Five years ago, people were basically writing the obituary for the "big box" bookstore. It seemed inevitable. Amazon was eating the world, and walking into a Barnes & Noble felt like stepping into a cluttered warehouse of 20% off thrillers and stale coffee.
Then things changed.
The Barnes & Noble comeback retail story is now being studied by every business school in the country, but the reality is much simpler than most "experts" make it out to be. It wasn't about a better website or a new logo.
Honestly? They just started acting like a bookstore again.
Why the Barnes & Noble Comeback Retail Strategy Worked
James Daunt is the guy everyone talks about when they bring up this turnaround. He took over as CEO in 2019 after Elliott Advisors bought the company for about $683 million. Daunt had already saved Waterstones in the UK, so he had a playbook.
But his playbook was weird. Most corporate CEOs want more control, more data, and more uniformity. Daunt wanted the opposite.
He looked at the 600+ stores and realized they were "infantilizing" their staff. In the old days, a guy in an office in New York would decide that every single store in America—from Miami to Seattle—had to put the same celebrity memoir on the front table.
If the books didn't sell? They just shipped them back.
The Death of the "Co-op" Kickback
Before the Barnes & Noble comeback retail era, the company lived on "co-op" money. This is a fancy term for publishers paying the retailer to put certain books in the window or on the endcaps.
It was basically a pay-to-play system.
It made the company a lot of money upfront, but it created a terrible experience for readers. You'd walk in and see a pile of books nobody actually wanted to read, just because a publisher wrote a check.
💡 You might also like: Economy Under Biden Graph: What Most People Get Wrong
Daunt killed that. He told publishers to keep their money and told store managers to pick their own books.
Suddenly, the returns rate—the percentage of books sent back to publishers because they didn't sell—dropped from a staggering 30% to around 7% by 2024. That is a massive operational win. It saved millions in shipping and labor costs alone.
Giving Power Back to the "Book Nerds"
If you walk into the Barnes & Noble in Naperville, Illinois, or the one in the Georgetown neighborhood of D.C., you'll notice they don't look the same anymore.
One might have a massive section dedicated to World War II history because the local community buys those books. Another might lean heavily into "Romantasy" or Manga because of a local BookTok community.
This decentralization is the "secret sauce."
Store managers are now empowered to "weed out the rubbish." If a book is bad, they don't stock it. If a local author is trending, they give them a display. It sounds so basic, right? But in the world of massive retail chains, this kind of autonomy is practically unheard of.
The Expansion: 2024 to 2026
The numbers don't lie.
After a decade where they barely opened any new locations, the floodgates opened. In 2024, they opened 57 new stores. That was more than they had opened in the entire decade between 2009 and 2019 combined.
And they didn't stop.
- 2025: They hit another gear, opening approximately 67 new stores.
- 2026: The company has already announced plans for another 60 locations.
They are even moving into spaces previously occupied by their old rivals. They recently opened a store in Naperville in a space that used to be a Pottery Barn. They’re taking over old Amazon Books locations too, which is a poetic bit of irony that isn't lost on anyone in the industry.
The BookTok Tailwind
We have to talk about TikTok. Specifically, #BookTok.
Gen Z and Millennials are driving a huge chunk of this growth. Despite being "digital natives," these groups are obsessed with physical books. They want the aesthetic of a bookshelf. They want the "third space" experience of sitting in a cafe surrounded by paper.
Barnes & Noble leaned into this by creating dedicated "As Seen on TikTok" sections. Because their managers are now allowed to be agile, they can spot a viral book on Tuesday and have it front-and-center by Friday.
Amazon’s algorithms are fast, but they can't replicate the feeling of a human bookseller saying, "You liked that? You'll love this."
The IPO on the Horizon
The ultimate validation of the Barnes & Noble comeback retail success is the talk of going public again. Analysts expect a potential IPO in 2026, likely combining Barnes & Noble with its UK sibling, Waterstones.
✨ Don't miss: Why the Built to Last Book Still Provokes Arguments in Boardrooms Today
When Elliott Advisors bought B&N, many thought they were just buying a dying horse to see if they could squeeze a few last dollars out of it. Instead, they built a growth engine.
It turns out that if you treat a bookstore like a bookstore, and your employees like experts instead of shelf-stockers, people will actually show up.
Actionable Lessons from the B&N Turnaround
If you’re looking at this from a business or investment perspective, there are a few "take-home" truths that apply to more than just books:
- Kill the "Cookie-Cutter" Model: If your business has multiple locations, stop trying to make them identical. Local nuance wins every time.
- Focus on "The Thing": B&N stopped trying to be a toy store or a tech shop. They focused on being the best place to discover books.
- Trust Your Frontline: Your store managers know the customers better than your VPs in New York or London ever will. Give them the budget to take risks.
- Physical is an Advantage: Use your physical space to do what the internet can't: provide a "third space" for community and browsing.
The era of the "retail apocalypse" isn't over for everyone. But for those willing to ditch the centralized, soul-crushing corporate handbooks, there’s clearly a path back to the top.