He wears a leather-bound grin that doesn't move when he talks. It’s a terrifying, static rictus. You’ve probably seen it in your nightmares or, at the very least, on a movie poster that made you double-check the locks on your front door.
The character known as the Grabber, played with a sort of twitchy, predatory grace by Ethan Hawke in the 2022 hit The Black Phone, isn’t your garden-variety slasher. He doesn't just chase you with a knife. He plays games. He waits. Honestly, the most unsettling thing about him isn't the kidnapping—it's the way he seems to be performing for an audience only he can see.
Who is the Grabber, really?
In the film, we never actually learn his real name. He's just "him." A part-time magician with a van full of black balloons and a basement that smells like damp concrete and old fear.
Scott Derrickson, the director, took Joe Hill’s original short story and turned the villain into something much more psychologically layered. In Hill’s writing, the character was named Albert and he was a "grotesquely fat" clown, a very clear nod to the real-life monster John Wayne Gacy. But the movie shifted gears. They didn't want another Pennywise. Instead, they gave us a lean, athletic man who uses masks to externalize his fractured personality.
One day he's wearing the "happy" face. The next, he's "sad" or "blank." It’s a theatrical nightmare.
📖 Related: Who is the Seasoned with Love cast? What to know about the 2021 rom-com
The mask is the man
You can’t talk about the Black Phone Grabber without talking about those masks. Tom Savini’s studio designed them, and they are basically the MVP of the movie’s visual horror.
They aren't just for hiding his identity. He's a magician, remember? He's obsessed with the "show."
- The Grin: Used when he's feeling dominant or "playful."
- The Frown: Used when he's disappointed in his victim’s behavior.
- The Blank Face: Perhaps the scariest, because it's totally devoid of humanity.
There is a specific theory among fans—and hinted at in the film—that the Grabber wears the masks because he can't stand to look at himself. When Finney finally rips the mask off during the climax, the Grabber panics. He covers his face. He screams like a child. It’s a moment of pure, pathetic vulnerability that proves the mask was his only source of power.
The "Naughty Boy" game
The Grabber has this ritual. He calls it the "Naughty Boy" game.
He leaves the basement door unlocked. He sits at the top of the stairs with a belt, waiting for the kid to try and escape. If they do, they're "naughty," and he gets to punish them. It’s a sick, cyclical trap. It suggests that the Grabber himself was likely a victim of the same "game" when he was a child.
In one of the most chilling lines, he mentions hearing the black phone ring when he was a kid. This implies he was once held in that very same basement. He’s not just a killer; he’s a byproduct of a cycle of abuse that he’s now forcing onto a new generation of boys in suburban Denver.
🔗 Read more: Where to Catch a Flick: Movie Theaters in Zanesville and Why the Colony Square Mall is Still King
Real-life inspirations and the Gacy connection
While the movie is supernatural, the roots are firmly planted in the "Stranger Danger" era of the 1970s.
Director Scott Derrickson grew up in North Denver during that time. He’s talked openly about the "blue-collar violence" of his childhood—the constant fights, the parents who used belts, the general sense that the world was a jagged place.
But the Gacy connection is the one that sticks. John Wayne Gacy, the "Killer Clown," also had a "trick" (the handcuff trick) that he used to lure victims. The Grabber’s "magic tricks" are a direct evolution of that real-world horror.
The Grabber's fate (and the sequel)
By the end of the first film, Finney uses the advice of the Grabber’s previous victims to turn the tables. He snaps the killer's neck with the very phone cord that was supposed to be his leash.
💡 You might also like: Why Mrs Cunningham from Happy Days Was Actually the Show’s Secret Weapon
But here’s the thing: you can’t keep a good monster down.
With The Black Phone 2 confirmed for a 2025/2026 release, Ethan Hawke is returning. How? The lore suggests the Grabber’s spirit is now tied to the phone or the house. Some leaked details suggest the sequel might dive into the "winter camp" or even the Grabber’s connection to Finney and Gwen’s mother.
What you can learn from the Grabber's "Mistakes"
If you're a horror fan or a writer, the Grabber is a masterclass in how to build a villain that feels "real" despite a supernatural premise.
- Give them a "Why" (even if it's hidden): The Grabber’s trauma makes him more than a cardboard cutout.
- Use visual anchors: The masks are iconic. They make him recognizable in a crowded market.
- Break the rules: Most slashers don't talk. The Grabber talks constantly. He’s polite, then he’s a monster. That unpredictability is where the true fear lives.
Your Next Steps for The Black Phone Lore
If you want to understand the full scope of this character before the sequel hits, go back and read Joe Hill’s short story in the collection 20th Century Ghosts. It’s a quick read but much darker in its implications about the "Al" version of the character.
Then, re-watch the film and pay attention to the Grabber’s brother, Max. There’s a lot of subtext there about how the Grabber managed to hide in plain sight—a reminder that the real monsters usually live right next door.