Television is a brutal business. It’s even more brutal when you’re trying to revive a format that peaked in the 1970s. When The Alec Baldwin Show premiered on ABC in 2018, the network wasn’t just looking for another talk show; they were looking for an event. They wanted prestige. What they got instead was a masterclass in how difficult it is to transition a successful podcast into a primetime television powerhouse.
Baldwin wasn't a novice. He had been hosting Here’s the Thing on WNYC for years, building a reputation as a thoughtful, deeply prepared interviewer who could coax surprising admissions out of A-listers. But radio is intimate. TV is a spectacle. The transition was rocky from the jump.
What Really Happened With The Alec Baldwin Show
Initially, the show wasn't even called The Alec Baldwin Show. It snuck onto the schedule under the title Sundays with Alec Baldwin, airing a sneak peek after the Academy Awards. That first episode featured Jerry Seinfeld. It was smart. It was sleek. It felt like something you’d see on PBS or HBO, not necessarily the network that brings you The Bachelor.
🔗 Read more: Della Reese in Harlem Nights: The Legend Who Almost Stole the Movie From Eddie Murphy
The problem was the timing.
ABC slotted the full series into Sunday nights at 10:00 PM. That is a graveyard shift for a talk show that isn't a rowdy comedy hour. They were asking viewers to sit through an hour of intense, one-on-one conversation right before the work week started. Honestly, the vibe was just too heavy for the time slot. Baldwin sat in a leather chair, the lighting was moody, and the conversations were long.
The Ratings Nose-Dive
It didn’t take long for the numbers to get ugly. The premiere brought in about 2.1 million viewers. By the second episode, that number dipped. By the third? It was hovering around 1.5 million. In the world of major network TV, those are "pack your bags" numbers.
ABC panicked. Well, maybe "panicked" is a strong word, but they definitely pivoted. After only a handful of episodes, they yanked the show from the Sunday lineup and banished it to Saturdays. If Sunday is the graveyard, Saturday night is the afterlife. It’s where shows go to finish their run quietly so the network can fulfill its contractual obligations to advertisers.
Why the Format Felt "Off" to Modern Viewers
Most talk shows today are built for YouTube. You need a "Carpool Karaoke" or a "Mean Tweets" segment—something that can go viral in 90 seconds while people are scrolling on their phones at work. The Alec Baldwin Show rejected that entirely. It was a throwback.
Baldwin’s style is very specific. He interrupts. He shares his own anecdotes. He challenges his guests. For some, it was refreshing to see someone actually talk to Kim Kardashian or Robert De Niro like they were real people rather than just products to be sold. For others, it felt like Baldwin was talking over them.
- Guest Diversity: The lineup was actually impressive. We’re talking Ricky Gervais, Jeff Bridges, and Kerry Washington.
- The Vibe: It felt like a New York penthouse conversation.
- The Conflict: Baldwin’s own public persona—often described as "combative" or "intense"—was inseparable from the show’s brand.
When you have a host who is as famous for his off-screen outbursts as he is for his acting, the audience is always waiting for a spark. But the show was actually quite civil. It was intellectual. Maybe it was too intellectual for a 2018 audience that was already exhausted by the 24-hour news cycle.
The Controversy That Didn't Help
You can't talk about this show without talking about the timing of Baldwin's personal life. Right as the show was struggling in the ratings, Baldwin was involved in a highly publicized altercation over a parking spot in Manhattan.
The optics were terrible.
The network was trying to market a "sophisticated" talk show hosted by a man who was simultaneously appearing in tabloids for losing his cool in the West Village. It created a disconnect. You can’t easily sell a "prestige" brand when the face of that brand is dealing with legal headaches. It overshadowed the actual content of the interviews. People weren't talking about what Jeff Bridges said about his career; they were talking about whether Baldwin was going to keep his show.
Was it Actually a Good Show?
Honestly? Parts of it were excellent. If you go back and watch the interview with Erna Solberg, the Prime Minister of Norway, it's fascinating. How often does an American network talk show give 20 minutes to a Nordic head of state to discuss global policy? Almost never.
Baldwin’s strengths as an interviewer come from his genuine curiosity. He’s a student of film history and politics. When he talked to Spike Lee, the conversation went deep into the mechanics of filmmaking in a way that Stephen Colbert or Jimmy Fallon just doesn't have the time for.
But television is about more than just "good." It’s about "fit." The Alec Baldwin Show was a square peg in a round hole. It was a podcast with a lighting budget. In an era where The Masked Singer was becoming a hit, a slow-burn interview show was a tough sell.
The Technical Failure
The editing felt a bit sluggish. On the Here's the Thing podcast, the audio editing is tight. On screen, the long pauses and the close-ups of Baldwin’s thinking face felt self-indulgent to a lot of critics. The Hollywood Reporter and Variety weren't particularly kind, often noting that the show felt like a vanity project.
Whether or not that's fair is up for debate. Every talk show is a vanity project to some extent. But when the ratings are high, people call it "visionary." When they're low, they call it "ego."
Final Takeaways on the Show's Legacy
The Alec Baldwin Show officially ended after one season. It didn't change the face of television. It didn't spark a revival of the long-form interview on network TV. If anything, it served as a cautionary tale for networks: just because someone is a great actor and a great podcaster doesn't mean they can carry a primetime TV slot.
📖 Related: Why Owlbert from The Owl House is More Than Just a Cute Stick
However, it did prove that there is still a hunger for "adult" conversation. The show's failure likely pushed these types of formats exclusively toward streaming services like Netflix (think David Letterman’s My Next Guest Needs No Introduction) or Apple TV+, where the pressure for immediate ratings isn't as suffocating.
If you’re interested in the art of the interview, the episodes are still worth hunting down. They capture a specific moment in pop culture where we tried—briefly—to make network TV smart again. It didn't work, but the attempt was interesting.
How to Apply These Lessons
If you are a creator or a business owner looking at the trajectory of this show, there are a few real-world takeaways:
- Context is Everything: Your content can be brilliant, but if it's delivered at the wrong time (Sunday at 10:00 PM) to the wrong audience, it will fail.
- Platform Matters: A podcast audience doesn't always migrate to a TV screen. Respect the medium you are playing in.
- Brand Alignment: Ensure the public persona of the lead aligns with the "vibe" of the product. Conflict between the two creates friction that distracts from the message.
To see how these dynamics play out today, look at the current late-night landscape. Notice how many hosts have shifted toward shorter, punchier segments. The era of the "big chair" interview is largely over on network television, moving instead to the world of long-form independent media.
👉 See also: Goodbye Yellow Brick Road: What Elton John and Bernie Taupin Were Actually Saying
Check out the archives of Baldwin's WNYC podcast to hear the format in its most natural environment, where the lack of cameras actually allows for more honesty than the TV version ever could. The transition from audio to visual remains one of the hardest jumps to make in entertainment.