on for an 8-7 win. Kris Bryant slipped on the wet grass as he threw the final out to Rizzo. It was 12:47 AM on a Thursday morning. A century of failure was deleted.
Why This Specific Bracket Matters for Today’s Game
The 2016 postseason changed how front offices build teams. You can see the "Andrew Miller Effect" in almost every playoffs since. Managers no longer wait for the ninth inning to use their best pitcher. They look for the "leverage index." If the bases are loaded in the sixth, you bring in the hammer.
It also proved that the "best team" can actually win. Usually, the MLB playoffs are a crapshoot. The 103-win Cubs were the best team all year, and they actually finished the job, though they barely escaped by the skin of their teeth.
Key Stats from the 2016 Run:
- Chicago Cubs: Ended a 108-year title drought.
- Ben Zobrist: Won World Series MVP after hitting .357 in the series.
- Andrew Miller: Struck out 30 batters in 19.1 postseason innings.
- Aroldis Chapman: Threw 42 pitches in Game 5, then came back for Games 6 and 7. His arm was basically noodles by the end.
- Attendance: Game 7 drew over 40 million viewers, the highest for a baseball game in decades.
Common Misconceptions About the 2016 Playoffs
A lot of people think the Cubs cruised because they had the best roster. They didn't. They were down 2-1 to the Dodgers and 3-1 to Cleveland. They were trailing in the ninth inning of an elimination game against the Giants. This wasn't a dominant stroll; it was a survival mission.
Another myth is that Cleveland "choked." In reality, they were playing with a decimated rotation. They were starting Josh Tomlin and Trevor Bauer (who had a sliced-open pinky from a drone accident) on short rest. The fact that they pushed the Cubs to 10 innings in Game 7 is actually a miracle of coaching and grit.
Actionable Takeaways for Baseball Historians and Fans
If you're looking to dive deeper into the 2016 MLB postseason bracket or just want to relive the glory, here is how to do it right:
- Watch "The Rain Delay" Documentary: It breaks down the 17 minutes that changed sports history. The locker room footage is legendary.
- Study the Box Scores of ALDS Game 3 (TOR vs TEX): It’s a masterclass in how small mistakes—like a missed double play—can end a 95-win season in seconds.
- Analyze Terry Francona’s Pitching Changes: If you want to understand modern baseball, look at how Cleveland used Andrew Miller in the first two rounds. It’s the blueprint for the current "opener" and "high-leverage" era.
- Check the "Elias Sports Bureau" archives: Look for the win-probability charts of World Series Game 7. It looks like a heart monitor of someone having a cardiac event.
The 2016 season remains the gold standard for drama. It had the narratives, the stars, and a bracket that didn't just break records—it broke curses. Whether you’re a Cubs fan or just a fan of the game, that October was as good as it gets.