Believe it or not, Bewitched almost didn't happen with the face we all know. Elizabeth Montgomery was already a bit of a rising star, but she wasn't exactly looking to be tethered to a sitcom for eight years. When you look back at the Bewitched cast, it’s easy to see the chemistry and the magic—literally—but the reality on that 1960s set was often way more chaotic than a simple nose twitch could fix.
The show premiered in 1964. It was a weird time for TV. People wanted escapism. They wanted to see a housewife who could solve her problems with a flick of a wrist because, honestly, the real world was getting pretty heavy. But the actors? They were dealing with everything from sudden recastings that confused the entire nation to secret battles with illness that they had to hide from the cameras.
Elizabeth Montgomery: More Than Just a Twitch
Elizabeth Montgomery wasn't just Samantha Stephens. She was the show's engine. Most people don't realize she actually played two roles, taking on the character of the wild, brunette cousin Serena under the pseudonym "Pandora Spocks." It was a clever wink to the audience, though many kids at the time didn't catch on that it was the same woman in a wig.
📖 Related: Characters in Clash of the Titans: Why the 1981 Originals Still Beat the Remakes
She was a perfectionist. You can see it in the physical comedy. Montgomery didn't actually twitch her nose; she moved her upper lip, which in turn moved her nose. It’s a subtle distinction, but it’s something she practiced until it became iconic. Off-camera, she was a powerhouse who eventually became a producer on the show, which was a huge deal for a woman in the late 60s. She pushed for the show to tackle social issues, like in the famous "Sisters at Heart" episode which dealt with racism—even if the execution feels a bit dated by today's standards.
The Two Darrins: A Mystery Solved
We have to talk about the Darrin situation. It’s the ultimate TV trivia question. Why did Dick York leave, and why did Dick Sargent step in?
Dick York was brilliant. His facial expressions were basically a masterclass in reactionary comedy. But he was in constant, agonizing pain. Back in 1959, while filming a movie called They Came to Cordura, he suffered a massive back injury. By the time he was filming Bewitched, he was addicted to painkillers just to get through the day. Eventually, he collapsed on set during the filming of the episode "Daddy Does His Thing." He had to quit. It wasn't a choice; his body just gave out.
Then came Dick Sargent.
Honestly, the transition was jarring. Sargent had actually been the first choice for the role years earlier, but he was busy with another project. When he finally took over in 1969, the "New Darrin" didn't quite have that same manic energy York brought to the table. Fans were split. Some didn't even notice—TV wasn't "bingeable" back then, so people's memories were shorter—but for the die-hards, the show changed forever. Sargent played it straighter, which changed the dynamic of the marriage.
Agnes Moorehead and the Enduring Power of Endora
If Montgomery was the heart, Agnes Moorehead was the spine. She was a serious actress. We’re talking about a woman who was part of Orson Welles’ Mercury Theatre and starred in Citizen Kane. She didn't particularly love being on a sitcom at first. She thought it was beneath her, but she grew to love the paycheck and the character’s flamboyant wardrobe.
Moorehead’s Endora was a revelation. She was the mother-in-law from hell, but with actual powers. Her disdain for "Derwood" (her nickname for Darrin) provided the friction that kept the plot moving. Interestingly, Moorehead and Dick York were incredibly close. When York left the show, she was reportedly devastated and didn't take kindly to Sargent at first. She was a pro, though. She kept that purple eyeshadow on and kept delivering those biting lines until the very end.
The Supporting Players: Neighbors and Warlocks
You can't talk about the Bewitched cast without mentioning the Kravitzes. Alice Pearce, the original Gladys Kravitz, was a comedic genius. She won an Emmy for the role, but sadly, she won it posthumously. She was dying of terminal cancer during the first two seasons, a fact she kept secret from almost everyone on the cast. She was so thin and frail, yet her energy as the nosy neighbor was unmatched. When Sandra Gould took over the role, the character became a bit more abrasive, less "confused" and more "confrontational."
And then there was Uncle Arthur. Paul Lynde brought a campy, sarcastic energy that the show desperately needed in its later years. Every time he appeared in a mirror or a hallway, you knew you were getting 22 minutes of pure gold. He was one of the few actors who could out-stage Moorehead.
The Tragic Curse Legend
There’s often talk of a "Bewitched Curse" because several cast members died relatively young or suffered great tragedies.
- Alice Pearce died at 48.
- Elizabeth Montgomery passed away at 62 from colon cancer.
- Dick York struggled with poverty and emphysema before dying at 63.
- David White (who played Larry Tate) lost his son in the Pan Am Flight 103 bombing over Lockerbie.
But "curses" are usually just a way for fans to process the sadness of losing their favorite stars. If you look at the statistics of any show from that era, the mortality rates aren't that different. It’s just that we cared about these people. They were in our living rooms every week.
The Kids: Tabitha and Adam
Erin Murphy played Tabitha, though she started the role sharing it with her twin sister, Diane. As they grew up, they stopped looking alike, so Erin took over full-time. Unlike many child stars, Erin Murphy actually had a pretty well-adjusted life after the show. She’s often the one keeping the flame alive today, showing up at conventions and sharing stories about her "TV mom."
Adam Stephens was played by David Lawrence. He didn't stay in the industry long. He’s mostly stayed out of the spotlight, which is probably a healthy choice considering how tough the child-actor-to-adult-actor pipeline can be.
Why the Magic Still Works
The show ended in 1972, not because it wasn't popular, but because it had run its course. Montgomery was tired. The scripts were starting to repeat themselves. But the legacy is huge. You see its influence in everything from WandaVision to Sabrina the Teenage Witch.
It worked because, at its core, it wasn't about magic. It was about a marriage. It was about two people from different worlds trying to make it work. Samantha wanted to be "normal," but her nature was extraordinary. Darrin wanted a "normal" life, but he fell in love with someone who could never give him that. That’s a universal story.
Real-World Takeaways for Fans
If you're looking to dive back into the world of the Bewitched cast, don't just stick to the TV show. There are layers to this story that make the viewing experience much richer.
- Watch the early Dick York seasons specifically to see the physical comedy. Knowing he was in pain makes his performance as a "human cartoon" almost unbelievable.
- Look for the Serena episodes. Montgomery’s range is on full display here. She wasn't just playing a "naughty" version of Samantha; she created an entirely different physical presence.
- Research the production design. The house at 1164 Morning Glory Circle was a real set on the Warner Bros. Ranch. It was used in dozens of other shows, including The Partridge Family.
- Check out Elizabeth Montgomery’s later work. She became the "Queen of the TV Movie" in the 70s and 80s, often playing very dark roles (like Lizzie Borden) to distance herself from the "good housewife" image.
The actors of Bewitched gave us a world where a snap of the fingers could fix a broken vase or a bad dinner party. Off-screen, they proved that real life is a lot messier, a lot harder, and requires a different kind of strength—the kind that doesn't come from a spellbook.
To get the most out of your next rewatch, pay close attention to the background characters like Marion Lorne’s Aunt Clara. Lorne was a legendary stage actress who brought a genuine, heartbreaking vulnerability to a character who was essentially a "failing" witch. It’s those human touches that keep the show relevant sixty years later.