When you talk about the 1980s, the original Caddyshack usually sits right at the top of the comedy mountain. It was lightning in a bottle. Bill Murray was hunting a gopher, Rodney Dangerfield was insulting everyone’s tie, and Chevy Chase was, well, being peak Chevy Chase. So, when the cast of Caddyshack 2 was announced in 1988, expectations were high. Or at least, they were until people actually saw the movie.
Honestly, it’s one of the most fascinating train wrecks in Hollywood history.
Most people remember the sequel as "the one without Rodney." That’s mostly true. But the story of how the production tried to replace legends with a whole new roster of talent is actually a wilder tale than the movie itself. From lawsuits to mid-production exits, the casting of this film was a desperate scramble to recapture a magic that had already left the building.
The Impossible Task: Replacing Rodney and Bill
You can’t just replace Rodney Dangerfield. The studio tried, though.
🔗 Read more: Vincent LaRusso Movies: Why the Cake Eater Still Matters in 2026
The original plan was for Rodney to return as Al Czervic. He even helped develop the script with Harold Ramis. But Dangerfield famously hated the draft, reportedly saying the jokes weren't there. He walked away, which led to a massive $10 million lawsuit from Warner Bros. Imagine being sued just because you didn't think a script was funny!
Enter Jackie Mason.
Mason was a Broadway sensation at the time, but he wasn't Rodney. He played Jack Hartounian, a wealthy developer who was basically a "copy-paste" version of the blue-collar-outsider archetype. While Mason was a brilliant stand-up, his energy was different. It felt like watching a cover band try to play a classic rock anthem—the notes were there, but the soul was missing.
Then there was the Bill Murray shaped hole in the film. Murray had zero interest in coming back. He supposedly hated the idea of a PG-rated sequel. To fill that void, the producers brought in Dan Aykroyd.
Now, Aykroyd is a legend. But his character, Captain Tom Everett, was a bizarre, high-pitched mercenary who felt like he belonged in a completely different movie. He was meant to be the "new Carl Spackler," but instead of a charmingly weird groundskeeper, we got a guy in a ghillie suit who made weird noises. It was a choice. A very strange choice.
Who Actually Made Up the Cast of Caddyshack 2?
Despite the chaos, the film actually had a pretty heavy-hitting lineup. If you look at the names on paper, it should have worked.
✨ Don't miss: Why Ouija Board Movies Still Scare Us Half to Death
- Jackie Mason (Jack Hartounian): The lead. A developer trying to get into Bushwood to please his daughter.
- Robert Stack (Chandler Young): Replacing Ted Knight’s "villain" role. Stack played it straight, which was his bread and butter, but he lacked the vein-popping hilarity of Judge Smails.
- Chevy Chase (Ty Webb): The only major returning star. He’s basically a ghost in this movie. He looks like he’d rather be anywhere else, and honestly? You can’t blame him.
- Dyan Cannon (Elizabeth Pearce): The love interest. She brought a lot of energy, but the script didn't give her much to work with beyond reacting to Jackie Mason.
- Randy Quaid (Peter Blunt): He played a high-strung, borderline psychopathic lawyer. It was one of the few parts of the movie that actually felt like it had some comedic bite.
- Jonathan Silverman (Harry): The "straight man" caddy. He did his best to ground the movie, but the plot around him was just too messy.
It’s worth noting that Jessica Lundy played Kate Hartounian, Jack’s daughter. She was the emotional core of the film, trying to navigate the snobbery of Bushwood. Also, look out for a young Chynna Phillips (of Wilson Phillips fame) playing the snobby Miffy Young.
Why the Chemistry Failed
Comedy is about timing and chemistry. The first Caddyshack was an ensemble where everyone felt like they were in the same universe. In the cast of Caddyshack 2, it felt like everyone was in a different zip code.
Chevy Chase has since admitted he only did it because he was "contractually obligated" or, more simply, for the paycheck. You can see it in his eyes. Ty Webb was a Zen master in the first film; in the second, he just seems tired.
The biggest issue was the PG rating. The original was a raunchy, R-rated flick. It had an edge. By scrubbing the sequel clean for a "family audience," the studio neutered the very comedians they hired. You can't hire Dan Aykroyd and Jackie Mason and then tell them to play it safe. It’s like hiring a Ferrari to drive through a school zone at 15 mph.
Real-World Lessons from the Bushwood Disaster
So, what can we actually learn from looking back at this cast?
First, sequels rarely work when you replace the "heart" of the original. Rodney and Bill were the heart. Without them, it was just a movie about a golf course.
Second, studio interference usually kills comedy. The fact that Harold Ramis—the man who directed the first one—tried to take his name off the sequel tells you everything you need to know. He stayed on because the studio "begged" him, fearing that his exit would ruin the opening weekend.
If you're a fan of the original, my best advice is to treat the sequel as a curious artifact of the 80s. It’s not "good" in the traditional sense, but watching Robert Stack and Jackie Mason trade barbs is a specific kind of surreal entertainment.
What to do next:
If you're feeling a bit let down by the sequel, the best remedy is to go back to the source. Re-watch the 1980 original and pay attention to the background characters—many of them were real-life caddies from the club where Brian Doyle-Murray worked. It puts the "human" back into a franchise that eventually lost its way.
Or, if you're a glutton for punishment, find the "making of" stories from Dan Aykroyd's perspective. His commitment to that weird Captain Everett voice is, if nothing else, a masterclass in staying in character even when the ship is sinking.